Greetings from an Industrial Graveyard

Advert

Greetings from an Industrial Graveyard

Home Forums Introduce Yourself – New members start here! Greetings from an Industrial Graveyard

  • This topic has 28 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 5 May 2017 at 23:21 by George Becker.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #296113
    George Becker
    Participant
      @georgebecker85540

      Hello,

      Having been a lurker for some while I am now looking forward to full participation. Not to be mysterious I am located in Detroit, Michigan USA, a onetime paradise for the engineering arts. After starting in lost wax foundry in the late 1960's at age 16 I have watched the decline of small shops for about 50 years. Once there were countless small tool and die and numerous local industrial suppliers in the Metropolitan region. Now most of it has gone. The only positive thing I personally gained was access to used machinery and tooling at rock bottom pricing as Detroit's industrial base faded away. The manual skills that were once abundant mostly resided in the heads and hands of machinists either retired or close to retiring. It is precisely sites like this that offer some chance for the old skills to be recorded and hopefully applied by an interested younger generation. Retired myself ,my current interest is in restoring old scientific equipment. and creating specialized tooling to help in that pursuit.

      Advert
      #40089
      George Becker
      Participant
        @georgebecker85540
        #296124
        Brian H
        Participant
          @brianh50089

          Welcome George, what you describe sounds much like Sheffield in England, also known as Steel City.

          I'm sure you will find much to interest you on here and everyone seems keen to help with questions.

          Brian

          #296133
          Andrew Evans
          Participant
            @andrewevans67134

            Greetings George and welcome to the forum. Is Detroit now on its way back up after the decline of the car industry? I know the city has had a huge decline in population. Andy

            #296141
            Hopper
            Participant
              @hopper

              Welcome to the forum. I hear what you're saying, loud and clear. I served my apprenticeship at a Chrysler car factory in Australia which too was surrounded by small tool and die shops, machine shops and press shops and the like all supplying the main factory as a mainstay and doing other work on the side. Also all gone now and the skills base lost except for perhaps a few venues like this site and similar. There were many absolute wizards of craftsmen among them and its too bad that knowledge is not being passed on to the next generation on a broader scale.

              #296156
              Chris Evans 6
              Participant
                @chrisevans6

                Welcome George, I spent my entire working life before retiring in the mould and die trade as a toolmaker. I got to visit Detroit for a look around the toolmakers in the late 1990s, lot of skill based there.

                #296166
                Geoff Theasby
                Participant
                  @geofftheasby

                  Hi George,

                  I live in Sheffield, although not an engineer. The steel mills have largely gone, but now the emphasis is on special steels, many only recently invented, and hi-tech manufacturing. There are still small businesses working in cutlery, and fine instruments though.

                  Geoff

                  #296250
                  Neil Wyatt
                  Moderator
                    @neilwyatt

                    Welcome George,

                    I understand Detroit has taken an even worse hammering than many other industrial towns.

                    On the plus side, at least you have great music, including Alice Cooper

                    Neil

                    #296282
                    George Becker
                    Participant
                      @georgebecker85540

                      Brian,

                      Thank you for the warm welcome. Re: Steel City decline. I guess the hollowing out of older industrial cites is quite common. Advancements in manufacturing have taken their toll on the skilled trades.

                      George

                      #296284
                      George Becker
                      Participant
                        @georgebecker85540

                        Andy, Thank you for your welcome message. Detroit proper is showing some minor signs of recovery but the population decline is still continuing. Manufacturing seems to have somewhat stabilized in the metropolitan region, partially due to some consolidation in the auto industry where plants in other areas have been closed and the work moved to Detroit. Partly also there is an uptick in automated manufacturing. However overall manufacturing employment is at a lower level in both numbers and pay levels as lesser skilled workers comprise more of those employed.

                        #296287
                        George Becker
                        Participant
                          @georgebecker85540

                          Hopper,

                          Thanks for the welcome. I presume you are still in Australia. I am a bit curious. Before the great influx of Chinese tooling what countries commonly supplied machine tools to Australia and was there a large machine tool industry native to Australia. I can't recall seeing much here of Australian manufacture except some drafting equipment.

