Slowing a motor on a potter’s wheel

Advert

Slowing a motor on a potter’s wheel

Home Forums Beginners questions Slowing a motor on a potter’s wheel

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 61 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #742782
    mrcharly
    Participant
      @mrcharly

      My wife has an old potter’s wheel driven by a AEI BC 2410 B56 motor.

      She wants to run it at a slower speed. I’ve investigated the drivetrain, and can’t easily change the speed by altering ratios of anything (mostly because of casing limitations).

      A friend suggested a VFD, but I’m struggling to find something suitable.

      As far as I can tell, this is a single phase induction motor.

      Can someone with experience of something similar help here, please?

      Advert
      #742791
      duncan webster 1
      Participant
        @duncanwebster1

        Vfd won’t work on a single phase motor. You’d need to replace it with 3 phase, or find a 6 pole single phase, which would run at 2/3 speed, but as rare as rocking horse droppings. You mug t be able to fit a DC motor

        #742792
        Michael Gilligan
        Participant
          @michaelgilligan61133
          On mrcharly Said:
          My wife has an old potter’s wheel driven by a AEI BC 2410 B56 motor.
          She wants to run it at a slower speed.
          […]
          A friend suggested a VFD, but I’m struggling to find something suitable.
          As far as I can tell, this is a single phase induction motor.
          […]

          If using a VFD … you will almost certainly need to use a 3-Phase motor

          … which is  not particularly expensive or difficult.

          MichaelG.

          .

          Edit: __ Duncan beat me to it.

          #742798
          SillyOldDuffer
          Moderator
            @sillyoldduffer

            First post on this electronics forum says: “The motor is an AEI BK-2410-C B56, it’s 4 pole 3 phase 415/230V 1hp / 0.75kW“.   If true, then a VFD is the answer, but it begs the question of how the wheel is powered at the moment?   Most of us don’t have a 3-phase supply.

            We need to correctly identify the motor and how it is controlled.   Most helpful for MrCharly to provide photographs of the motor, the wiring inside the motor’s terminal box, the control switches, and anything inside or outside the cabinet the cabling connects to up to and including the mains plug.

            Dave

             

            #742807
            duncan webster 1
            Participant
              @duncanwebster1

              OP’s motor is quoted as AEI BC……. not BK….

              #742824
              Nealeb
              Participant
                @nealeb

                I have only delved into the internals of a potter’s wheel on one occasion, and that certainly used a VFD and 3-phase motor. Also had a strange mechanical linkage allowing a foot pedal to operate a pot for speed control, although it seemed to work OK. Well, until the VFD gave up the ghost, which is where I came in. That wheel belonged to a professional potter.

                While my preference would be for the VFD/3-phase solution, I wonder if this might also be an application for the DC sewing machine motors that often get mentioned in this forum, available at relatively low price complete with speed controller. Don’t have a source for them, but my guess is that they would meet the speed control and power requirements.

                #742915
                duncan webster 1
                Participant
                  @duncanwebster1

                  AEI BC 3010 is single phase (interweb). I know it’s a different number, but if there is any logic I’d expect BC  motors to be single phase

                  #742920
                  Clive Steer
                  Participant
                    @clivesteer55943

                    A sewing machine brushless DC motor responds very quickly to speed changes including rapid deceleration with dynamic braking. Good for sewing machines but possibly not so good for potters wheel. Wheel may stop but not the pot. There may be a parameter in the BLDC controller that sets braking performance but it will depend on controller make.

                    VFD’s can be set for dynamic braking or coasting to stop.

                    CS

                    #742931
                    mrcharly
                    Participant
                      @mrcharly

                      It is definitely single phase – we don’t have a 3 phase supply.

                      I’ll try to get photographs of the motor.

                      This is a very old wheel, no foot pedal control. Speed control is by radially pushing a leather wheel radially across a platen.

                      #742934
                      Michael Gilligan
                      Participant
                        @michaelgilligan61133

                        Thanks, Charly

                        On that evidence, the first two responses are appropriate

                        … but pictures would be most welcome and reassuring.

                        MichaelG.

                        #742955
                        John Doe 2
                        Participant
                          @johndoe2
                          On mrcharly Said:

                          It is definitely single phase – we don’t have a 3 phase supply.

                          I’ll try to get photographs of the motor.

                          This is a very old wheel, no foot pedal control. Speed control is by radially pushing a leather wheel radially across a platen.

