2 pole or 4 pole for Myford ML7R

Advert

2 pole or 4 pole for Myford ML7R

Home Forums Electronics in the Workshop 2 pole or 4 pole for Myford ML7R

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 84 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #652102
    Chris152
    Participant
      @chris152

      I'm thinking to convert our lathe from single phase to 3 phase with an inverter. Top speed on our lathe is 2105; speed on the 4 pole we're looking at is 1400, and the 2 pole is 2800. So far we've not gone beyond the 600 that the slow pulley gives and that seems fine for now, but that may change.
      From what I've read, it's ok to run the motor at 60 Hz and increase the 4 pole speed to about 1700. Is that correct, and if so, given that it doesn't look like we'll be doing much at high speeds/ narrower diameters, would 4 pole be a better bet for us?

      I guess my question in short is, is there any disadvantage in using a 2 pole motor compared to a 4?

      Advert
      #32348
      Chris152
      Participant
        @chris152
        #652105
        Thor 🇳🇴
        Participant
          @thor

          Hi Chris,

          I converted one of my lathes to 3-phase 4 pole motor, using an inverter to supply the 3-phase. The motor I bought can run at both 50Hz and 60Hz so running your motor at a higher frequency than 50Hz should not be a problem. I regularly run my motor over 60Hz, and after more than a decade I have had no problems. A 4 pole motor should be able to give more torque than a 2 pole as long as you don't turn the frequency too high.

          Thor

           

          Edited By Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:09:42

          #652114
          Mike Poole
          Participant
            @mikepoole82104

            The standard motor for the ML7R is a 4 pole. Doubling the speed using a 2 pole motor could run into questions about the max safe speed of chucks and whether the headstock bearings would be happy, in particular the bronze cone bearing. If you want extra speed the 4 pole motor can be over speeded with the VFD if required but I would be wary about massively exceeding the design speed of any machine. The standard motor for the ML7R is 4 pole and 3/4 hp or 550W. I fitted a VFD to mine and fitted a 4 pole 1hp or 750W motor as I felt the motor would give just a little bit more power at low frequencies but never avoid changing the belt ratios and using the back gear if required.

            Mike

            #652121
            duncan webster 1
            Participant
              @duncanwebster1

              I regularly run my setup at 75 hz, no issues. I'd go for 4 pole.

              #652131
              not done it yet
              Participant
                @notdoneityet
                Posted by Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:05:25:

                Hi Chris,

                I converted one of my lathes to 3-phase 4 pole motor, using an inverter to supply the 3-phase. The motor I bought can run at both 50Hz and 60Hz so running your motor at a higher frequency than 50Hz should not be a problem. I regularly run my motor over 60Hz, and after more than a decade I have had no problems. A 4 pole motor should be able to give more torque than a 2 pole as long as you don't turn the frequency too high.

                Thor

                Edited By Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:09:42

                I expect the rotor and bearing assembly are likely identical for either the 2 or 4 pole motor, so motor speed will not be an issue with the 1425 motor.

                #652168
                Steviegtr
                Participant
                  @steviegtr
                  Posted by not done it yet on 13/07/2023 20:24:20:

                  Posted by Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:05:25:

                  Hi Chris,

                  I converted one of my lathes to 3-phase 4 pole motor, using an inverter to supply the 3-phase. The motor I bought can run at both 50Hz and 60Hz so running your motor at a higher frequency than 50Hz should not be a problem. I regularly run my motor over 60Hz, and after more than a decade I have had no problems. A 4 pole motor should be able to give more torque than a 2 pole as long as you don't turn the frequency too high.

                  Thor

                  Edited By Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:09:42

                  I expect the rotor and bearing assembly are likely identical for either the 2 or 4 pole motor, so motor speed will not be an issue with the 1425 motor.

                  Are you getting confused by the inverter setting for a 50Hz supply or a 60Hz supply as some countries have. Here in the UK you would set the inverter up for 50Hz. The speed settings are a different parameter & in many cases can be set from 0 to over 100Hz. My Myford is set at about 60-65Hz max Which in the right gear runs just over 2000rpm.

                  I would not want to run it at this speed & usualy it never gets taken above 1000. Yes the motor cage is the same for a 2 pole & a 4 pole motor ,so not much chance of doing any damage overdriving it. Definately a 4 pole as the 2 pole will stall out under load. 2 pole motors are usually found on fans. Or any machine that does not require high torque.

                  Steve.