                          George

                          #296288
                          George Becker
                          Participant
                            @georgebecker85540

                            Chris,

                            Thank you for the welcome note. You are lucky to have visited in the 90's. That is about the last time that the smaller engineering firms could still make a go of it and even then the decline was setting in.

                            George

                            #296289
                            George Becker
                            Participant
                              @georgebecker85540

                              Geoff,

                              Thank you for the welcome. I still have some Moore and Wright and Shardlow precision instruments and tooling, some of which is among my favorite kit. Is the steel industry in Sheffield all in smaller plants now or are there still some large works operating?

                              #296290
                              George Becker
                              Participant
                                @georgebecker85540

                                Neil,

                                Thank you for welcoming me. Detroit has indeed been hit hard but I don't know that is worse than other locations. The steel industry throughout the nation has been devastated. When I was a boy I lived close to the Detroit river and during the summer there was always at least one ore boat, (800-900 foot long iron ore carrier) in view on the river and very often 3 or 4 at the same time. They were carrying ore from Lake Superior to the mills in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New York. Nowadays you can often look down from the bridge crossing to Windsor, Ontario Canada and not see any in either direction. I was recently told that all that remained of the Bethlehem Steel Works was a portion that had been converted into a casino. Funny, I really never cared for Alice Cooper. Much more a Hendrix fan.

                                George

                                #296296
                                Chris Evans 6
                                Participant
                                  @chrisevans6

                                  George, I have happy memories of my time in Detroit. I stayed over the river in Windsor and there where many toolmaking outfits there to. Rounded off the trip with a visit to the Finkle (spelling) steelworks in Chicago. In all a nicely organised trip with our UK trade association and USA trade association.

                                  #296297
                                  Anonymous

                                    Hi George,

                                    Welcome to the forum; plenty of knowledge here.

                                    I visited Detroit several times in the 1990s. Initially we were doing the hardware and software for an engine controller for Detroit Diesel – Series 60 engine if I recall. Later I came over to attend the SAE show.

                                    The first night, on the first visit, the client took us to a lap dancing club, although to fair I think it was actually in Windsor. Being from the UK I asked why we were frisked going in; answer, looking for guns.

                                    Andrew

                                    #296303
                                    Geoff Theasby
                                    Participant
                                      @geofftheasby

                                      Hi George,

                                      Thank you. There are still the big plants, Forgemasters (Was Vickers River Don) Outo Kumpu, stainless, a Finnish Co, Firth in some incarnation, Tata Steel, now sold to Liberty, (Stocksbridge, Parkgate) but most of the old basic steel has gone. Several big bits of machinery, drop hammers etc., have been placed at road junctions, roundabouts etc., as monuments to the past. The mighty 'River Don' rolling mill steam engine has been preserved in working order at Kelham Island museum.

                                      Geoff

                                      #296309
                                      Chris Evans 6
                                      Participant
                                        @chrisevans6

                                        Andrew, when I visited and stayed in Windsor our host called them "Gentlemans Clubs". We where not asked to visit them though.

                                        #296314
                                        Neil Wyatt
                                        Moderator
                                          @neilwyatt

                                          Hi George,

                                          I was born in Barry, South Wales. Once it was the fastest growing and busiest coal port on the planet. I saw the docks decline, and now its rising up again with designer dwellings instead of cranes. Sill a few ships, but not many.

                                          In the mid-80s I worked in Bridgend, on a job creation scheme. We had a lot of ex-steelworkers, many of who had worked at Port Talbot. As a boy I remember the drive to (great) Aunt Lil's in Mumbles/Swansea and when you drove past Port Talbot you had to wind up the windows and shut the air vents to keep the eggy small out. The hills above the motorway opposite the steelworks were covered in dead trees. So there were good and bad sides to the decline of industry, but the human cost was high.

                                          I've spent about 20 years working in the Black Country and Birmingham, not quite where the industrial revolution began (I think we can attribute that to Ironbridge to the west) but certainly where it got up to speed. You'll know that the area has an equally long list of bands to its credit, what is the link between heavy industry and music?