                          If the speed control is a leather wheel driving the platen at different radii, would it not be a lot easier and cheaper to simply make a smaller driving wheel to replace the leather one ?

                          You mention casing limitations, but surely a smaller wheel would fit where the original larger wheel did ? And a smaller drive wheel will drive the platen more slowly without changing anything else or buying new motors and VFDs etc.

                          #742965
                          Ian P
                          Participant
                            @ianp

                            Potters wheels are not something I knew (know) much about until recently when I was asked if I could repair one that had stopped working.

                            The machine sound similar to the OP’s in that the speed control was purely mechanical inasmuch as it had a variable ratio transmission. Rather than the leather wheel on a platen it had a conical ‘pulley’ on a motor shaft that engaged with rubber tyre on the edge of a large disk below the table. The motor was movable by a foot pedal to steplessly change the contact position between the tyre and the cone diameter.

                            I do not know how the latest or modern potters wheels are driven but I suspect if electronics are involved it will be tailored to suit this specific application. I think the pure mechanical drive has characteristics and a feel that a potter gets accustomed to so a VFD with a pot might not cut the mustard.

                            I think the OP only really has two options, one being to re-engineer the leather wheel so it is smaller diameter, the second being some sort of motor swap, say to a two speed induction motor or a VFD and three phase motor.

                            Ian P

                             

                            Edit, JD2 beat me to it

                            #743002
                            ChrisLH
                            Participant
                              @chrislh

                              If the existing motor is 2 pole say 2800 rpm approx (apologies for being somewhat confused over the nature of the existing motor), could a 4 pole motor at 1400 rpm provide a solution ? If so I have a 4 pole motor spare which I am willing to pass on for very little money. Please contact me by PM if this is of interest.

                              #743023
                              Sonic Escape
                              Participant
                                @sonicescape38234

                                The motor has a capacitor? If yes then I think there can be two cases. First, if it is a permanent split capacitor motor it should work with a VFD. Especially if you don’t want to adjust the speed over a wide range. But if it is a capacitor start type then it will not work.

                                #743057
                                peak4
                                Participant
                                  @peak4

                                  Many folk, when referring to a single phase inverter/VFD only consider an AT-1 type, from single phase in to 3 phase out.
                                  It may be possible to use an AT-2, which is single phase in and out, where the motor’s start winding is pulled out to the W terminal of the inverter; the internal design & firmware allow specifically for this.
                                  I’ve no personal experience of using one; some folk will tell you alternatively, they don’t exist, or don’t work.
                                  It may be less than a perfect solution, I don’t know; a friend of mine has, or maybe had as I’ve not seen him for a bit, a 2″ belt grinder running off one, which from the videos I’ve seen certainly worked fine, though arguably not quite as well as a 3 phase one.
                                  Starting from scratch, 3 phase does seem to be the preferred option.

                                  It was all documented/discussed, with videos, on a closed Home Built Belt Grinders Facebook group; one of the posts here.
                                  https://www.facebook.com/groups/847488865357217/posts/2853706118068805/

                                  Bill

                                  #743117
                                  Howard Lewis
                                  Participant
                                    @howardlewis46836

                                    If the motor is a simgle phase, I would expect it to be fixed single speed (1470  – 4 pole 2940 2 pole)

                                    To slow the wheel will entail either changing the motor, (to 4 if a 2 pole, or to  3 phase and VFD), or mechanical methods, such as smaller driving wheel or larger driven wheel.  Would be much easier if were belt driven.

                                    Can you make up and fit a smaller driving wheel, and / or arrange the driver to contact the driven wheel closer to the centre?

                                    To complicate matters, if space close to the driven wheel is too small, make up and fit a smaller driver, onto an idler, and change the start windings over, to reverse the motor direction of rotation.

                                    Howard

                                    #743164
                                    Michael Gilligan
                                    Participant
                                      @michaelgilligan61133
                                      On mrcharly Said:
                                      […]  Speed control is by radially pushing a leather wheel radially across a platen.

                                      I eagerly await sight of the photographs, but that sounds rather like this mechanism:

                                      https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/7c/f6/91/c26fc1f060e9a1/US2902741.pdf

                                      MichaelG.

                                      #743276
                                      mrcharly
                                      Participant
                                        @mrcharly
                                        On Michael Gilligan Said:
                                        On mrcharly Said:
                                        […]  Speed control is by radially pushing a leather wheel radially across a platen.