                  #652176
                  noel shelley
                  Participant
                    @noelshelley55608

                    4 pole , no question about it ! Noel.

                    #652200
                    Chris152
                    Participant
                      @chris152

                      That's great chaps – I think a decision has been made!

                      Thanks all, Chris.

                      #652202
                      not done it yet
                      Participant
                        @notdoneityet
                        Posted by Steviegtr on 13/07/2023 22:31:09:

                        Posted by not done it yet on 13/07/2023 20:24:20:

                        Posted by Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:05:25:

                        Hi Chris,

                        I converted one of my lathes to 3-phase 4 pole motor, using an inverter to supply the 3-phase. The motor I bought can run at both 50Hz and 60Hz so running your motor at a higher frequency than 50Hz should not be a problem. I regularly run my motor over 60Hz, and after more than a decade I have had no problems. A 4 pole motor should be able to give more torque than a 2 pole as long as you don't turn the frequency too high.

                        Thor

                        Edited By Thor 🇳🇴 on 13/07/2023 18:09:42

                        I expect the rotor and bearing assembly are likely identical for either the 2 or 4 pole motor, so motor speed will not be an issue with the 1425 motor.

                        Are you getting confused by the inverter setting for a 50Hz supply or a 60Hz supply as some countries have. Here in the UK you would set the inverter up for 50Hz. The speed settings are a different parameter & in many cases can be set from 0 to over 100Hz. My Myford is set at about 60-65Hz max Which in the right gear runs just over 2000rpm.

                        I would not want to run it at this speed & usualy it never gets taken above 1000. Yes the motor cage is the same for a 2 pole & a 4 pole motor ,so not much chance of doing any damage overdriving it. Definately a 4 pole as the 2 pole will stall out under load. 2 pole motors are usually found on fans. Or any machine that does not require high torque.

                        Steve.

                        No, I am not. If he was in a 60Hz region, he would have been quoting 1800rpm for his 4 pole motor, not 1400rpm.

                        Neither motor type will/should ‘stall out’ if operated at less than full load. At least one of my VFDs will operate at up to 400Hz. Some high speed drives use frequencies at those highs.

                        #652204
                        Robert Atkinson 2
                        Participant
                          @robertatkinson2

                          I was busy last night and missed this thread:

                          I recently fitted a 3 phase motor and VFD to my ML7 and after asssessing all the parameters I fitted a SIX pole motor and a larger (75mm) pulley on the motor.

                          The 6 pole motor is even smoother and quieter than a 4 pole, has more torque (for the same power) and the larger pulley is kinder on the belt. Even with tension off, the old belt would take a slight set around the motor pulley adding to noise and vibration when started.
                          It helped that the NOS 1/2 HP (0.37 kW) 910 RPM TEFC motor was only £40. A 1/2HP 3 phase motor is more than enough power for an ML7. The Gamak 6 pole I got is larger than a typical 0.37kW 4 pole to provide the torque so is very rugged.

                          The motor construction is identical to the two and four pole so is rated to the same speeds. Generally best use is made of a VFD when using it to run the motor at higher than rated (nominal mains frequency) speed. A modern inverter rated 4 motor will typically be good to at least 120Hz and a 6 pole to 200Hz but check the datasheet.

                          A two pole motor is not an viable option for the ML7. It's too fast and less smooth due to increased torque ripple. This can actually be seen in the surface finish of turned items.

                          Robert.

                          #652207
                          Robert Atkinson 2
                          Participant
                            @robertatkinson2
                            Posted by Steviegtr on 13/07/2023 22:31:09:

                            <BIG SNIP>

                            Are you getting confused by the inverter setting for a 50Hz supply or a 60Hz supply as some countries have. Here in the UK you would set the inverter up for 50Hz. The speed settings are a different parameter & in many cases can be set from 0 to over 100Hz. My Myford is set at about 60-65Hz max Which in the right gear runs just over 2000rpm.

                            I would not want to run it at this speed & usualy it never gets taken above 1000. Yes the motor cage is the same for a 2 pole & a 4 pole motor ,so not much chance of doing any damage overdriving it. Definately a 4 pole as the 2 pole will stall out under load. 2 pole motors are usually found on fans. Or any machine that does not require high torque.

                            Steve.