                                          Neil

                                          #296320
                                          Mike Poole
                                          Participant
                                            @mikepoole82104

                                            I am a fan of the Motor City Madman Ted Nugent and classic Motown but I believe Motown relocated to the west coast many years ago. I worked all my life in the British car industry which still produces a similar volume of cars to years ago but with far fewer people and foreign owners.

                                            Mike

                                            #296322
                                            George Becker
                                            Participant
                                              @georgebecker85540

                                              Andrew,

                                              Thanks for the welcome. Windsor certainly has a reputation for nightlife especially among the younger set. A lot of it is due to the disparity in drinking age which is 18 in Ontario but 21 in Michigan so there is quite a bit of cross border entertainment traffic. About being questioned about guns many years back somewhere around a dozen Baptist ministers on a bus were arrested attempting to cross into Canada while in possession of their handguns. That despite signs on the American side warning that handguns are not permitted in Canada. If nothing else the driver should have known and warned them.

                                              George

                                              #296325
                                              George Becker
                                              Participant
                                                @georgebecker85540

                                                Mike,

                                                You are quite right about Motown. About all that is left in Detroit is the Motown museum, Hitsville USA, which is located in the modest former residence and studio of Berry Gordy and a few aging Motown musicians and performers.. Ted Nugent while originally from Detroit first made it musically in Illinois. After moving back to Michigan he located near Jackson which is about an hour and one half drive west of Detroit. If I remember correctly he had some 3,000 acres of land out there which he may still own even though he has long since left the state. Funny you should mention foreign ownership I still hear Chrysler being referred to as an American car company when it is in fact only a Fiat nameplate now. Under the iconic Jeep brand we now have the Jeep Renegade which is built on the Fiat 500 platform. Of course that is no farther from the original Jeep concept than the bloated Jeep Wrangler which weighs in at around 5000 pounds. The Wrangler is a far cry from the World War Two vehicle that was less than half that weight.

                                                 

                                                George.

                                                 

                                                 

                                                 

                                                 

                                                 

                                                 

                                                 

                                                Edited By George Becker on 04/05/2017 11:04:56

                                                Edited By George Becker on 04/05/2017 11:11:07

                                                #296328
                                                George Becker
                                                Participant
                                                  @georgebecker85540

                                                  Neil,

                                                  "what is the link between heavy industry and music?" A decent disposable income perhaps?

                                                  George

                                                  #296330
                                                  richardandtracy
                                                  Participant
                                                    @richardandtracy

                                                    How the great industrial centres rise & fall.

                                                    Cornwall – at one time there were more steam engines the county than in the rest of the planet put together. Now, who even remembers it was a hive of industry? Few enough..

                                                    I have been looking at Detroit house prices regularly over the last 8 years (on Realtor.com) and have got the feeling that there are fewer houses for $1 than there used to be, and when looking at the $1 plots, you get less for your money than you did. Occasionally in the past you got something nearly habitable, but now it's rarely better than a burnt out heap of rubble. I do get the feeling that things are not as bad as they were for house prices, though having said that, a property with the same/bigger 1200 sq ft floor area as my home in the UK can be as low as $2754 (15364 Steel Street at 2000 sq ft on a 35x110ft plot). Very sad to see how much money in the form of property value has simply evaporated, leaving people well & truly stuffed.

                                                    Regards,

                                                    Richard.

                                                    #296334
                                                    Hopper
                                                    Participant
                                                      @hopper
                                                      Posted by George Becker on 04/05/2017 11:07:52:

                                                      Neil,

                                                      "what is the link between heavy industry and music?" A decent disposable income perhaps?

                                                      George

                                                      And noise. Volume. Rhythm. Power. Hard driving relentless production machinery. I read Jimmy Barnes's autobiography recently — he was lead singer for Aussie hard rock band Cold Chisel, who also made the bigtime overseas for a while. He says straight up they took a lot of their musical inspiration, and the band name, from the car factories around where he grew up. Most likely the stamping plant with 100 or so presses banging away rocking the foundations. Plus he wanted an escape from life as an apprentice moulder in a foundry and rock 'n' roll was it.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up