Posted by Bob Stevenson on 12/10/2021 07:57:06:
…
Also, if you have a good 4 jaw then you hardly need to bother with a 3 jaw….It does take an hour or so to get the hang of centreing work using a dial guage but there after it's very easy and gives the best accuracy of any workholding method.
…
Bob makes an excellent point: if I could only have one chuck, it would be a 4-jaw. There are turners who, by choice, always use 4-jaw chucks.
The advantage of a 3-jaw chuck is speed. They are the quickest easiest way of gripping round work and hexagons, but after that are nothing but bad news. They're not very accurate in terms of run-out, which often doesn't matter, and it's difficult to reset work in them, which does matter. So 3-jaws are great for turning shortish round jobs, where it's not necessary to move the work half-way through to a mill, saw, shaper or bench vice, and then go back to the lathe. Perhaps 90% of what I do can be done in a 3-jaw.
Collets have low run-out, are good for close work, and support fast accurate resetting but can only hold round objects of particular diameters. Extremely useful for certain types of work, such as clockmaking, but otherwise limiting.
4-jaws chucks are versatile. They can be adjusted to minimise run-out, accurately reset, hold shapes other than round, and offset jobs for boring super-accurate holes. Offsetting is also useful for turning ovals. The downside is having to learn how to use them. Centring 4-jaws is best done with two chuck keys and a DTI :
- Using one chuck key, position the job centrally by eye, but don't tighten the jaws.
- Position the DTI to measure how far the job moves horizontally when the chuck is turned.
- Turn the chuck by hand so one pair of jaws are horizontal. Note the DTI reading. Turn the chuck through half a turn. If the job is centred, first DTI reading minus second DTI reading = zero. If not zero, use both chuck keys on the opposing horizontal adjusters to ease the job such that the DTI difference is halved. Repeat step 3, halving the difference each time until the DTI says the job is centred. Then go to step 4
- Turn the chuck through 90° and repeat step 3 on the other pair of jaws.
- When the job is centred between both pairs of jaws, carefully tighten them without moving the work. Confirm with the DTI.
At first adjusting a 4-jaw is tedious and fiddly, especially if attempted with only one chuck key. Don't give up! The good news is the technique gets faster and easier with practice. An experienced operator can often get close enough by eye with a few tweaks, for example by looking for wobble relative to the sharp end of a centre held in the tailstock. Lesser mortals, and those needing high accuracy should confirm all is well with the DTI. The accuracy of the method is limited by the sensitivity of the DTI as a comparator and even a cheapo one should centre within 0.01mm.
Dave