Posted by An Other on 25/04/2022 08:39:34:
… Sadly it seems to be a 'feature' of modern engineering that 'tuning' has to be carried out to make stuff work 'as required' – on the other hand, I have two lathes and a mill that I could never have afforded if I had got them from Western suppliers, so I had to buy 'Chinese' and do the work. …
Me too, though I didn't have to do much to my machines. But any fettling needed on these machines is only a feature of modern engineering as a consequence of the very limited amount of money hobbyists are prepared to pay for their euipment. Model Engineers have extremely short arms and keep our wallets padlocked at the bottom of a deep pocket protected by an irritable rattlesnake. We think a few thousand quid is a lot of money.
Bad mistake to believe Far Eastern hobby lathes are representative of modern machine tools. Truth is, a new industrial machine costs 6 to 20 times more than the hobby equivalent. And, Industry has moved away from general purpose tools towards specialist equipment, CNC and Machine Centres, all rarely seen in hobby-world. As a result, Model Engineers don't compare like with like, and fall into a trap labelled 'unrealistic expectations'!
If modern machine tools were no good, we wouldn't be surrounded by wonderful affordable technology. Take a £50 computer hard-drive apart and look at how accurately it's made. Then try and copy the mechanism! Hard drives aren't made in a shed by blokes with a Super 7, Tom Senior and thou micrometer! Sadly, it's unlikely any of us will ever own even the most basic Machine Centre – they're just too expensive. As a result, our understanding of machine tools is often horribly out-of-date.
My Far-Eastern gear turned out to be better than expected. Although clearly made down to a price, it does more than I need, and I'm able to make things. Hard to tell the difference between a mild-steel rod turned by me on a Chinese lathe and another made on a Colchester. The difference between machines is more to do with feel, slick operation and stamina than the individal parts they make. For the same reason clapped out old lathes in skilled hands can still do useful work.
Dave
Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 25/04/2022 09:38:38