What grade of aluminium is best for making a pulley?

Advert

What grade of aluminium is best for making a pulley?

Home Forums Materials What grade of aluminium is best for making a pulley?

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #30278
    Andrew Tinsley
    Participant
      @andrewtinsley63637
      Advert
      #639981
      Andrew Tinsley
      Participant
        @andrewtinsley63637

        I have, at long last, run out of my hoard of Picador pulleys. So I need to make some.

        What is the recommended grade of aluminium?

        Andrew.

        #639983
        old mart
        Participant
          @oldmart

          Any of the 6—- or 7—- series would do they are much better to machine than the pure stuff.

          #639986
          Chris Evans 6
          Participant
            @chrisevans6

            6082 is my go to grade. nice to machine

            #639987
            Andrew Tinsley
            Participant
              @andrewtinsley63637

              Thanks guys, I shall get some on order!

              Andrew.

              #639990
              Emgee
              Participant
                @emgee
                Posted by Chris Evans 6 on 02/04/2023 18:09:46:

                6082 is my go to grade. nice to machine

                Hi Chris

                I usually end up with a birds-nest of swarf when taking light cuts but the chipbreaker does work better with deep cuts, this is using ground inserts, HSS or diamond tipped don't perform any better.

                What's your secret to machining 6082 ?

                Emgee

                Edited By Emgee on 02/04/2023 18:38:23

                #639996
                Bob Brown 1
                Participant
                  @bobbrown1
                  Posted by Emgee on 02/04/2023 18:37:51:

                  What's your secret to machining 6082 ?

                  Emgee

                  Paraffin other wise you get a build up on the tool.

                  #639998
                  SillyOldDuffer
                  Moderator
                    @sillyoldduffer

                    How critical is the application in terms of load and RPM? Aluminium pulleys are usually cast, not fabricated, because die castings are less likely to burst. And if the pulley will be worked hard, or take snatch loads, the alloy needs to be tough enough not to fail at the shaft fixing.

                    No problem making small diameter slow RPM pulleys from 6082 stock where the stresses are low, but I'd buy the commercial product if the pulley was to be spun fast or heavily loaded. Big stress difference between a 3" pulley fitted to a 1000W lathe chugging along at 600rpm, and the same item pushed over 6000 rpm by a 50kW car engine.

                    A genuine Picador pulley is probably significantly stronger than a home-turned copy.

                    Dave

                    #640007
                    old mart
                    Participant
                      @oldmart

                      If the rpm is critical, then 7075 T6 would be strongest easily available. But the 6082 would be far superior to those ancient Picador cast ones.

                      #640009
                      duncan webster 1
                      Participant
                        @duncanwebster1

                        I think Picardor pullets were mazak, not the strongest material known to man.

                        #640011
                        Emgee
                        Participant
                          @emgee
                          Posted by Bob Brown 1 on 02/04/2023 19:40:42:

                          Posted by Emgee on 02/04/2023 18:37:51:

                          What's your secret to machining 6082 ?

                          Emgee

                          Paraffin other wise you get a build up on the tool.

                          Thanks Bob, Yes certainly helps to prevent build up on the tool if you use paraffin, WD40 or mist coolant but from my experience it doesn't stop bird-nesting and if you are running at 1800rpm without full enclosure it gets very messy.

                          Emgee

                          #640013
                          JasonB
                          Moderator
                            @jasonb

                            A pulley from 6082 T6 would be my preference over an unknow commercial one, tensile strength of the bar is 50 to 100% more than typical cast alloys. One only has to look at those chipped pullies that we see here from time to time to see another disadvantage of cast ones

                            Edited By JasonB on 03/04/2023 07:30:21

                            #640017
                            Chris Evans 6
                            Participant
                              @chrisevans6

                              Machining 6082-T6 with "GT" inserts seems to go well with a spray of suds oil to prevent build up on the tool. Birds nesting of swarf is the nature of this type of material, I tend to stop the lathe after every pass or two and clear the area.

                              #640022
                              Neil Lickfold
                              Participant
                                @neillickfold44316

                                and For 6082, need a geometry with a short chip breaker. It will curl with a light cut, but a deeper cut like 2x the tip radius and a feedrate of 3/4 of the radius to the radius per rev. So a 0.2mm radius , 0.15mm/rev to 0.2mm/rev, and cut depth of 0.4 Ø0.8mm cuts. Peck the cuts if it starts bird nesting. So hand feed and stop every .5mm of travel if the tools you have do not make curl chips. I use a kyocera CCGT09T302MP-CK PR1725 or PR1425 grade. I have them in the 09 and 06 sized inserts to suite the boring bars and the external holders.

                                For getting down into the pulley sides there are some very high rake 35 deg inserts like the VCGX110304 in the 0.4mm radius is the more common in these, but Iscar make a very good insert that is in the 0.2mm radius and also a very high rake for aluminium and plastics.

