Posted by Andrew Tinsley on 19/03/2022 09:41:14:
… All the petition is asking is that all three heating fuels should be treated in a similar manner. I don't really care if that means everyone should pay market price.
Andrew.
Another case of be very careful what you ask for! At the moment oil is a cheap way of heating a home, and I guess many are signing this petition because they want that happy state to continue. They correctly foresee oil prices following gas and electricity upwards, and think the government should protect them inline with other consumers. (Not that the government's buffer is that generous – a major part of it is a loan.)
But oh dear, the petition has oil users sticking their heads over the parapet. It draws attention to a disparity that government might feel obliged to correct, and the petitioners haven't considered the alternative ways that might be done. One way of fixing the issue is to subsidise oil users as they wish, another is to tax oil in line with other energy sources. As large numbers of voters might prefer everyone to pay their way and government policy is to reduce carbon footprint, it's not unlikely fairness will be achieved by taxing heating oil.
A similar booby trap caught residents in North Bristol a few years ago. The locals got fed up with visitors to UWE and other large offices parking outside their homes. Complaining to the council resulted in a Residents Parking Scheme requiring Residents to pay a hefty annual fee. Many people believe the public road outside their home is theirs to park on – it's not!
I suspect the best outcome for oil burning home-owners is for the petition to be discussed by a sub-committee and quietly dropped. I don't suppose the politicians want to upset another group of voters so it's to their advantage to let sleeping dogs doze on. The sleeping dogs in this case are the large number of voters who dislike subsidies in principle and those already paying more to heat their homes than the petitioners.
Petitions or not, it's likely Government Policy on energy regulation is already being reconsidered. The UK has enjoyed 30 years of price stability but that appears to be coming to an end due to mix of UK sources becoming exhausted, the ever increasing demand for energy abroad, and the rise of cheap but intermittent Green electricity. The existing regulatory framework and tax system probably needs major adjustment. We're already seeing a drive to replace gas and oil with heat pumps.
Dave