If you can get the HSS that's pre-ground to be narrower at the bottom than the top, then using it on one of these would give you side clearance, which is nice data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/472df/472dfdac6477296c3cc2f7509cad30f058103056" alt=""
With ordinary HSS, the only possible advantage would be if, like teh old swan neck holders, it tends to swing clear rather than dig in.
Proof of pudding in the eating.
Neil