IS IT A SCAM

Advert

IS IT A SCAM

Home Forums The Tea Room IS IT A SCAM

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 33 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #611048
    Michael Brett 1
    Participant
      @michaelbrett1

      Hi

      Anyone had any dealings with Aliexpress based in China. They are offering many model steam engines for sale at silly prices. Examples , a three cylinder compound for 21.08 or a twin cylinder with boiler for 35.62, both post free from China. Not sure if these are kits or assembled but either way to good to be true.

      Mike

      Advert
      #36956
      Michael Brett 1
      Participant
        @michaelbrett1

        Unbelievable offer

        #611053
        martin haysom
        Participant
          @martinhaysom48469

          take a chance you might be lucky its worth a punt if its something you want

          #611054
          SillyOldDuffer
          Moderator
            @sillyoldduffer

            Aliexpress is a marketplace rather than a single seller, so what's on offer is a mixture of OK and suspicious. A proportion of the deals are dodgy, but it seems the majority are OK.

            UK consumer protection is unenforceable if a purchase goes wrong because this is buying from abroad. And the goods may be untaxed resulting in nasty extra charges when the parcel is checked. Goods may not meet UK safety standards etc. It's risky.

            I prefer to buy from UK suppliers. When I buy abroad to get stuff not sold in the UK, I assume in advance that I will be whacked for customs duty, and that either nothing or rubbish will arrive. All smiles when the goods arrive as advertised, but no tears if it fouls up. I understood the risk and chose to take it.

            If you don't mind a gamble, go for it!

            Dave

            #611066
            Nigel Graham 2
            Participant
              @nigelgraham2

              That does look suspicious but I think more likely cheapskate than fraudulent. The market would be too small to interest the crooks.

              Unless of course the models have been stolen….

              I'd not touch it with a barge-mouse.

              #611067
              Paul Rhodes
              Participant
                @paulrhodes20292

                Michael, double check that the unit price is not for a bulk order of say 500!

                Paul

                #611073
                JasonB
                Moderator
                  @jasonb

                  Would you really want to buy from a seller that does not even know how many cylinders are on the engine they are selling, photos are also of more than one engine so who knows what you may or may not get

                  2-3 cylinder.jpg

                   

                  The more well established and hopefully a bit more reputable far eastern suppliers have that 3-cylinder engine up for $799.99 so I doubt you will get one for 20 quid. $599.99 for the twin

                   

                  Edited By JasonB on 24/08/2022 18:53:21

                  #611074
                  JasonB
                  Moderator
                    @jasonb

                    Ah I've got it now, when you open the 1tem it is showing £21.08 and there is a little photo of the wooden base with a red box round it.

                    Click the photo next to it for the 3cyl and prce is £750, click the one for the 2cyl and that is £550.

                    So question is do you want a bit of wood for £21crying 2

                    spam.jpg

                    And to think that some members moan when us moderators remove links to these sitesdevil

                     

                    Edited By JasonB on 24/08/2022 19:14:04

                    #611087
                    lee webster
                    Participant
                      @leewebster72680

                      Hmmm, a piece of wood for £21.08. Sounds good!

                      #611089
                      JasonB
                      Moderator
                        @jasonb

                        Does say it's Rosewood, hopefully that is just the colour of the stain as CITES may not be too happy

                        #611100
                        Jeff Dayman
                        Participant
                          @jeffdayman43397

                          It is sometimes very difficult to tell on Alley express exactly what it is you are buying, and how many, for the stated cost. I have had a few purchases from them that were very cheap and acceptable quality and the expected qty. However other orders were ultra low quality and wrong qty, or never showed up. Caveat Emptor in the wild west show that is Alley express.

                          The worst one was a pair of shoes my wife found there, and wanted to order. We ordered them at a reasonable but not low cost. 5 weeks later a box showed up with one left shoe. She's not good at hopping on one foot so overall this purchase went Tango Uniform fast. No response to refund requests or returns enquires – all of a sudden no one in their customer service dept speaks English! ( it's like a Benny Hill skit really)

                          #611110
                          Chris Crew
                          Participant
                            @chriscrew66644

                            I received an email informing me that some beautiful Ukranian girls were just waiting to meet me and make my life even more wonderful than it ever could be with SWMBO. As I was going to be attending the Huddersfield Jazz Guitar Festival, which co-incidentally was being held at the Ukranian Centre in the town, I thought that I might just meet a couple of these beauties there and that they would be all over me like a rash. Unfortunately it didn't happen and I had to be satisfied by listening to some incredibly talented musicians and a jazz rendition of the Ukrainian national anthem. Sometimes I think that these emails may just be a scam although I am sure that in my case the beauties must have been delayed at the airport due to a shortage of baggage handlers. Of course, that must have been the reason, I should have thought about it at the time!

                            Edited By Chris Crew on 24/08/2022 22:09:43

                            #611120
                            Anonymous

                              That takes topic drift to a new level, Chris …. are you sure you are replying to the right thread?

