30 Year old MOTORUN 3 Phase Static converter

Advert

30 Year old MOTORUN 3 Phase Static converter

Home Forums Introduce Yourself – New members start here! 30 Year old MOTORUN 3 Phase Static converter

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 85 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #761425
    mr fixit
    Participant
      @mr-fixit

      Hello,

      I am just an amateur and I have a go at repairing anything and never throw anyting away. I have a small Mn80a lathe that I bought in 1996, with a 0.55KW / 0.74HP 3 Pase Motor.
      I purchased a MOTORUN Static Phase Converter to run it which has worked perfectly until recently, I tried to contact the firm without succesess. The problem is that the Motor would not start and the Contactor was switching on and off quite fast banging the side of metal case.
      I think the fault is with one or more of the 30 Year old Capacitors, There are five, two are for Starting in High or Low mode. In Low Mode only one the 20µF C5 is in circuit. in High Start Mode an additional 31.5µF Capacitor c4 is switched in parallel to C5.
      There are 3 Run Capacitors I have labelled C1 10µF, C2 6µF and C3 6µF. there are two HP output settings LOW (1/8HP – 1/2HP) and HIGH (1HP – 2HP). in LOW setting C2 and another are in parallel in the HIGH setting all three capacitors are in parallel. Unfortunately I made an error tracing out the circuit. and now I am not totally certain which pair of two capacitors are in circuit for the Lower HP it is either C1 & C2 OR C3 & C2. of course it does not matter for the High HP setting as all three are connected in circuit in parallel.
      I have purchased a new set of all Five Replacement Capacitors.
      Does anyone have one of these, and if so I would be very grateful for some help to resolve my problem. I have attrached pictures, although I am not sure what all the Transformer secondary windings are for, but as I have not moved any of them I don’t think there will be a problem there.MVC-006FSchematic diagram 7 Switch Labels 003

      Advert
      #761460
      john fletcher 1
      Participant
        @johnfletcher1

        Sorry, I don’t know any thing about your motor run device, you appear to be knowledable on matters electrical, but before removing the exist capacitor do ensure they are fully discharged. This can be done by short circuiting each capacitor terminals with an old screw driver, I hope I’m not telling grandma how to suck eggs. As you have already bought the new capacitors and haven’t disturbed any of the wiring why not fit them and see if the converter then works as before. I think the transformer is wired as an auto transformer, non isolating. Converters are now a thing of the past, inverters have taken over, so might be worth while altering the motor connections to Delta and fitting an inverter.

        #761470
        Clive Foster
        Participant
          @clivefoster55965

          Mr Fixit

          Ages ago I had a similar MotoRun static converter and should still have a circuit digram somewhere. I found the instructions for another correspondent a while back but unfortunately the circuit had gotten separated. I’ll have another look.

          Failing that I should be able to figure out the correct connections for you. I’ve built static and rotary converters in the past so I was familiar with whats going on. Digging back 30 odd years for the right memory isn’t a Sunday evening job tho’. Need to be bright eyed and bushy tailed!

          Clive

          #761536
          mr fixit
          Participant
            @mr-fixit

            Hi, John and Clive

            Thank you ever so much replying to my call for help. I used to buy MEW magazines, but the shop in Lancaster only ordered a few and I sometimes missed out, I have heaps of them and also some Hardback bound, I might start getting them again, I love looking through them, that is how I got the idea of joining the Forum.

            I have a slight very small confession, I did not make details of the Transformer Secondary wires correctly as I was not going to have anything to do with them and after looking at my circuit I realised I had not drawn the Transformer connections accurately so I have put this right just in case it was of any help to you. This is how the wires really are. The empty Connector block at the bottom is only used as a 240 Volt Live supply to connect it to the Contactor. (RLC 21-22 on my diagram.)

            Schematic diagram 7

             

            I have already removed the Capacitors still connected together, thank you for reminding me about that Hazard though, I had actually removed them without checking, oops. but I think the Capacitors are discharged automatically anyway through the 1M Resistor R3 across C2. C2 is always connected in circuit. But I shall definitely make a discharging probe for when I get around to rebuilding the circuit.
            I have searched the Internet for information about this unit, and I have not found anything at all apart from one thread on this Forum but that one has a 3 position Hourse Power Switch and also has a more complicated circuit with a highly populated Circuit Board, this is the thread I found. -:

            Motorun 2HP statin 3phase converter

            I would love to see a proper Circuit Diagram if you find it, I kept everything I recieved from MOTORUN even the reciept.BLIMY ££ but the info supplied is not all that helpful, just instaltion and how to use it, the firm seems to have vanished.

            Trevor

            Reciept

             

             

             

             

             

             

             

             

             

            #761537
            mr fixit
            Participant
              @mr-fixit

              Sorry just realised,   I had already sent the corrected Transformer circuit.

