Posted by David Siddle 1 on 28/03/2019 09:46:50:
… What about contactor/circuit breaker? Are these strictly necessary in a home workshop?
…
I looked up the contactor Mitsubishi, (the VFD manufacturers), recommended and it was pretty pricey. Is there a cheaper alternative?
The contactor is a safety feature and no-one today can tell you it's OK not to fit one. It's down to you to assess the risks, and these have to be taken much more seriously if someone else is involved. Do you ever have visitors in the workshop? Is there an insurance problem if you burn the house down due to a home-made electrical installation?
That said, many older machine tools have unacceptably poor safety features by modern standards and people use them privately without ending up in hospital, being persecuted by the HSE, or getting sued by the neighbours. Exposed gears and belts whizzing round on machines with dodgy 1925 electrics and no interlocks are manageable provided the owner takes reasonable care. Although the hobby has it's risks, I think they're relatively small. Model Engineering is considerably safer than Amateur Radio where chaps get killed and maimed falling off masts and roof-tops, or having heavy aerials land on them, plus the odd RF burn, electrocution, and lightning strike. Let's not mention microlights, horse-riding, or motor-bikes!
I would definitely build Mitsubishi's recommended circuit if your machine already has safety interlocks because deliberately rendering interlocks ineffective to save money isn't smart. Conversely, if an older machine doesn't have safety interlocks, adding a contactor is likely to be a waste of time.
For H&S and commercial reasons Mitsubishi are unlikely to recommend anything but the very best contactor. There are plenty of cheaper alternatives available: prices start just below £14 on Amazon, other suppliers available.
Dave