                              #611127
                              Chris Crew
                              Participant
                                @chriscrew66644
                                Posted by Peter Greene 🇨🇦 on 24/08/2022 22:34:41:

                                That takes topic drift to a new level, Chris …. are you sure you are replying to the right thread?

                                Well, I thought I was because I would like to think that with the amount of 'grey matter' that exists in the model engineering fraternity no one would ever be taken in by this nonsense and I thought I might have raised a wry smile along the way. But you are right, maybe I should leave comedy to the professionals. I really must investigate the possibility of getting a humour by-pass operation on the NHS!

                                As regards topic drift, I don't think this comes anywhere near the course navigated by a previous post of mine regarding how much it would be costing me to operate in the workshop. I think we entered the realms of coal versus nuclear versus the environment with some very long treatises on the pros and cons by some obviously well informed and technically well-educated people. All very interesting reading but most of it didn't come close to answering the question.

                                #611128
                                Nigel Graham 2
                                Participant
                                  @nigelgraham2

                                  Bit like that game in I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue:

                                  "This is the answer – what was the question?"

                                  #611134
                                  Paul Kemp
                                  Participant
                                    @paulkemp46892
                                    Posted by Chris Crew on 24/08/2022 22:52:14:

                                    Posted by Peter Greene 🇨🇦 on 24/08/2022 22:34:41:

                                    That takes topic drift to a new level, Chris …. are you sure you are replying to the right thread?

                                    Well, I thought I was because I would like to think that with the amount of 'grey matter' that exists in the model engineering fraternity no one would ever be taken in by this nonsense and I thought I might have raised a wry smile along the way. But you are right, maybe I should leave comedy to the professionals. I really must investigate the possibility of getting a humour by-pass operation on the NHS!

                                    As regards topic drift, I don't think this comes anywhere near the course navigated by a previous post of mine regarding how much it would be costing me to operate in the workshop. I think we entered the realms of coal versus nuclear versus the environment with some very long treatises on the pros and cons by some obviously well informed and technically well-educated people. All very interesting reading but most of it didn't come close to answering the question.

                                    Chris,

                                    I don’t think that’s quite fair regarding your how much does it cost me question, there were several answers giving you ideas on how to measure your electricity usage in the shed. How much that energy actually costs you if you measure it is in your court depending on how much your supplier is charging you and if on variable rate at what time of day you use it. You can estimate it from the ratings of your machines and lights and time the usage or you can measure as suggested. I don’t think anyone could have reasonably been expected to give you a quantified answer in £’s and p’s?

                                    Personally it’s down to cost benefit. How much enjoyment do I get from making stuff and can I afford it, if I can pay the bills I can afford it so I don’t care what it costs. If I can’t afford it then I have to find other savings to support or pack it in.

                                    Paul.

                                    #611135
                                    Chris Crew
                                    Participant
                                      @chriscrew66644

                                      Paul, Yes, a fair cop, I hold my hands up! There was some useful practical advice provided initially, it's just that it seemed to drift into a very technical and controversial debate later on. I did actually find it all very interesting.

                                      #611139
                                      Anonymous
                                        Posted by Michael Brett 1 on 24/08/2022 16:32:15:

                                        Anyone had any dealings with Aliexpress based in China.

                                        If you do go this route, I'd suggest not using a "prime" email address. You *will* get daily spam from AliExpress which you *won't* be able to turn off.

                                        A gmail address will do – gmail's spam filter is pretty good and if you flag it as such will reliably disappear it for you on an ongoing basis.

                                        #611140
                                        Paul Lousick
                                        Participant
                                          @paullousick59116

                                          I always pay for goods which are advertised on Amazon, Ebay, etc thru Paypal.

                                          Their guarantee of a refund if goods are not received is good. I have had a couple of problems with goods not turning up and I got my money back.

                                          #611180
                                          Howi
                                          Participant
                                            @howi
                                            Posted by Michael Brett 1 on 24/08/2022 16:32:15:

                                            Hi

                                            Anyone had any dealings with Aliexpress based in China. They are offering many model steam engines for sale at silly prices. Examples , a three cylinder compound for 21.08 or a twin cylinder with boiler for 35.62, both post free from China. Not sure if these are kits or assembled but either way to good to be true.

                                            Mike

                                            this type of scam is common on Chinese sites – check the advertisement VERY carefully before commiting to buy.

                                            The low price is designed to reel you in and desire to 'get a bargain' clouds your judgement.

                                            If it is too good to be true…………!!!!!!!!!

                                            #611188
                                            SillyOldDuffer
                                            Moderator
                                              @sillyoldduffer
                                              Posted by Chris Crew on 24/08/2022 22:52:14:

                                              Posted by Peter Greene 🇨🇦 on 24/08/2022 22:34:41:

                                              Well, I thought I was because I would like to think that with the amount of 'grey matter' that exists in the model engineering fraternity no one would ever be taken in by this nonsense…

                                              Unfortunately being intelligent isn't enough protection on it's own because people – all of us – jump to conclusions.

                                              The trap springs when the con seems right.

