3″ Scale traction engine queries

Advert

3″ Scale traction engine queries

Home Forums Traction engines 3″ Scale traction engine queries

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #158383
    Henry Beams 1
    Participant
      @henrybeams1

      Hi all,

      I am 15 and wanting to get into the steam traction scene and think that 3" scale is the best option for me.

      I am just wanting to know how much I need to save! What sort of prices am I looking at for something ready to rally? Or something part built but requiring no machining would suffice.

      Also if anyone in Devon or the South West has anything available that would be suitable then let me know.

      Cheers,

      Henry

      Advert
      #2804
      Henry Beams 1
      Participant
        @henrybeams1
        #158418
        Dan Jones
        Participant
          @danjones77555

          Hi Henry,

          I was 12/13 when I decided that I wanted to advance from a mamod into the rally sizes. I did a lot of research which eventually came up trumps.

          I would fully advise that you go part built if you have access to workshops and are willing to learn a fresh set of skills. If you go part built or do a restoration, you're indefinitely going to lean about the principles of steam engines and you'll learn how a traction engine works as well as learn new engineering skills such as metal working, measuring, machining, fabrication, interpreting drawings and fitting etc. All very adaptable skills that you can take into the workplace if you are interested in entering engineering as an eventual employment option. Also, if you go part built or do a restoration, the things you learn during the project will help with the maintenance and upkeep of the engine when it's finished.

          I was 13 when I got my first engine. It was a part built 3" Burrell traction engine bought from Station Road Steam. My grandfather bought it initially as the chances of a 13 year old having enough cash to buy a 3" engine are highly unlikely. So I was doing what I could as often as I could to get the engine finished. I was shown how to competently use lathes, milling machines and various hand tools to produce a quality finish.

          It took me around a year and a half to get enough money to buy out a 1/4 share in the engine. A sum of £1200.

          So before you do anything, you need to find a suitable engine make and scale. As a mere beginner, I suggest you go simple like I did. So you will be looking at a single cylinder agricultural/general purpose engine in a size that is rally worthy but small enough to be easily transported, used by a beginner and cheap enough for a teenager. A 3" scale single cylinder agricultural/general purpose engine is what you want as a basis.

          A few engines fitting this description are:

          3" Burrell Agricultural traction engine to Plastow's design- Very popular for beginners of all ages and aspects, castings and drawings supplied by bridport foundry (the engine I started off with)

          3" Fowler A7 General Purpose traction engine- A little larger than the Plastow Burrell and more powerful. A bit more powerful and a bit more expensive. Generally a highly rated engine however. Road and rally worthy.

          3" Marshall agricultural traction engine- A less common engine but a well designed model and aesthetically pleasing engine.

          3" Allchin agricultural traction engine- Becoming more common in this scale although most are built to W J Hughes design in 1 1/2" scale. A very nice engine all round in terms of power and looks. Quite a large engine for the scale

          3" "Little Sampson" tractor- A very small engine for the scale but still rally worthy. Bit odd with looks in my opinion. A cost effective solution.

          3" Aveling and Porter road tractor- Simple and compact in design. A kit engine from Maxitrak. I've heard a lot of different points of view from this type of engine.

          In terms of cost, for a relatively new engine, you're looking at £7,000 to £10,000 depending on what you get and the quality of the build and finish.

          For a part built engine, you can't price them unless you know what you get and what needs to be done. As is often the case with part built engines for sale, the boiler isn't there, which is the bulk of the cost in an engine. You need to expect that the chances of a part built engine coming up for sale without needing any machining having to be completed is going to be quite unlikely unless it's a kit engine. With this option though, you are much more likely to get better value for money.

          Keep an eye on the Station Road Steam website and Steam Engines for Sale.

          I hope some of this helps. I'm also in the South West and am only 16 so if you have any questions just ask.

          Thanks,

          Dan.

          #158419
          JasonB
          Moderator
            @jasonb

            I think Dan has it covered quite well. You may also want to keep an eye on what Berrybrook have available as they are in your part of the country. And sign up to join Traction Talk Forum, they have an active miniatures section and also engines for sale

            J

            #158420
            Henry Beams 1
            Participant
              @henrybeams1

              Thanks very much Dan for the detailed response! That really does help. I would cope with a part built kit but don't have machining facilities other than a basic metalworking lathe which I have very little experience of. Whereabouts are you Dan? I am near Newton Abbot, will probably see you at rallies if you are close enough. I was at Berrybrook today having a chat and looking at their stock, all very tempting but a bit of saving yet!

              Cheers,

              Henry

              #158820
              Dan Jones
              Participant
                @danjones77555

                Im in Chippenham, so North Wiltshire. Quite a distance from Newton Abbot.

                If you have a lathe then I say get out and use it. I would recommend you try and make a small stationary steam engine, start super simple. It's so uncommon now to see young people such as myself with the skills to be able to go out and independently use lathes, milling machines and hand tools, so the more you can learn, the better.

                If you want to have a go at simple steam engine, I designed a small oscillating engine that can be made by people who only have a lathe and a hand drill.

                My grandfather and I bought an engine from Berrybrook back in 2011. I must say, I find their prices quite expensive, so don't base your perception of engine costs on their prices.

                Dan.

                #158954
                Jeanie Walker
                Participant
                  @jeaniewalker87401

                  Hi,
                  I am also 16 and looking to start my own 3" model, am intrested in the Fowler myself. Thanks Dan for your intresting posts.
                  If anyone on here has a full set of drawings for the 3" Fowler A7, at a reasonable price (16 yr old minimum wage doesn't go far against a 3" model) I would greatly appreciate it if you could please PM me.
                  Thanks, Jeanie

                  Edited By Diane Carney on 28/07/2014 22:08:14

                  #158984
                  Dan Jones
                  Participant
                    @danjones77555

                    Hi Jeanie,

                    Before you decide on anything, try and find as many different options as possible. Pick out the options you like and ask for a price list of castings and drawings for each option. This will give you a rough idea of the amount of money you will need to put into your budget. Before I consider buying anything, I find the price list of castings and drawings, put each individual casting and its connecting price in an excel spread sheet and total up the cost of everything I need. this lets me know if I have enough money to build the engine.

                    I made a spread sheet for MJ Engineering's 3" Fowler A7 as I was offered a part built rolling chassis of one. It's a very very nice engine but it consists of some complicated machining for a beginner to deal with. Also, I find that parts and castings from MJ Engineering are quite expensive, so try and get what you can second hand (a part built project or second hand castings). I you would like a copy of the spreadsheet I can PM it to you if you want.

                    Thanks,

                    Dan.

                    #159227
                    Jeanie Walker
                    Participant
                      @jeaniewalker87401

                      There's a PM for you Dan

                      Jeanie

                      #159236
                      Bazyle
                      Participant
                        @bazyle

                        You should contact the Newton Abbott club to talk to some owners face to face. Ultimately you will need to join them to get a boiler certifcate anyway. Also visit Tiverton and Plymouth clubs. Taunton and Yeovil clubs also have a few large traction engines.

                        Make sure you think about transport, even for picking up a part built model which if without wheels is more difficult to move than a complete one. Also storage which needs to be frost free and dry. If you have only ever lived in Devon you won't understand what dry really is. The three weeks of limitted rain you have just experienced is what Londoners call 'dull and damp'.

                        Edited By Bazyle on 31/07/2014 13:13:29

                      Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
                      • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                      Advert

                      Latest Replies

                      Home Forums Traction engines Topics

                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                      View full reply list.

                      Advert

                      Newsletter Sign-up