                                #640055
                                duncan webster 1
                                Participant
                                  @duncanwebster1

                                  Several people have stated that a high speed pulley will need a very strong material. It's worth doing some sums. This is not going to cause me any sleepless nights, less than half a ton/sqin. It's not surprising really, at the other end of an IC engine is a much larger flywheel, which is made out of a much denser material which seems to survive OK. In case you feel like exploring further note that some sources use the reciprocal of Poisson's ratio, so instead of (1-u) they have (1-1/m), which causes a bit of confusion.

                                   

                                  pulley.jpg

                                  Edited By duncan webster on 03/04/2023 13:49:28

                                  #640074
                                  Andrew Tinsley
                                  Participant
                                    @andrewtinsley63637

                                    I did take Dave's warning with a very large pinch of salt. So thanks Duncan for the supporting calculation!

                                    Andrew.

                                    #640086
                                    Tim Stevens
                                    Participant
                                      @timstevens64731

                                      Dave warns against 'fabricated' pulleys, but what exactly does he mean by it? To me, fabricated implies a built-up structure – the Forth Bridge is fabricated from steel tubes and rivets. But the pulleys we need (I think) are one-piece, whether cast or forged or turned from an extrusion.

                                      Experts always know what they mean, but they need to remember that we are not all experts at what they are expert at.

                                      Regards, Tim

                                      #655846
                                      andrew lyner
                                      Participant
                                        @andrewlyner71257

                                        On the subject of pulleys, I've just turned a couple of pulleys, about 30mm diameter and picked out a bar of 30mm 'aluminium' from my box of bits. I don't remember where I got it or the spec. I tried to clean up the end of the bar with it centred up and I kept getting that chi, ch, ch noise every rev – just like it was off centre. I carried turning down and couldn't;t get rid of a patch of crystalline looking stuff. Looking at the end of the rod, that whitish region went down several mm. I tried different tools but same result.

                                        Is this a common problem? It's of no consequence for my inconsequential project but it was interesting. I guess you'll all tell me to use Metal For U to source my stuff. fair enough but eBay is a convenient source of one-off bits with no postage and the pukkah sources have a minimum quantity etc. etc.

                                        Same problem with some cheap steel plate; drilling one particular hole gave graunchy noises and chewed up the drill ends. Snatched at the pilot drill and I feared it would break. Seven other holes were no prob. (I used cutting oil, a pilot and fast speed).

                                        #655878
                                        Martin Connelly
                                        Participant
                                          @martinconnelly55370

                                          The scrap bins in the raw material stores where I worked always had some cut off ends of bar stock in them. They were cut off and discarded due to the inclusions in them. As the stock is cold formed the ends curl over towards the centre and in the worst cases some of the rubbish on the end face ends up being squeezed into the material where it is hidden. These discarded ends were usually in the region of 100mm long to be on the safe side. A stockist who is cutting off parts and sending them to a customer does not want the cost of too much waste so would probably cut off the minimum to remove the curled over end and no more. The result is if you get the first piece cut off a length of stock there is a risk of the end face scale and corrosion being embedded in the material to a significant depth.

                                          Martin C

                                          #655882
                                          andrew lyner
                                          Participant
                                            @andrewlyner71257

                                            Hi Martin

                                            Thanks. That makes sense. No problems for me in they case but a 'proper job' needs a good supplier. I'll see what the rest of that bar holds for me. The other end may be fine.

                                            Andrew

                                            "Inclusions". I know that term from jewellery.

                                            #655883
                                            Michael Gilligan
                                            Participant
                                              @michaelgilligan61133
                                              Posted by Tim Stevens on 03/04/2023 20:31:34:

                                              Dave warns against 'fabricated' pulleys, but what exactly does he mean by it? …

                                              .

                                              I suspect that Dave just meant ‘fabricated’ to mean ‘made by machining’ … but only he can confirm or refute that.

                                              It is, however quite possible to fabricate Vee pulleys by using two truncated cones … either fixed together or keyed, with an adjustment mechanism.

                                              MichaelG.

                                              #655976
                                              SillyOldDuffer
                                              Moderator
                                                @sillyoldduffer
                                                Posted by Michael Gilligan on 10/08/2023 09:59:45:

                                                Posted by Tim Stevens on 03/04/2023 20:31:34:

                                                Dave warns against 'fabricated' pulleys, but what exactly does he mean by it? …

                                                .

                                                I suspect that Dave just meant ‘fabricated’ to mean ‘made by machining’ … but only he can confirm or refute that.

                                                It is, however quite possible to fabricate Vee pulleys by using two truncated cones … either fixed together or keyed, with an adjustment mechanism.

                                                MichaelG.

                                                It is what I meant.

                                                The grain structure of extruded or rolled metal stock runs longitudinally, and making stock stronger lengthwise than across the diameter. Not ideal slicing stock to make pulleys, because pulley forces run the other way – centre out

                                                Stock is strong enough for a slow turning, small diameter pulley, but unwise for a large diameter pulley spinning at high RPM. It's better to make pulleys with a process that makes the item strong in the right direction, such as by casting or drop forging. In the past the flywheels on big steam engines often burst because they weren't strong enough.

                                                Dave

                                              Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
                                              • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                              Advert

                                              Latest Replies

                                              Home Forums Materials Topics

                                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                              View full reply list.

                                              Advert

                                              Newsletter Sign-up