              Trevor

              #761540
              Michael Gilligan
              Participant
                @michaelgilligan61133

                This information could be way out of date

                … I think MapQuest just scrapes stuff from available databases …

                But anyway:

                https://www.mapquest.com/gb/england/motorun-phase-converters-506536552

                MichaelG.

                #761541
                Michael Gilligan
                Participant
                  @michaelgilligan61133
                  #761710
                  mr fixit
                  Participant
                    @mr-fixit

                    Hi MichaelG.

                     

                    Thanks for taking the time to look for me. I did look up the address on Google Maps and oddly got a completely different picture of 23, Waldergrave Road, Teddington. unless the pictures on your link are more up to date and that is what it looks like now but this is what I found.

                     

                    Screenshot 2024-10-29 at 00-23-09 Google Maps

                    I even contacted the the Estate agents (Niall Christian – Partner – Michael Rogers LLP) who’s name is on the gates, but he had no idea where MOTORUN HAD gone.

                    I tried to contact this firm which has the same name in London, but did not get a reply. So I gave up.

                    https://kingston-upon-thames.cylex-uk.co.uk/company/motorun-phase-converters-14114501.html

                     

                    Trevor

                     

                     

                     

                    #761713
                    Chris Crew
                    Participant
                      @chriscrew66644
                      • I noticed at the Midlands show that Transwave were still selling static converters so they haven’t disappeared completely. I have three of them, one is definitely over 30 years old and the other two not far off. I know they are obsolescent and live in fear of one failing but at least Transwave may be able to help. I suppose the apprehension of having to adopt to a new technology is a bit like moving from a dumb to a smart phone. As soon as we make the leap we start to wonder how we ever lived without one.
                      #761714
                      Michael Gilligan
                      Participant
                        @michaelgilligan61133

                        How very strange, Trevor … I will need coffee before pursuing that any further.

                        A couple of notes to keep things going:

                        1. I have so far found no reference to Motorun on Companies House, so it may be a “trading-as” name.
                        2. a search for the VAT number on your invoice also drew a blank

                        For general interest … this one looks nice & clean and bears a very legible label:

                        https://gandmtools.co.uk/product/motorun-4-h-p-phase-converter-80216092/

                         

                        C’mon chaps … “The Chase is On”

                        MichaelG.

                        #761717
                        Michael Gilligan
                        Participant
                          @michaelgilligan61133

                          Mews Style Commercial Units does fit rather well with the development that I linked … so I’m pretty sure we both found the same geographical location.

                          The development of ‘Brownfield Sites’ will bring a lot of these puzzles.

                          MichaelG.

                          #761718
                          Circlip
                          Participant
                            @circlip

                            Hopefully, a gallon of the brown stuff will quench the hypotheses.

                            If my memory is still working, about thirty years ago I did a detour on the way to Southampton to collect my MRPC from said address. The operation was a “Cottage Industry”type business run by a couple of guys rather than a white hot development. Access was via a yard in front of either (now misty) a wooden or brick building. I remember the yard in front, as when loading box into car, a cacophony over head was the mid day Concord(e) winging it way to wherever. It was purchased to run, and still does, me 3 phase V10.

                            Regards  Ian.

                            #761723
                            Michael Gilligan
                            Participant
                              @michaelgilligan61133

                              Thanks for the input, Ian

                              … I see no real contradiction: You visited old Railway buildings of some sort, which are now redeveloped.

                              What’s missing [and may, or may not turn-out to be interesting] is the recent history.

                              MichaelG.

                              #761726
                              Michael Gilligan
                              Participant
                                @michaelgilligan61133

                                IMG_0238

                                #761728
                                Baz
                                Participant
                                  @baz89810

                                  About 35 years ago I purchased a Britan turret lathe from Javelin machine tools who were I believe in Staines, West London. The machine was 3 phase so they obtained and fitted the phase converter for me. I got the impression at the time that Motorun was a shed in the garden business rather than a proper business on an industrial estate. As the machine tool dealer obtained the converter I never saw the premises. Converter is still in use but now powers a Brierley drill grinder.

                                  #761735
                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                  Moderator
                                    @sillyoldduffer

                                    For the purpose of getting it to work, there’s a good chance getting two capacitors the wrong way round isn’t a problem.  Short answer is in bold below, the following explanation can be ignored by anyone with TL;DR!

                                    The reason is static converters are imperfect even when set up optimally.  True 3-phase power consists of 3 lines each alternating 120° out of phase with each other.  Static converters use single-phase L and N to produce a 3-phase system in which two phases are 180° apart, and then create a third phase about 90° from L/N by adding capacitors.   A capacitor only circuit gives 0°, 180°, and about 270° rather than 0°, 120°, 240°.   The ‘about 270°’ is improved somewhat by adding an auto-transformer.

