20 TPI threads

Advert

20 TPI threads

Home Forums General Questions 20 TPI threads

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #619962
    Mark P.
    Participant
      @markp

      Can anyone tell me the major difference if any between 7/16" 20 unf and 7/16" 20 bcy, I know they are both 60°. I need to find a left hand bolt / stud for my BSA left hand footrest. The stud I require doesn't seem to be available.

      Regards Mark P.

      Advert
      #28911
      Mark P.
      Participant
        @markp
        #619965
        old mart
        Participant
          @oldmart

          You would have to closely compare the specifications, the differences would be the rads at the top and root of the threads. There is not much difference in practice, and as long as the nut is a decent length, say 1.5 diameters and not loose on the male, it should be fine.

          #619966
          Nick Hughes
          Participant
            @nickhughes97026

            Is this what you're looking for?

            BSA A50/A65 LH Footrest Stud

            or

            Unit Singles

            or

            Draganfly Motorcycles

            Edited By Nick Hughes on 06/11/2022 15:47:03

            #619968
            Mark P.
            Participant
              @markp

              Nick Hughes, I bought one of those but it's wrong for my frame I need a plain 7/16" left hand stud. Unfortunately as it's an unused frame I don't know the year as it's never been stamped.

              Yes Old Mart that was my thinking too, for what I need unf should be fine.

              Regards Mark P.

              #619969
              Nick Hughes
              Participant
                @nickhughes97026

                The last one is a plain LH Threaded stud, for the early Plunger A series, as shown in this diagram:-

                **LINK**

                #619970
                SillyOldDuffer
                Moderator
                  @sillyoldduffer

                  The most obvious difference to me is the thread shapes are different. Diameter, TPI, thread depth and angle all seem compatible, but UNF has squared off peaks and valleys whilst BSC threads are rounded top and bottom. This makes them somewhat stronger and less likely to vibrate loose.

                  However, I think a close tolerance male BSC would be too tight to fit into a close tolerance UNF female. Never tried it but I guess a UNF male will fit into a BSC female. There's a degree of uncertainty, and I don't think anyone can guarantee a fit. Though if failed, running a cheap tap and die over the partners would fix it – judging by the spec very little metal needs to be removed.

                  I'm a bit nervous of this sort of compromise on vehicles because of the risk stuff will come apart at 90mph and cause a crash! Much safer to source the correct part. But a footrest doesn't seem safety critical at all. If UNF fits, even as after a bodge, why not?

                  Dave

                  #619976
                  Maurice Taylor
                  Participant
                    @mauricetaylor82093

                    Hi Mark , I have a BSA A10 and all the bcy nuts and bolts were 26tpi. I have just checked on Google and there isn’t a 7/16 20 tpi listed . I am not criticising ,but please check again.

                    Maurice

                    #619977
                    Mark P.
                    Participant
                      @markp

                      Maurice Taylor, it's definitely 7/16" 20. I'm now sorted with what I need.

                      Mark P.

                      Edited By Mark P. on 06/11/2022 16:26:04

                      #619980
                      Clive Foster
                      Participant
                        @clivefoster55965

                        Basically BSC is to whitworth specifications re written for 60° flank angle.

                        According "Guide to World Screw Threads" by PA Sidders

                        Triangular height (H) = pitch x 0.8660254

                        Shortening is symmetrical at pitch divided by 6, = pitch x 0.1666667

                        Radius of crest and root = pitch x 0.166666

                        Depth of thread (h) = pitch x 0.5326921

                        There is no truncated form.

                        For 7/16 " 26 tpi BSC depth is near enough 0.021" (21 thou)

                        Major Diameter is 0.4375",

                        Effective Diameter 0.4170",

                        Minor Diameter 0.3956".

