There could be issues with swarf getting trapped between the roller and the job if bearings are used. Also if you do them up too tight, you are basically rolling the job between three hardened steel rollers, which can become a machining process in itself! Toolpost mounted rollers can be used to generate a very smooth shiny finish to a close tolerance.
I don't have any trouble with brass tipped steady fingers used on steel etc. But have never had occasion to try it on aluminium etc that would mark a bit easier. Trick is to keep plenty of oil on the fingers and don't do them up too tight. Contact and that is all.
I do remember seeing in one of the old books, Sparey possibly, the dodge of inserting a strip of cardboard or gasket jointing material between the fingers and the job and nipping the ends of the strip up between the top and bottom halves of the steady where they clamp together.
But as a project, making both options would be best of both worlds.
Edited By Hopper on 02/12/2022 01:29:59