                                    In electronics, the time taken by AC to pass through a capacitor by charging and discharging it, is equivalent to a -90° phase shift.  An inductor adds a +90° phase shift.  Approximately!  Both depend on the frequency and the impedance of the load.  Impedance is a complex mix of inductance, capacitance and resistance and in a motor, inductance varies with current drawn.   Start current is usually much bigger than Run current, and Run current varies with the load.  It’s impossible for a static converter circuit to get this right automatically so they come with a bunch of switches typically labelled START, LOW and HIGH HP.  These allow the owner to find the combination of capacitors that start and run his motor.  He has to experiment.  If Trevor gets C1 and C3 the wrong way round, all that will happen is the HIGH, LOW switches will be set differently for motor best running.   A guess:  C1 (6uF) is connected to the LOW switch, and C3 (10uF) to the HIGH switch.

                                    As static converters are a bit of a bodge, no surprise that not all motors work with them!   Or that the power output and smoothness of the motor are both somewhat inferior compared with accurate 3-phase.

                                    Rotary converters do better by putting an idler motor in the circuit.   The idler motor responds to the current drawn by the working motor, so the false phase doesn’t jump about so much.   Better technical answer, but noisy, physically bigger, more expensive, and relatively inefficient.  They do support having a number of different machines plugged into them, which is important in some workshops.

                                    These days Variable Frequency Drives are usually preferred for fixed installations.   Unlike static and rotary converters, VFDs output correctly phased 0°, 120°, 240° power.  Quietly and with high efficiency. Plus speed control and a long, long list of other goodies.   Disadvantages include: understanding the manual, not plug-and-play; affordable units only support one motor, no sharing;  EMC issues; and a spiky synthesised waveform likely to poke holes through the insulation of an electric motor made before 1970.

                                    In the UK at least, Electricity suppliers are extremely reluctant to provide 3-phase to domestic users.  I guess this is partly economics – small users are unprofitable!  In the past single-phase installation costs were partly amortised over a 40 to 50 year supply life, usually in a scheme doing a whole village or new housing estate.   In contrast today, singleton domestic customers seem be quoted the full initial installation cost.   Not too bad if a 3-phase connection point is adjacent, but horrifyingly expensive if a deep trench is dug across a busy main road, poles put up, or. god forbid, a new transformer is needed.   Counter-intuitively, the per customer cost of converting a whole street to 3-phase is cheaper than running 3-phase to one small workshop; it’s because the installation expense is shared by many customers.   Electric cars may be the best bet for getting Model Engineering 3-phase. With luck, the government will encourage us to install 3-phase chargers en-mass by running an efficient roll-out scheme, where they carry the initial cost.   Unlike a small workshop using tiny quantities of 3-phase, car chargers will pay for themselves by being used!   And once 3-phase is on the premises for a car charger, then running a cable to the workshop will be much cheaper.

                                    Dave

                                    #761738
                                    Clive Foster
                                    Participant
                                      @clivefoster55965

                                      The run capacitor layout in that circuit looks wrong to me.

                                      Normally the generated “wild” leg has a capacitor running to each side of the mains powered legs so it’s pretty much balanced.

                                      In that was you’d have C2 going from the wild leg to one side of the 440 volt transformer output and C3 going to the other side in low power mode. So 6 µF each side.

                                      In high power mode C2 and C3 would be in parallel for one side and C1 connected on its own for the other so 12µF one side and 10 µF the other. It’s a bit unbalanced but it does save a capacitor.

                                      ——–

                                      Here is the typical circuit, L1 and L2 come off the transformer, C 3 is the start capacitor C1 and C2 are run capacitors. According to American sources a good general rule of thumb for run capacitor sizing is 5 µF per HP on 480 V / 60Hz. bit more on lower voltage and frequency so 6µF is reasonable over here at 440 v and 50 Hz.

                                      So with your components I’d expect C1 and C2 to be 6 µF each in low but one 12 µF (6+6 in parallel) and one 10µF in High.

                                      Typical C440 V circuit

                                      ——

                                      For yours I’d guess it’s C2 and C3 connected together for the low range. But I don’t know. Sorry.

                                      Clive

                                      #761757
                                      Michael Gilligan
                                      Participant
                                        @michaelgilligan61133

                                        I don’t know if this will be of any help to anyone, but as I stumbled across it:

                                        https://www.electro-tech-online.com/threads/3-phase-converter-schematic-miller-system.100563/

                                        MichaelG.

                                        #761765
                                        Clive Foster
                                        Participant
                                          @clivefoster55965

                                          MichealG

                                          That a good discussion link.

                                          Actually shows the same circuit as my post above.

