Is this credible …?

Advert

Is this credible …?

Home Forums The Tea Room Is this credible …?

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 54 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #36960
    Michael Gilligan
    Participant
      @michaelgilligan61133
      Advert
      #612279
      Michael Gilligan
      Participant
        @michaelgilligan61133

        I don’t want to hi-jack Robin’s thread so I am starting this

        … Happy to let it live or die as the forum sees fit

        .

        As “Engineers” … How convinced are we by this statement:

        [quote]

        How can green gas replace fossil fuels?

        Across the UK, we still heat our homes and businesses using fossil fuels – mainly natural gas. About 1% of the gas we supply today is green gas from sustainable sources. The rest is carbon neutralised gas – we invest in carbon reduction programmes to cancel out the carbon burned.

        This isn’t our ideal solution, and at first, we thought the best route was for the country to switch from gas to green electricity for its heating and cooking. However, we now see green gas as the way forward. We believe we can build enough green gas mills – making biomethane from grass cuttings – to replace natural gas in the grid. When the grass grows back, it absorbs the carbon dioxide created by burning green gas. Then we cut the grass and make more green gas, and the sustainable cycle repeats itself.

        [/quote]

        dont know

        MichaelG.

        #612281
        jimmy b
        Participant
          @jimmyb

          Have a look at the Ecotricity accounts, directors etc…………………

          Jim

          #612283
          Martin Connelly
          Participant
            @martinconnelly55370

            The farms where I live grow maize to feed the biogas reactors. It is the quickest way to get biomass apparently. They can grow a crop of maize then something else after it is cropped. You can tell it is for biomass as the cropping just shreds the whole plant and squirts the resulting small pieces into a trailer. I don't think grass grows fast enough unless you choose bamboo and that is a bit hard to control and may be more climate sensitive.

            Martin C

            #612284
            Roderick Jenkins
            Participant
              @roderickjenkins93242
              Posted by Martin Connelly on 04/09/2022 08:28:18:

              The farms where I live grow maize to feed the biogas reactors. It is the quickest way to get biomass apparently. They can grow a crop of maize then something else after it is cropped. You can tell it is for biomass as the cropping just shreds the whole plant and squirts the resulting small pieces into a trailer.

              Round here I think that farmers use the whole maize plant chopped up to make maize silage for cattle feed.

              Rod

              #612289
              Farmboy
              Participant
                @farmboy

                We could possibly produce all our own " green " energy if all farms switched to biomass, solar panels and wind turbines. At least we could keep warm while we are starving to death . . .

                Perhaps we should look at the vast resource we apparently pump into the sea in the form of raw sewage. It would seem more credible to use that as a source of biomass, with the added benefit of using the solid by-product as fertiliser, and the purified water can be recycled into the reservoirs. Our local water company are already supplying treated sewage water through our taps. One side benefit from this is less limescale in the kettle.

                Mike.

                #612292
                larry phelan 1
                Participant
                  @larryphelan1

                  Anyone fancy a beer ?

                  Thought not !cheeky

                  #612295
                  Brian Wood
                  Participant
                    @brianwood45127

                    Ecotricity have a product called Vegan Energy; it is grossly expensive and is plain ridiculous in trying to fool the buyers that this is what comes out of their gas main. Whatever next I wonder!

                    Brian

                    #612296
                    Michael Gilligan
                    Participant
                      @michaelgilligan61133
                      Posted by jimmy b on 04/09/2022 07:59:43:

                      Have a look at the Ecotricity accounts, directors etc…………………

                      .

                      Just watching the video that’s linked in that quote was enough for me, Jim

                      MichaelG.

                      #612305
                      Dalboy
                      Participant
                        @dalboy

                        Does that mean that the government will issue yet another waste bin for grasscheeky

                        #612307
                        blowlamp
                        Participant
                          @blowlamp

                          What happens when the grass doesn't grow?

                          Martin.

                          #612310
                          Martin Kyte
                          Participant
                            @martinkyte99762

                            Well, technically yes. If you burn ancient gas then you release Co2 in a linear process. The more gas you use the more CO2 you make. The challenge is to convert the linear process into a closed cycle. One of the was that this can be done is produce your gas from plants, burn the gas making CO2 and heat, harness photosynthesis in a new generation of plants to draw down CO2 and build organic molecules. Ferment or biodigest the organics to make gas and the loop is closed. The energy input is the sun which drives the cycle and the output is heat to your cooker or gas boiler. Downsides are the amount of land you need for energy rather than food and the overall efficiency of the loop.

