Posted by Hopper on 10/04/2021 03:11:13:
Posted by Robert Butler on 09/04/2021 23:08:47:
PS the ex Myford fitter who serviced my lathe advised Myford used the cheapest spanner sets available
Yes but in those days the cheapest spanners were still made in Britain and still quite reasonable quality for home use. They must have churned out millions of Snail brand and King Dick, Vincent etc spanners over the years so costs were low. But they used good steel and good dies to make them. Different story with today's cheapest cheese-metal spanners.
I round up handfuls of good old BS spanners for peanuts whenever I am at garage sales and flea markets etc. The supply will run out one day so I figure I might as well keep them out of the hands of the hoarders. So I have a full set for each Brit motorbike and lathe in the shed.
Isn't it odd Model Engineers are the only people in the world who believe steel made 60 years ago is better than anything produced today? It's not my experience. When I bought my first socket-set, an elderly chap intervened to explain Japanese tools were rubbish and because it wouldn't last I should spend 3 times more on a British set. Fifty years later the Japanese set is fine (and is now recognised as a reputable Brand!) He was wrong!
In the last 3 years the Chinese made more steel than the British steel industry produced throughout their entire history. It is an enormous quantity of steel and although some of it might be below par, in general it's closer to specification than historic steels. Not paddy farmers stirring old bicycles into a pot, the production is from large modern steelworks using the world's most advanced processes.
Too many British firms after WW2 believed their own propaganda. Rather than accept the need to change and modernise, they tried to convince customers their over-priced products were 'quality' and appealed to our patriotism. Unfortunately, patriotism cuts no ice in export markets. Abroad, British goods came to be associated with average quality and high-prices. At home, people gradually realised they were paying over the odds for stuff that was just expensive.
I suggest we rose-tint the past as we grow older! The past was better because I was young, not because things were done properly then. Now retired, I remember the good bits and expunge the less creditable episodes! Spanners are an example: lasted jolly well most them, but is it due to them being solid, lightly used and kept indoors or ' they used good steel and good dies to make them'. If spanners were wonderful, why did UK makers churn out millions of third rate steel cars? Nice spanner, shame about the car?
I have a GPO tool roll full of well-made British screwdrivers and a contemporary British screwdriver that bends! It's rubbish. Nothing to do with steel, or when and where the screw-drivers were made. The bendy example is too cheap whereas the GPO bought the best tools available at the time, unaffordable for amateur purposes. Important to compare like with like before jumping to conclusions.
Always dangerous to believe your own propaganda. Faced with the need to compete in a rapidly changing world, looking to the obsolete methods of the past is unlikely to work for industry today, no matter how effective they once were. Time flies. It's what customers want tomorrow that matters. There's no place for small 'c' conservatism in manufacturing: such thinking does too much damage.
Dave