                                          I have several versions of the circuit on my computer hoovered up in days when I  was seriously involved in such things but that is the clearest I have for the purposes of this discussion because there is no extraneous detail. Probably ‘undreds of “same but different” – “this is what I made” versions out on t’net.

                                          This has reminded me why I resolved to ‘keep big mouf shut” about such things around about year 2000 na plead ignorance when folk wanted a converter made or fixed!

                                          Clive

                                          #761766
                                          mgnbuk
                                          Participant
                                            @mgnbuk

                                            Machine Mart sell Clarke branded static converters – the manual for their 2 hp version is here

                                            The manual includes a circuit diiagram & a parts list that details the capacitors used.

                                            I have one to drive a small Ingar manual surface grinder, though it would also run a 3 phase version of an RF30 mill-drill (now departed). Seems to work OK, though the current price of nearly £350 is way more than I paid for mine (around £200 on one of their “Vat free” promotions IIRC). At the current price it may now be more cost effective to swap the existing motor, which is 415v only, than buy the static converter.

                                            Nigel B.

                                            #761771
                                            Nicholas Farr
                                            Participant
                                              @nicholasfarr14254

                                              Hi, I think we are all on the same page, and zooming in on Google Maps, puts  23 Waldegrave Rd  between No’s 27 & 31, but the number on the gate is 29. No, 29.

                                              I do have some detailed reprints of old London maps, that I bought when researching my family tree, but none of them are of that area. When you zoom in on the iron gates beside No. 21 street view, The words Engine Shed Yard can be seen above the two main gates, and there’s a No. 23 over the right hand side gate, and it looks like it’s in keeping with MichaelG’s Pavehall projects link.

                                              Regards Nick.

                                              #761774
                                              noel shelley
                                              Participant
                                                @noelshelley55608

                                                I seem to remember that Transwave statics have some sort of voltage sensitive boost device in them and I think it was on here that it cropped up as a fault. They are I seem to recall commercially available off the shelf ? This sort of got round the need for the start switch, only needing to match the run caps to the motor.

                                                If the OPs problem IS a faulty cap a Good meter will give a clue as to this. I hope the caps are right voltage,400V+ and type ? Good Luck. Noel.

                                                #761788
                                                Clive Foster
                                                Participant
                                                  @clivefoster55965

                                                  Noel

                                                  On commercial units the start boost capacitors are controlled by sensing the voltage on the generated “wild” leg. When it approaches halfway between the mains power supplied legs. Power to the start boost capacitor comes via a relay or contactor which opens when the generated leg voltage is sufficient.

                                                  I used two capacitors across the mains power derived legs to make voltage divider and connected the start boost capacitor relay /contactor coil between the wild leg and the centre of the divider. Maximum voltage across there relay coil when the motor was first switched on so the relay closed bridging the start boost capacitor into circuit. As the motor gained speed the generated leg voltage rose towards the divider voltage so the current in the relay coil fell. Eventually the current in the coil was too low for the relay to hold in so it opened and the start boost capacitor was taken out of circuit. The proper commercial device is more sophisticated but functionally the same.

                                                  Clive

                                                  #761956
                                                  mr fixit
                                                  Participant
                                                    @mr-fixit

                                                    Well high everyone,

                                                     

                                                    It is going to take me a while to absorb this influx of information, I have been reading all your replies with great interest and it sounds a bit complicated and I don’t pretend that I understand much about the Electonic Theory of operation, but I am sure that apart from mixing up the positions of C1 & C3 the circuit I have drawn is accurate. The reason I messed up was due to a re draw, it seems that I drew the switch the other way up so as to avoid the tracks from crossing as they were in my earler schematic and as it was a Year ago I am now unsure which was right.

                                                     

                                                     

                                                     

                                                    C1 & C3 Cocktail

                                                    SCHEMATIC 2 003SCHEMATIC 2 004

                                                     

                                                    My early scribbling also shows the switched capacitor as C1. My new Capacitors are exactly the same as the originals so they should be ok.

                                                    20241030_000509[1]

                                                    The original Capacitors were Soldered but I am going to use Spade Terminals to avoid any possibility of damaging them, I have read that NASA use crimped connectors instead of soldering when they go to Mars.

                                                    I was also thinking about the posibility of incorporating some lights indicating contacts opening and closing or maybe an Amp Meter, but not sure where in the circuit.

                                                    I shall read all your messages again tomorrow, Oh this is is the Schematic from the Clake, Thanks Nigel B, I shall have to study this a bit tomorrow

                                                     

                                                    Trevor

                                                    Macine Mart Schematic

                                                    #762021
                                                    noel shelley
                                                    Participant
                                                      @noelshelley55608

                                                      IF you consider using an ampmeter you may in view of the application use an over scale ampmeter to take account of start up surge  ? Noel.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 85 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up