                                        I eagerly await sight of the photographs, but that sounds rather like this mechanism:

                                        https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/7c/f6/91/c26fc1f060e9a1/US2902741.pdf

                                        MichaelG.

                                        Yes, that is the mechanism.

                                        The leather wheel is pushed along the drive shaft by a ‘fork’. And therein lies the complication. The leather wheel is bolted to a steel flange that has a notch (which engages on the drive shaft). It isn’t possible to have a wheel smaller than this flange.

                                        The alternative approach would be to change the belt-drive wheels – but these are already about as large/small as will fit.

                                        Hence looking for a way to slow the motor. I will try to get some photos today (this is awkward, as The Potter has a 3 day exhibition coming up and gets very snappy if a grease monkey starts unbolting things in the studio).

                                        #743301
                                        mrcharly
                                        Participant
                                          @mrcharly

                                          PXL_20240724_163251033PXL_20240724_163139963

                                          #743303
                                          Michael Gilligan
                                          Participant
                                            @michaelgilligan61133

                                            Excellent, thanks

                                            … I am quite sure that a simple motor swap [to 3-phase with VFD] will work wonders.

                                            MichaelG.

                                            .

                                            Edit: __ some useful drawings of modern frame-sizes here:

                                            https://www.electric-motors.online/products/motors/b56-motors/

                                            #743310
                                            Ian P
                                            Participant
                                              @ianp

                                              Whilst a three phase motor and a VFD would transform the machine (make it smoother, quieter and have a greater speed range) it is a bit of an overkill and its installation is not completely straightforward.

                                              There looks to be acres of room to mount the VFD in the cabinet but, it would need protecting from water splashes and drips. Ideally too one should have the cabinet door lockable or at least need a tool to open (screwdriver) to prevent access whilst connected to the mains.

                                              You do not say how much slower your wife wants the machine to run at and whether if (for example) it is half the current speed, then it would also halve the top speed. With a VFD set to 10Hz the motor will run at one fifth of is normal speed. A VFD will act like a gearbox leaving the foot pedal for the potter to use as normal.

                                              Having said all that the simplest option might be to just have a much smaller pulley on the existing motor leaving the large one as it is. It might be below the specified bend radius for the belt but if it works will just shorten the belt life.

                                              What you end up doing may depend on whether you have mechanical or electrical skills. Knowing just a little about the wet and messy environment below the wheel I would favour a mechanical solution.

                                              Ian P

                                              #743312
                                              Michael Gilligan
                                              Participant
                                                @michaelgilligan61133

                                                Funny,that Ian … I was seeing a nice new ‘Drip Proof’ 3-phase motor as a major improvement in safety.

                                                MichaelG.

                                                .

                                                P.S. __ if Charly does elect to make the simple pulley change, a Poly-V pulley should obviate the stated problem with ‘wrap’

                                                #743315
                                                Clive Brown 1
                                                Participant
                                                  @clivebrown1

                                                  Not many VFDs are drip-proof though, AFAIK. There seems to be a fair bit of room in th cabinet which makes me wonder if introduction of a countershaft into the drive would be practicable as a simple speed reduction.

                                                  #743318
                                                  Ian P
                                                  Participant
                                                    @ianp

                                                    Regulations are not what they were, or more accurately they are more stringent than when his wheel was manufactured. Safety could be ensured by the electrics (and the finger trapping belts!) being in a secure cabinet so what is inside becomes less relevant.

                                                    Another vote for PolyVee. It would however mean two new pulleys and belt, whereas keeping the existing large pulley just fitting a new smaller motor pulley and moving the motor in its slots would be a simple cost effective answer. Pulley might have to be made as its unlikely to be stock item.

                                                    Ian P

                                                    #743320
                                                    Michael Gilligan
                                                    Participant
                                                      @michaelgilligan61133
                                                      On Clive Brown 1 Said:

                                                      Not many VFDs are drip-proof though, AFAIK. […]

                                                      Despite there being plenty of room, I can see no useful purpose in putting the VFD in, or on, the cabinet … methinks it would be safer mounted elsewhere.

                                                      My reference to ‘Drip Proof’ related only to the motor.

                                                      I’m having a much-needed early night, so will leave the discussion for now.

                                                      MichaelG.

                                                      .

                                                      P.S. __ Quote:

                                                      The alternative approach would be to change the belt-drive wheels – but these are already about as large/small as will fit.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 61 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up