Ally bike cranks

[Graham Williams 11Participant @grahamwilliams11]

What's the general view on using Ally bike crank arms off mountain bikes to make con rods in model 'diesel' engines replacing HE 15 ?

[Graham Williams 11Participant @grahamwilliams11]

[Michael GilliganParticipant @michaelgilligan61133]

If it’s a good spec of crank then it will most likely be forged [no pun intended] and excellent for the purpose.

… But, as with so many things, cheap tat is also available.

MichaelG

[JasonBModerator @jasonb]

without knowing the grade of alloy it's hard to say and it could vary a lot between a set off a cheap £100 bike or a set of cranks alone costing several hundred.

Also if you are not fitting bushes the copper in 2014 is something you would want in a substitute alloy.

For the amount of work that can go into a conrod I'd rather start with known material.

[Andy_GParticipant @andy_g]

Posted by Graham Williams 11 on 16/09/2020 18:08:35:

What's the general view on using Ally bike crank arms off mountain bikes to make con rods in model 'diesel' engines replacing HE 15 ?

If they're decent cranks, they may well be hollow.

[John OlsenParticipant @johnolsen79199]

I sawed one open with the idea of using the material once. It turned out to be cast, and had so many blow holes and pores that you could almost say it was hollow. Naturally it was discarded!

John

[BazyleParticipant @bazyle]

They can be quite tough. I have one from when someone ran into me sideways on a roundabout and it took the punishment bending by about 3 inches which would have been a double fracture and permanent limp if the car bumper had hit my leg. I keep thinking of bending it back to use with the pedal shaft as a mandrel handle.

[Graham Williams 11Participant @grahamwilliams11]

The crank arms that are on offer are off £800 + bikes that have been pounded round the lakes, step son lives there, but seems that there might be a risk. Think I'll try one in one of the rough looking AM25s I have and see if it holds up as a failure might not be to hard to take. Thanks for all your input. G

[Bo’sunParticipant @bosun58570]

Might be worth a punt, but beware of metal fatigue in used crank arms. If you do try, stick with quality brands such as Shimano, Suntour, Race Face, Hope, etc.

[Author]

Posts