MIG to TIG

Advert

MIG to TIG

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #280927
    AJW
    Participant
      @ajw

      I occasionally use my Clarke Turbo 130 MIG welder which over the years has done a good job, if there is a problem it is usually operator error!
      Toying with the idea of a TIG welder and have found a few articles regarding using the MIG converted ie, no wire , tip converted to hold the tungsten electrode and using an appropriate gas, argon and reversing current.
      Any of you guys had a dabble with a conversion, and how successful was it!

      Alan

      Edited By AJW on 28/01/2017 22:44:27

      Advert
      #34341
      AJW
      Participant
        @ajw

        MIG welder conversion

        #280928
        ronan walsh
        Participant
          @ronanwalsh98054

          I wouldn't bother, have a look at the R-Tech range of welders, they have a small dc tig plant for not much money, three year warranty. They are chinese, but very good. Also have a look at doubleboost's channel on youtube.

          #280930
          John Reese
          Participant
            @johnreese12848

            For Tig and stick you need a constant current welder. For Mig and flux core it needs to be constant voltage. In the past there were some wire feeders made to work with constant current welders but the arc wasn't very stable. With modern technology you can change from CC mode to CV with the flip of a switch.

            #281014
            AJW
            Participant
              @ajw

              This sounds like I shouldn’t bother!
              Looked at the r-tech range but that’s not my idea of not much money!!
              Might be worth getting a cheap stick welder for the constant current supply?

              Alan

              #281022
              ronan walsh
              Participant
                @ronanwalsh98054
                Posted by AJW on 29/01/2017 13:10:14:
                This sounds like I shouldn't bother!
                Looked at the r-tech range but that's not my idea of not much money!!
                Might be worth getting a cheap stick welder for the constant current supply?

                Alan

                Compare their prices to miller, lincoln or fronius and suddenly they seem extremely reasonably priced. You can buy a dc stick welder, and run a gas line separately from an argon bottle, to your tig torch.

                #281147
                Nicholas Farr
                Participant
                  @nicholasfarr14254
                  Posted by ronan walsh on 29/01/2017 14:11:10:

                  Posted by AJW on 29/01/2017 13:10:14:
                  This sounds like I shouldn't bother!
                  Looked at the r-tech range but that's not my idea of not much money!!
                  Might be worth getting a cheap stick welder for the constant current supply?

                  Alan

                  Compare their prices to miller, lincoln or fronius and suddenly they seem extremely reasonably priced. You can buy a dc stick welder, and run a gas line separately from an argon bottle, to your tig torch.

                  Hi, the old company where I used to work, over ten years ago now, just purchased a TIG torch, a HF unit and an add on rectifier and just coupled it up to one of the AC welders, it also allowed it to be used for aluminium welding, by not using the rectifier. This was of course, when TIG welding started to become popular. It worked then, so no reason not to work now, but the biggest issue you would maybe find now is a stand alone HF unit at a reasonable cost.

                  Regards Nick.

                  #281161
                  ronan walsh
                  Participant
                    @ronanwalsh98054

                    Yes Nick, it was the same in the company i served my time. However things have moved on. I asked the welding supplier to my company about ten years ago to get me a price for a ac/dc tig welder. The price was huge, about four/five months wages at the time i seem to recall. But now i can buy a chinese plant to the same spec for less than two weeks wages.

                    It won't be a cheap falling to bits pile of junk either, and come with a fairly long warranty and be reliable. I bought an r-tech plasma cutter a year ago for a large job, worked the tar out of it in tough conditions and its still perfect.

                    But i suppose no matter how cheap something is, there will still be those who want it cheaper.

                    #281163
                    AJW
                    Participant
                      @ajw

                      Thanks for all your inputs, I (obviously wrongly)! thought I could experiment with this method on the cheap using my existing MIG as the main cost item hoping to add a few periferal bits and be having a go.

                      Alan

                      #281178
                      Michael Horner
                      Participant
                        @michaelhorner54327
                        Posted by Nicholas Farr on 29/01/2017 22:38:03:

                        Posted by ronan walsh on 29/01/2017 14:11:10:

                        Posted by AJW on 29/01/2017 13:10:14:
                        This sounds like I shouldn't bother!
                        Looked at the r-tech range but that's not my idea of not much money!!
                        Might be worth getting a cheap stick welder for the constant current supply?

                        Alan

                        Compare their prices to miller, lincoln or fronius and suddenly they seem extremely reasonably priced. You can buy a dc stick welder, and run a gas line separately from an argon bottle, to your tig torch.

                        Hi, the old company where I used to work, over ten years ago now, just purchased a TIG torch, a HF unit and an add on rectifier and just coupled it up to one of the AC welders, it also allowed it to be used for aluminium welding, by not using the rectifier. This was of course, when TIG welding started to become popular. It worked then, so no reason not to work now, but the biggest issue you would maybe find now is a stand alone HF unit at a reasonable cost.

                        Regards Nick.