                            The VFD does not care what the mains frequency is. I think you mean the base or rated frequency of the MOTOR. This is used by the VFD to calculate the correct output voltage for any given speed. If the VFD also allows input of the motor voltage rating you can use either 50 or 60 Hz as long as you also use the voltage for that frequency. If the VFD base voltage rating (not actual voltage) is fixed then you use the frequency for the motor that relates to that voltage.

                            There are two motor damage related limitaions on the maximum speed you can run a given motor on a VFD. First is mechanical and even if it is not stated in the available data a 4 (or 6) pole motor will run at the same speed as a 2 (or 4) pole of the same construction / model. Second issue is voltage spikes and harmonics from the VFD. Modern motors are more resistant to these and "inverter" rated motors have additional insulation.

                            Robert.

                            #657480
                            Chris152
                            Participant
                              @chris152

                              I posted this question on the FB Myford page but I'm not getting a definitive answer, hope it's ok to repeat the question here.

                              We're putting a 3 phase motor and inverter on our Myford, following an excellent Youtube video on this.

                              I tried to order exactly the same motor as in the video, but the one we've just had delivered turns out to be the TEC T3A (0.75kw, 4 pole), the one in the video is the MS2. The T3A power is rated at 0.75 – 7.5; the MS2 is 0.75 – 37. What will the effect of this be if we go ahead and use the T3A, compared to the MS2? Ours can run at full Super 7 speeds (it's an ML7R), I know that the motor is rated at 1460 rpm, that's fine.

                              Should we just return the motor and change to the MS2?

                              Thanks for any advice.

                              ps This is the link to the T3A:

                              https://tecmotors.co.uk/products/motors/three-phase/aluminium-motors/t3a/0-75kw-4-pole-foot-mounted-motor-b3-ie3/?fbclid=IwAR2GR2W0BNAruBgw3yaTZjjPRUqDLSqHnjpOfmV7KcTdsaIcbfKMrhCeSJo

                              and this is the link to the MS2 (which says on the plate, for VSD use only):

                              https://tecmotors.co.uk/products/motors/three-phase/aluminium-motors/ms2/0-75kw-4-pole-foot-mounted-motor-b3-ie2/

                              Edited By Chris152 on 22/08/2023 14:05:37

                              #657488
                              SillyOldDuffer
                              Moderator
                                @sillyoldduffer

                                "The T3A power is rated at 0.75 – 7.5; the MS2 is 0.75 – 37"

                                I don't understand the numbers or see them in the spec. Where did they come from?

                                Twigged it! It's from the website. Doesn't matter. The T3A series is a range of motors. The smallest T3A is 0.75kW, up to the largest, which is 7.5kW. MS2 is another series ranging from 0.75kW up to 37kW. They both come with 2-4 or 6 poles and with the usual standard footprints The difference appears to be their relative efficiency and power factor – T3A motors are shade better than the MS2, not power or torque, just running cost. On a home lathe, the running cost difference will be tiny. It would show up on a machine that did much more work per day than a Myford.

                                Practically the 0.75kW motors from the T3A and MS2 ranges are almost identical. Either will be fine.

                                Dave

                                #657493
                                Chris152
                                Participant
                                  @chris152

                                  That's brilliant, Dave – I was thinking I'd have to send it back which would be a real pain. Now you've explained it, it's simple and I just completely misunderstood what the range was. Thank you so much!

                                  Chris

                                  ps I'm correct thinking this'll be fine to work with an inverter, aren't !? The MS2 plate says only for VFD use apparently, our one says nothing about VFD.

                                  Edited By Chris152 on 22/08/2023 15:11:25

                                  #657514
                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                  Moderator
                                    @sillyoldduffer
                                    Posted by Chris152 on 22/08/2023 15:09:25:

                                    ps I'm correct thinking this'll be fine to work with an inverter, aren't !? The MS2 plate says only for VFD use apparently, our one says nothing about VFD.

                                    Highly unlikely the motor won't work perfectly with a VFD. Possibly the MS2 is extra well-matched to a VFD, perhaps constructed to give a bit more torque at low speed and to run a little faster than a T3A could.

                                    Small differences sometimes matter to industrial users. On a Myford you won't run the motor at top speed in case it damages the bearings, and – if the motor struggles at low speed – torque on a Myford can be got by changing the belt down or engaging back-gear.

                                    Dave

                                    #657517
                                    Chris152
                                    Participant
                                      @chris152

                                      That's great – thanks Dave.

