All I will say for now having seen the first part is don't be put off having a go by what looks a long complicated process from reading the article. Get the trial downloaded and have a go it really is a lot simpler than it looks.

I do have one question though, why was the XY axis chosen to start drawing? I would have gone with ZX so that when any of the View Icons are clicked the part shows the right way up. I find this also helps later when you come to start assembly of parts.

J

Jason,

I can't speak for Rob (the tutorial author), but XY plane often gets used simply because it is 'face on' to the computer screen at launch and hence the quickest one to select. No reason why another plane couldn't have been used instead, and no reason why readers shouldn't try using a different plane (perhaps after building a little confidence).

In some CAD system the 'face on' plane is a carry over from looking at graph paper on your desk (XY plane), in others since the screen now tends to be vertical not horizontal the ZX plane is presented 'face on'. I see huge arguments over which is 'correct' – they are all arbitrary.

In Alibre Atom3D – Initial 'Face on' plane or 'Front view' is looking at the XY plane from the +Z direction, the view orientation icons are consistent with that.

If you plan to later transfer your model to CAM or to 3D printing software, it might save some time to consider which plane you start on – so your model imports 'as expected' into the other software (though this can usually be worked around).

Edited By David Jupp on 26/10/2018 11:39:24

I normally use the XY plane as the bottom of a part. Then the part is orientated in the same way as a milling machine. This is particularly useful when transferring the part to a CAM program prior to CNC milling. Saves a lot of faffing about.

Apart from the initial part in an assembly, which I usually orientate to the workspace, all the other parts are constrained to other parts, so initial orientation isn't important.

Andrew

Edited By Andrew Johnston on 26/10/2018 15:47:18

Thanks Andrew, starting so that the part suits further use of the file makes sense be it for milling or getting a flat surface on the 3D printer bed. I think I will keep doing it my way for now as it suits rendering if the light falls on the top of the part and shadows below and also if I want to add a 3D image to a 2D drawing the part is the right way up, maybe if I get into CNC or Printing in the future that will change.

Steambuff and anyone else for that matter, I will move any Atom3D related threads or posts to here as it makes it easier for the various people from Alibre who are looking in to keep track of things and possibly get you an quicker answer. If anyone does raise a ticket with support can you include the ticket number in your post as it makes it easier to look you up.

J

Edited By JasonB on 27/10/2018 07:07:39

David, Thank you for your response and email.

You state that the user interface has changed, but can you tell me –

1/ What new features are in Alibre Atom3D that are not in Cubify Design?

2/ What features are in Cubify Design that are not in Alibre Atom3D?

Based on this I can make a decision to upgrade or not …. Is there an upgrade price available?

Thanks

Dave

Rod, how did you do the two tangental lines? For the trim to work they must actually be tangental not just look like it on the screen.

1 option if you want the line vertical or horizontal starting at the circles ctr line is to draw your circle then select the line tool, now hover your cursor near circle where you want the line to start and you will see the little image of a line near your cursor arrow change to a line and inverted triangle as you move around to 0, 90, 180 & 270 deg a red guide line will also appear now click mouse to start line. As you start drawing your line now it will automatically snap to the circle and be tangental when vertical or horizontal. You can tell if it is by a black dot where the line joins the circle.

Another method is to draw a line approx where you want it and then go upto the "constraints" box along the top. one icon there is a circle with a tangental line, hover cursor over that and it will tell you what it does. You then click that icon and follow what it says bottom left – select first figure, I usually select the circle then select second figure which is your line it will then move to be tangental to the circle

Easier done that said

EDIT rough and ready video, my version is slightly different but you have the same functions

Edited By JasonB on 28/10/2018 14:44:20

Rod – though produced for Alibre Design, rather than Atom3D, this video shows general usage of the trim tool. It might help.

Jason is correct – the lines have to either cross the circle, or be truly tangent to it for the trim to work, alternatively the end nodes of the lines could be set coincident with the circle.

Well I just redrew it to send you a screenshot and the trim function worked as I would expect. Must have drawn it in a more acceptable way. It was the first time I had used the programme. Apologies for wasting your time.

Still playing

Not a waste of time Rod – it seems that these 'little things' that are obvious to the experienced user, conspire to defeat some new users.

If a sketch isn't behaving as you'd expect – it can be worth just starting a new sketch and trying again…

"I have moved the comments on other CAD packages to another thread."

Which thread would that be Neil?

Rik