                        Hi Nick

                        Do you remember the output voltage of the welder? I have the bits you mentioned (made my own rectifier) but couldn't get it too work. I could get the TIG box to work if I plugged it into a 50 volt PSU (not a welding one). Will all TIG boxes work off AC? Never got round to trying it in case the magic smoke escaped. I often get ideas above my abilities!

                        Cheers Michael.

                        #281196
                        Muzzer
                        Participant
                          @muzzer

                          I don't think HF units are made any more these days, as modern inverter sources with built-in HF are so cheap – probably little different from the cost of an HF unit. The "HF unit" includes the various functions you need to convert an AC or DC source to TIG. Several decades ago, TIG equipment was new and very expensive, so HF units were developed to give an alternative solution based on existing welding sources.

                          As mentioned, for TIG you need a constant current (CC) source ie possibly a stick welder. In the old days, AC sources could be little more than a (variable current) transformer, so AC was easier to generate than DC. These days it's the other way around – inverter sources will produce DC output and converting that back to an AC output adds cost.

                          The old HF units contain a spark generator and a coupler (high frequency high current transformer) to inject this high frequency, high voltage onto the output to the torch. That enables the arc to start without having to touch the electrode to the work, which would risk contaminating the tungsten. Generally, once the arc is established, the spark generator is turned off if you are running DC, whereas it's helpful to leave it running for AC welding.

                          The other function generally included is the gas control – and water if you have a high current, water-cooled torch (typically for over 150A or so). So there is generally a couple of solenoids, one for the argon and one for water. To control these you need a switch on the torch (or a foot pedal) and ideally a timer to continue the gas for a few seconds after stopping the arc. Ideally this switch would also control the welding source….

                          Doesn't sound much but these features are the basic difference between a simple constant current source and a TIG welder. The main feature missing from this approach is any form of remote current control, eg the ability for the operator to turn the current up and down (and on and off). You'd need some sort of contactor to turn the welder on and off at the very least.

                          If you plan to weld steel you should rectify the output. HF units work with DC or AC. If you don't rectify the output, half of the output power (heat) will end up in the torch. Also bear in mind that you need pure argon (or argon helium mix). The argon – CO2 mix used for MIG is not suitable.

                          True enough, you could have a go at making your own HF unit if you have a stick welder. But it will be very crude and take a fair bit of effort. Apart from proving that it can be done, it won't be a very productive use of your time. At the very best, if you managed to find an HF unit for free or very cheap it may get you started and then you may be able to decide if TIG is for you. I used to have an HF unit but threw it way because nobody uses them any more…

                          Murray

                          #281360
                          Nicholas Farr
                          Participant
                            @nicholasfarr14254
                            Posted by Michael Horner on 30/01/2017 07:33:45:

                            Posted by Nicholas Farr on 29/01/2017 22:38:03:

                            Posted by ronan walsh on 29/01/2017 14:11:10:

                            Posted by AJW on 29/01/2017 13:10:14:
                            This sounds like I shouldn't bother!
                            Looked at the r-tech range but that's not my idea of not much money!!
                            Might be worth getting a cheap stick welder for the constant current supply?

                            Alan

                            Compare their prices to miller, lincoln or fronius and suddenly they seem extremely reasonably priced. You can buy a dc stick welder, and run a gas line separately from an argon bottle, to your tig torch.

                            Hi, the old company where I used to work, over ten years ago now, just purchased a TIG torch, a HF unit and an add on rectifier and just coupled it up to one of the AC welders, it also allowed it to be used for aluminium welding, by not using the rectifier. This was of course, when TIG welding started to become popular. It worked then, so no reason not to work now, but the biggest issue you would maybe find now is a stand alone HF unit at a reasonable cost.

                            Regards Nick.

                            Hi Nick

                            Do you remember the output voltage of the welder? I have the bits you mentioned (made my own rectifier) but couldn't get it too work. I could get the TIG box to work if I plugged it into a 50 volt PSU (not a welding one). Will all TIG boxes work off AC? Never got round to trying it in case the magic smoke escaped. I often get ideas above my abilities!

                            Cheers Michael.

                            Hi Michael, the welder it was used on was a BOC Quasi-Arc ACP 450 oil cooled with a switchable 100/80 OCV and the HF unit was powered from 230 V mains via a standard 13 A plug. The torch was a BOC TW 450 water cooled one. The set up was extensively used on aluminium lorry tankers, and as Muzzer points out, it had a high power single pole contactor in the welding lead line.

                            Muzzer has described the set up in great detail.

                            Regards Nick.

                            #281383
                            Michael Horner
                            Participant
                              @michaelhorner54327

                              Thanks Muzzer and Nick

                              Probably stick them on Ebay on the next clear out.

                              The arc welder has aluminium wire in the transformer, it's rated at 200 amp but I don't know for how long. I think this means it's not a proper one. I suspect the OC voltage wasn't high enough to drive the TIG box

                              Cheers Michael.

                            Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
                            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                            Advert

                            Latest Replies

                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                            View full reply list.

                            Advert

                            Newsletter Sign-up