                                      #657557
                                      Chris152
                                      Participant
                                        @chris152

                                        One last question if I may – what amp fuse should I be putting in the plug that'll supply the above setup? (It's a single phase domestic input to a 2.2kw inverter, then on to the .75kw 3 phase motor.)

                                        #657580
                                        noel shelley
                                        Participant
                                          @noelshelley55608

                                          10 amp, or 13.. Noel

                                          #657592
                                          Chris152
                                          Participant
                                            @chris152

                                            Thanks Noel.

                                            #657596
                                            Robert Atkinson 2
                                            Participant
                                              @robertatkinson2

                                              While Noel's answer isn't wrong per-se, he does not have the required information to determine the fuse size required. The fuse in the plug is there to protect the cable. So to know the rating you need to know the size of the flexible cable used. If a 13A fuse is fitted then 1.25mm2 or 1.5mm2 flex must be used. If 1mm2 flex is used then a 10A or smaller fuse must be fitted.

                                              While noting that a 2.2kW VFD is a bit oversized for a 0.75kW motor, a 5A fuse would be adequate for the actual load of your system. I would still use 1.25 or 1.5mm2 flex for the mains input though. This is to minimise voltage drops. The VFD try to supply the required power so if the voltage drops the VFD will draw more current causing more voltage drop. This can lead to instabilites and reduced performance. Ideally you would use a 13A fuse in the plug with 1.25mm fleax and then put a 6.3A T ceramic fuse in the VFD enclosure before the mains filter.

                                              Robert.

                                              #657598
                                              Chris152
                                              Participant
                                                @chris152

                                                Both wires I have are stranded.

                                                I don't recall the size of the mains input wire, but just measured the diameter as about 1.8mm, which makes it about 2mm2 – but that doesn't seem to be a standard size, so I'm measuring wrong! But clearly it's at least 1.5mm2.

                                                The three phase wire is 2.5mm2.

                                                So I'll use 13A. I'll look into the remainder of your last sentence and see if I can understand (as you've gathered, I really don't know about electrics at all)!

                                                Thanks Robert.

                                                #657605
                                                noel shelley
                                                Participant
                                                  @noelshelley55608

                                                  Robert is correct in his comment and I had made the fatal mistake of assumption – that in wiring up a machine tool one would use at least 1.5 flex or cable. I tend to use 2.5 flex but that is because I can, though things get tight in some 13a plugs !

                                                  Chris, to find the sectional area of a wire or flex take 1 strand accurately measure the diameter in mm then use the formula Pi R squared. If a single conductor then that will be the answer, if flex then multiply the answer by the number of strands. Since in the main there are standard sizes of flex or cable if the answer looks near it should be right – or way out and obviously wrong ! Good luck. Noel.

                                                  #657714
                                                  Chris152
                                                  Participant
                                                    @chris152

                                                    Thanks Robert – I'd remembered Pi x r2 from O-Level maths in my approximate calculation, quite surprised myself!

                                                    I'm trying to figure the parameters I need to set and would appreciate any advice:

                                                    1. Maximum operating frequency is preset to 65Hz – should I change that to 50Hz here in the UK? (A separate parameter says 'Working Frequency – Default 50Hz.'

                                                    2. Revolution for 50Hz is stated as 2800 – as this is 4-pole, should I change this to about 1500 for mine? (I've read around the net and some parameter specs for XSY AT1 specify 2, 4 or 6 pole, this doesn't appear in my handbook, will it be automatic?)

                                                    I can't find any others that look as if they need changing at this stage, let me know if anyone thinks I'm wrong?!

                                                     

                                                    Edited By Chris152 on 24/08/2023 07:25:01

                                                    #657717
                                                    Robert Atkinson 2
                                                    Participant
                                                      @robertatkinson2

                                                      I'd leave the maximum frequency (speed) at 65Hz. This gives you a bit more operating speed range but is well within the limits of your 50/60 Hz motor. As an aside, often the best utility can be had from a motor/VFD set up by arranging for the motor to run at higher speed than it's name plate rating. This is why I recommended, and fitted on my own ML7, a 6 pole motor. On a VFD this motor can easilly run at 4 pole motor speeds. It has the same rotor, bearing and fan construction as the 4 pole. It prodces more torque at low speeds than a 4 pole. I also fitted a larger motor pulley to reduce stress on the belt.

                                                      The revolution for 50 Hz probably only affects the RPM indication or parameters set in RPM. It should be set to the value for your motor but does not affect actual operation of the motor.

                                                      Robert.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 84 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up