                                              A man rings up claiming to be your bank; maybe he's knows something about you by harvesting data off the internet, legally or illegally. Worst case, he has your account number. Or perhaps he gets the name of the bank right with a lucky guess – not unlikely because most UK customers are with one of 'The Big Four'.

                                              To reassure you he can quote the banks address and phone numbers, perhaps suggesting you hang up and ring back to be sure. When you do, the line is held open, so he can send you the recording of a dial tone, then ringing, and then he's back. Works because most people don't know how the phone system works, have hazy notions of banking methods in general, and probably no experience of bank security processes. Wait 10 minutes and then call someone else before dialling the bank, and remember most banks say 'WE WILL NEVER RING YOU'.

                                              So, extra dangerous when the victim happens to be expecting a call from the real bank because they're already dealing with a concern. Cons haves an exceptionally good chance of biting when a fake call arrives in the middle of a real concern.

                                              To achieve this, a mastermind sets up a call-centre with an auto-dialer continuously working down a list, or ringing random numbers. When someone answers, a human picks up runs through a script, which will occassionally hook someone. When the auto-dialer is working a list, the mastermind will have collected information that helps reassure the victim. As the danger of being successfully reassured rises the more they know, it's important not to blab private information on the internet.

                                              Fraud and computer misuse are responsible for about half of all crime in the UK. Unfortunately the police have not been resourced to deal with it. The problem has been growing for 30 years without recruiting people, or providing equipment and developing skills. Governments are extremely good at passing impressive new laws and very bad at providing the resources needed to enforce them.

                                              Dave

                                              #611215
                                              Chris Crew
                                              Participant
                                                @chriscrew66644

                                                "When you do, the line is held open, so he can send you the recording of a dial tone, then ringing, and then he's back. Works because most people don't know how the phone system works, have hazy notions of banking methods in general, and probably no experience of bank security processes. Wait 10 minutes and then call someone else before dialling"

                                                Dave, I stand to be corrected because I have been out of the telecoms industry for a few years now, but it is my recollection that forward call holding, which was a throwback to the old electro-mechanical exchanges, was eliminated several years ago. I think I know this because, although I had taken a voluntary redundancy from my employer of 38 years, I was requested to assist with the loading of a new build of software on to the exchanges of some OLO's (other licensed operators). I can't comment on the BT build uplift because I was not involved with that program. Although I was not privy to all the details of the uplift, it was my understanding that one of the issues the new build dealt with was that of the bank scam that relied, as you rightly point out, the line being held open by the caller for fake dial tone to be sent to the called party. I don't think this was ever any longer than 20 seconds in the case of System X switches but in any event it was eliminated around 6 or 7 years ago. As I say, I do stand to be corrected on this if someone is still in the industry and if the old narrow-band digital switches even exist anymore.

                                                #611235
                                                SillyOldDuffer
                                                Moderator
                                                  @sillyoldduffer
                                                  Posted by Chris Crew on 25/08/2022 13:52:29:

                                                  "When you do, the line is held open, so he can send you the recording of a dial tone, then ringing, and then he's back. Works because most people don't know how the phone system works, have hazy notions of banking methods in general, and probably no experience of bank security processes. Wait 10 minutes and then call someone else before dialling"

                                                  Dave, I stand to be corrected because I have been out of the telecoms industry for a few years now, but it is my recollection that forward call holding, which was a throwback to the old electro-mechanical exchanges, was eliminated several years ago. …

                                                  I always stand to be corrected too! However, a quick check on the web shows Age Concern give the same warning (mentioned under number spoofing). Haven't tried it though and out of date advice on the internet is a problem. Might try the experiment next time I ring my tech savvy nephew; he's always game for a laugh.

                                                  As usual I missed out the main point of my post, which is victims shouldn't beat themselves up if they get caught by one of these b*st*rds. Bad enough to be robbed without being left feeling one was a dimwit as well!

                                                  Dave

                                                  #611238
                                                  lee webster
                                                  Participant
                                                    @leewebster72680

                                                    Dave, If your nephew is game for a laugh try this on him. I did it to a friend many years ago and he fell for it.

                                                    Phone your nephew and tell him you are writing out a new contacts directory and could he give you his number, you can't find it. It might work, but be ready for a great deal of swearing!

                                                    #611242
                                                    Steve Pavey
                                                    Participant
                                                      @stevepavey65865

                                                      Seems to be a lot of prejudice about AliExpress, possibly from people who have never bought anything from them. I built a laser CNC last year using parts sourced almost entirely from there. I think in total I placed around 50 separate orders for various components, ranging from bags of machine screws for next to nothing to a 100watt Cloudray CO2 laser tube for around £500. I can’t recall a problem with any of the orders, apart from a few of them taking a couple of months to arrive. There is actually a system for dealing with orders that go wrong, as AliExpress clearly rely on their suppliers being reliable and trustworthy.

                                                      As for quality, I have no complaints with what I have purchased, and it’s as least as good as any of the Chinese stuff that U.K. sellers supply. Of course you can buy rubbish from AliExpress, especially if you can’t be bothered to do a bit of research. Equally you can buy rubbish from U.K. suppliers – it just costs more.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 33 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums The Tea Room Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up