Error in CNC article

Advert

Error in CNC article

Home Forums Model Engineers’ Workshop. Error in CNC article

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #38198
    John Haine
    Participant
      @johnhaine32865
      Advert
      #130974
      John Haine
      Participant
        @johnhaine32865

        There's an error in the CNC in the Workshop article in the latest MEW which could cause some head scratching. In the 3rd column of the first page there is a little bit of g code that is supposed to take the drill 1 mm above the work, then centre drill in 2 pecks of 3 then 6 mm. Unfortunately the z values given are 3 and 6 mm rather than -3 and -6 mm, so the drill won't break the metal surface at all! The same error is repeated in the text a few lines below, so it's not just in the g code transcription.

        On the next page there's another bit of code to drill holes to 20 mm deep in 3 pecks. I think the intention is to use a safe z 1 mm above the work, but in the 3rd line z is set to the work surface z=0. This time though the drill depths are given correctly as negative z values.

        This is an exercise so I guess that is why the peck drill instruction isn't used?

        i must say this series seems to be making glacial progress, as well as apparently spending more time describing general purpose milling accessories than specifically CNC.

        #130979
        John Stevenson 1
        Participant
          @johnstevenson1

          It does seem to dance about a bit and I think this is one problem why CNC gets so much bad press in the mag.

          There has now been about 5 or 6 major articles on CNC but not one has worked logically.

           

          By logically imagine you are now the proud owner of a Widget CNC mill, all singing, all dancing in it's coat of metallichrome turd brown.

           

          You have bought a couple of cutters, a collet or collet chuck but what do you do with it. ??

           

          There are three area's you have to learn. One is to draw the part, second is to bring that into a CAM package that will convert the drawing to G Code and lastly you have to tell the machine how to use this code.

           

          That's it – everything else is just experience on these 3 modules.

          However all the articles I have seen either get sidetracked or start off like you are fully experienced anyway.

          [edited] because the Welsh version of my keyboard only has 21 letters and 5 of these are L's and 7 are F's

           

          Edited By John Stevenson on 29/09/2013 13:34:20

          #130981
          blowlamp
          Participant
            @blowlamp
            Posted by John Stevenson on 29/09/2013 13:30:23:

            …There has now been about 5 or 6 major articles on CNC but not one has worked logically…

            Edited By John Stevenson on 29/09/2013 13:34:20

            I though the "Bridging the CAD/CAM Divide" articles were superb.

            Martin.

            #130982
            mick
            Participant
              @mick65121

              trouble is, if you write a simple article you get accused of being patronising, get a little more adventurous and your also accused of not taking the beginner into consideration and there's always someone ready to pounce on the smallest mistake, which is the main reason I stopped writing them several years ago, and now only skirt around the periphery of the subject, leaving sticking the head above the parapet for other souls brave enough to tackle the subject.

              I feel the only way to learn CNC is one to one in the workshop, which unfortunately is not always possible.

              #130983
              John Stevenson 1
              Participant
                @johnstevenson1
                Posted by blowlamp on 29/09/2013 13:58:05:

                Posted by John Stevenson on 29/09/2013 13:30:23:

                …There has now been about 5 or 6 major articles on CNC but not one has worked logically…

                Edited By John Stevenson on 29/09/2013 13:34:20

                I though the "Bridging the CAD/CAM Divide" articles were superb.

                Martin.

                Perhaps need to go back and re-read this one, may have missed it but I still stand by my general post.

              Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
              • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

              Advert

              Latest Replies

              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

              View full reply list.

              Advert

              Newsletter Sign-up