                        According to Sidders tolerances are quite wide at near enough 0 to- 0.006" (6 thou" ) on screws for medium fit and 0 to+ 0.0117" on nut minor diameter. Which seems way to great. I suspect a mis-print

                        The major difference between UNF and BSC is that the UN thread is flat topped and the shortening assymetric, H/8 outside for a male thread as against H/6

                        UNF data for male thread

                        Triangular height (H) = pitch x 0.86603"

                        Height of external thread = 17/24 x H = pitch x 0.61343

                        Height of internal thread = 5/8 x H = pitch x 0.54127

                        Shortening :-

                        At crest of screw = 1/8 H = pitch x 0.10825 at root of screw = 1/6 H = pitch x 0.14434

                        At crest of nut = 1/4 H = pitch x 0.21651 at root of nut = 1/8 H = pitch x 0.10825

                        For 7/16 " 26 tpi UNF depth is near enough 0.021" (21 thou)

                        Major Diameter :- screw = 0.4375", nut = 0.4375"

                        Effective Diameter :- screw = 0.4050", nut = 0.4050"

                        Minor Diameter :- screw = 0.3762", nut = 0.3834"

                        Sidders gives tolerances without ± indications for the Unified 20 thread series.

                        Screw :- major diameter 0.0081" (8.1 thou}, effective diameter = 0.0042" (4.2 thou)

                        Nut :- effective diameter 0.0054" (5.4 thou}, minor diameter = 0.0115" (11.5 thou)

                        Still seem quite wide

                        Plenty of room for tolerance stack up to give you a very poor fit if you use a UN form thread.

                        Clive

                        Edited By Clive Foster on 06/11/2022 16:33:54

                        #620005
                        SillyOldDuffer
                        Moderator
                          @sillyoldduffer
                          Posted by Maurice Taylor on 06/11/2022 16:21:14:

                          Hi Mark , I have a BSA A10 and all the bcy nuts and bolts were 26tpi. I have just checked on Google and there isn’t a 7/16 20 tpi listed . I am not criticising ,but please check again.

                          Maurice

                          I nearly fell into the same trap. Although several tables on the web and one of my books suggest BSC threads are all 26tpi, and these are most common on bikes, the standard also has some 20tpi too. Apparently 20tpi was inherited from the earlier CEI standard, and we're still using them!

                          Dave

                          #620008
                          Maurice Taylor
                          Participant
                            @mauricetaylor82093

                            Hi Dave, I thought they were all 26tpi ,I have looked again on Google and found 20 tpi bcy bolts.

                            Thanks for your post ,I’ve learned something new .

                            Maurice

                            #620016
                            CHAS LIPSCOMBE
                            Participant
                              @chaslipscombe64795

                              I seem to remember that as originally devised, cycle threads had two standards, 26 tpi and 20 tpi but the 20 tpi thread was abandoned in 1935. Despite this the 20 tpi thread was found to be useful by motorcycle manufacturers and continued in use even after WW2.

                              We can get too precious about this – if the footrest thread is old then there will be some wear which will affect thread dimensions anyway.

                              A while back Hopper commented that despite carefully defined standard tolerances, sometimes sloppy manufacturing (oriental suppliers?) and worn manufacturing equipment came into play, and theoretical thread forms were not always met in practice. Wear on UNF thread manufacturing equipment would lead to a more rounded crest and root form anyway. Certainly for non-safety related purposes I would use a 7/16 UNF nut on a 7/16 BSC thread

                              Chas

                              #620030
                              Hopper
                              Participant
                                @hopper

                                Indeed. And commercial threads are made with plenty of clearance, so it matters not if the crest is a radius or a flat, there should be no contact in that area between the two threads. All contact should be on the flanks. If the crests and roots are in contact, any tiny piece of grit will prevent the two threads screwing together. If worst comes to worst, you can run a file over the male thread in the lathe and knock quite a few thou off the OD and all questions of crest profile are moot. Remember, according to Tubal Cain's Model Engineer's Handbook, you only need 65 per cent thread depth engagement to maintain 95 per cent of full thread strength.

                                #620223
                                old mart
                                Participant
                                  @oldmart

                                  My good old standby from Motalia who have a range of motorcycle goodies:

                                  **LINK**

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                Advert

                                Latest Replies

                                Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                View full reply list.

                                Advert

                                Newsletter Sign-up