Finding star point

Advert

Finding star point

Home Forums Electronics in the Workshop Finding star point

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #633267
    John Haine
    Participant
      @johnhaine32865

      A friend in the village has acquired a 60s vintage Wadkin cabinet saw, a very nice bit of woodworking kit. It has a 2hp 3ph Brook motor which is star connected.

      pxl_20230213_123645052.jpg

      I was wondering if anyone here has specific experience of finding the star point on these motors please? In particular just how much dismantling is needed to get at it.

      Edited By John Haine on 13/02/2023 13:35:49

      Advert
      #32324
      John Haine
      Participant
        @johnhaine32865
        #633276
        john fletcher 1
        Participant
          @johnfletcher1

          Once you have the motor on the bench and using a scriber put scratch marks across both end shields to stator, two lots one end and single the other. Theses marks will help you when reassembling the motor, then its a matter of very carefully dismantling the motor. Its not at all difficult to dismantle a motor, its the reassembling, getting it to run smooth, hence the scratch marks. Brook often have 4 threaded through bolts with a 2BA thread each end. Be very careful when withdrawing the rotor not to scratch the stator windings. Very recently (maybe last week) some one on HERE has posted a series of pictures on how he located the STAR point, in fact there been several lots. You are looking for a destinctive lump, often at the non drive end, using a sharp knife open it up. If you have got it wrong look else where, its some times a bit difficult to locate . You can of course go to a rewind shop, they will know for certain. You will need some cotton tape, cotton string, three lengths of flexible wire and some air drying varnish, all available on the favourite purchasing site. Do remember to identify the new ends, but as always, there is away should you forget. John

          #633279
          John Haine
          Participant
            @johnhaine32865

            Thanks John, that's helpful.. I know the basics though have never tried it. Do you have any specific experience with a Brook motor please?

            #633282
            Brian Wood
            Participant
              @brianwood45127

              Hello John,

              I've done this twice, once on an American made motor of 1/2 HP, the second time was on a Chinese 3/4 HP motor, both single phase. I used Jim Cox's excellent WPS book for guidance and got it right both times.

              Do be sure you are using high temperature varnish when soaking the windings and binding things up

              Best of luck Brian

              #633285
              DC31k
              Participant
                @dc31k
                Posted by John Haine on 13/02/2023 15:01:16:

                Thanks John, that's helpful.. I know the basics though have never tried it.

                Sometimes it is a case of playing it by ear. Even motors from the same manufacturer might differ slightly.

                Perhaps remove the two end bells and the rotor, take a good photo of both ends, clearly identifying which is which, and post them here if the star point is not obvious.

                If it is old and has been used for woodworking, a very good clean and blow out will do it a power of good.

                In addition to the items mentioned above, you will need some insulation sleeve. Standard heatshrink is not really the right stuff. The siliconised fibreglass sleeving is good. Similarly, the new tails you connect are better if made from heat resistant wire. If you can find an old electric cooker or oven, the wires and sleeving used in it are ideal. A source for new material is commercial catering spares/repairs places.

                #633296
                duncan webster 1
                Participant
                  @duncanwebster1

                  I did it on a RJH Ferret grinder, can't remember make of motor but British. I was warned off from using it on vfd by the manufacturers, can't remember why, something to do with stray currents comes to mind. However I converted it to run off a capacitor setup, which worked fine. The advice was to silver solder new tails after finding and separating the star point, must be to do with potential heat. I chickened and used soft solder, perhaps crimping with a proper tool would be OK

                  #633297
                  Clive Foster
                  Participant
                    @clivefoster55965

                    As I recall things the Brook I did had the star point easily visible and pretty much outside the winding lacing. Foot and paint style seemed similar to yours so probably of same era.

                    Older motors seemed to have less prominent joint settled down into the windings and well laced. Presumably a vibration thing.

                    Clive

                    #633299
                    John Haine
                    Participant
                      @johnhaine32865

                      Thanks Clive, that's encouraging!

                      #633311
                      duncan webster 1
                      Participant
                        @duncanwebster1
                        Posted by duncan webster on 13/02/2023 17:18:38:

                        I did it on a RJH Ferret grinder, can't remember make of motor but British. I was warned off from using it on vfd by the manufacturers, can't remember why, something to do with stray currents comes to mind. However I converted it to run off a capacitor setup, which worked fine. The advice was to silver solder new tails after finding and separating the star point, must be to do with potential heat. I chickened and used soft solder, perhaps crimping with a proper tool would be OK

                        Finally remembered, Steinmetz connection, one capacitor described in workshop practice book. Can scan relevant pages if interested.

                        #633386
                        john fletcher 1
                        Participant
                          @johnfletcher1

                          Back again John, The conversion article Star/Delta I referred to, was dated 5/10/2015 it contained excellent pictures, unfortunately I don't know how to get to retrieve it, perhaps some one will help out. John

                          #633390
                          Mike Poole
                          Participant
                            @mikepoole82104

                            Star point

                            was this the thread you had in mind John?

                            Mike

                            #633543
                            John Haine
                            Participant
                              @johnhaine32865

                              Thanks for all the info, lots to go on. I've also asked a local rewind place for a quote, but overall it looks like a fairly straightforward job to do myself. And I think we are definitely intending to use a VFD rather than a capacitor Kluge.

                              #633630
                              Pete Rimmer
                              Participant
                                @peterimmer30576

                                Usually the star point is easy to find because it is tied on top of the windings after the motor is wound and then tested. The winder will leave all of the winding ends accessible, test them individually, then connect, insulate and tie them in to the winding before laquering/encapsulating so that they don't move and rub through the insulation. The star point will usually be and obvious junction of 3 winding ends if it is not fully taped over or appear as a large bulge if it is.

                                #633774
                                Bob Worsley
                                Participant
                                  @bobworsley31976

                                  Just wondered why you thought it was star connected? Yes, 400V, but could also be delta connected at 400V?

                                  Look at the three leads, do they join with one or two winding wires? If one, star, if two, delta.

                                  #633775
                                  John Haine
                                  Participant
                                    @johnhaine32865

                                    It is star connected.

                                    #633776
                                    duncan webster 1
                                    Participant
                                      @duncanwebster1

                                      Place I worked had a big circular saw that you started up in star connection then switched to delta. I presume it was to reduce starting current on a high inertia (big circular saw) load.

                                      #633802
                                      Mike Poole
                                      Participant
                                        @mikepoole82104

                                        2hp is a small motor that would normally be quite happily started direct on and typically wound for 400V star, when motors get larger star delta becomes useful and the motors may be wound for star at 690V and delta at 400V. Electronic soft start units are probably very competitive with a contactor based star delta starter these days. As larger motors will not be run from a single phase input VFD then winding for 230V delta is not very practical as it will not be possible to use star delta starting.

                                        Mike

                                      Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
                                      • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                      Advert

                                      Latest Replies

                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                      Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                      View full reply list.

                                      Advert

                                      Newsletter Sign-up