                            As far as the carbon offsetting is concerned it's a tricky calculation as both behaviour internationally (does it just move the emmissions and consequences abroad) and nationally do we stop doing all the other things that can help the situation.

                            regards Martin

                            #612313
                            Nicholas Farr
                            Participant
                              @nicholasfarr14254

                              Hi, I was thinking much the same as Martin (Blowlamp) if we get many summers like the one we've just had and all the grass turns brown, will they have to suspend using the gas until they can harvest a new crop of grass. I suppose the fuel used in the harvest is in the carbon equation? I haven't read all of their statement.

                              Regards Nick.

                              #612315
                              blowlamp
                              Participant
                                @blowlamp

                                It's a scam. Since when were grass clippings packed with enough energy to power anything more than a lukewarm composter?

                                Martin.

                                #612316
                                Tony Pratt 1
                                Participant
                                  @tonypratt1

                                  It's the old problem 'heat or eat' if you use all the fields for grass, as farmboy says 'At least we could keep warm while we are starving to death 'sad We are in for some interesting times ahead boys and girls, I wonder what the new ships captain will come up with.

                                  Tony

                                  #612317
                                  Roger Williams 2
                                  Participant
                                    @rogerwilliams2

                                    The green brigade ( theyre definitely green allright ) have been at it again, plus brainless politicians …..

                                    Edited By Roger Williams 2 on 04/09/2022 13:37:01

                                    #612319
                                    File Handle
                                    Participant
                                      @filehandle

                                      Using agricultural land to produce energy reduces the amount of food that we can produce, so solves one problem by creating another. For too long finite resources have been assumed to be infinite. The real problem is always ignored, that there are simply too many people trying to consume these resources. However, if we get to the position of producing an excess of green electricity, this could be used to hydrolyse water to produce hydrogen (and oxygen) to provide a clean fuel.

                                      #612320
                                      J Hancock
                                      Participant
                                        @jhancock95746

                                        Sailing ships and windmills seemed quite successful at the time.

                                        I wonder what is the biggest difference between then …………. and now ?

                                        #612324
                                        Joseph Noci 1
                                        Participant
                                          @josephnoci1
                                          Posted by Keith Wyles on 04/09/2022 13:38:59:

                                          Using agricultural land to produce ……….. However, if we get to the position of producing an excess of green electricity, this could be used to hydrolyse water to produce hydrogen (and oxygen) to provide a clean fuel.

                                          Or just use the excess of green electricity…

                                          #612325
                                          Mike Poole
                                          Participant
                                            @mikepoole82104

                                            I think we need to acknowledge that there are simply too many people on this planet and all the resources are finite. If fusion does solve our energy problem we still need food. We may eventually produce products to sustain life that may be enjoyable to eat as well as nourish us. While we still can I will have a steak and a pint of real ale.

                                            Mike

                                            Edited By Mike Poole on 04/09/2022 14:55:30

                                            #612326
                                            Michael Gilligan
                                            Participant
                                              @michaelgilligan61133

                                              … and nobody’s even mentioned all that concrete they are pouring to make these Green Gas generators.

                                              MichaelG.

                                              #612328
                                              Dalboy
                                              Participant
                                                @dalboy

                                                Why is it that sewage works use methane gas to help treat the raw sewage can't be used in some way as an energy source after all no matter what we eat we all still need to use the loo. Also there is so much Bulls**t in the world gas as an energy source will never be in short demanddevildevildevil

                                                #612330
                                                larry phelan 1
                                                Participant
                                                  @larryphelan1

                                                  Hi Brian,

                                                  Remember that if you repeat something stupid enough, often enough, people actually accept it !cheeky

                                                  #612335
                                                  duncan webster 1
                                                  Participant
                                                    @duncanwebster1

                                                    According to a university in California grass is better at sequestering carbon than trees. Eventually trees either die, fall down and rot away or catch fire and burn away. Either way the captured carbon is released back into the atmosphere, whereas grass creates soil via its roots and that is permanent. As a by product you can have meat. Ploughing to grow cereals and vegetables releases carbon fom the soil, you don't have to plough permanent grassland

                                                    #612340
                                                    Joseph Noci 1
                                                    Participant
                                                      @josephnoci1
                                                      Posted by Mike Poole on 04/09/2022 14:54:53:

                                                      I think we need to acknowledge that there are simply too many people on this planet and all the resources are finite. If fusion does solve our energy problem we still need food. We may eventually produce products to sustain life that may be enjoyable to eat as well as nourish us. While we still can I will have a steak and a pint of real ale.

                                                      Mike

                                                      Edited By Mike Poole on 04/09/2022 14:55:30

                                                      Soylent Green????

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 54 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up