Just Started a 4 inch Foster

Advert

Just Started a 4 inch Foster

Home Forums Traction engines Just Started a 4 inch Foster

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 32 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #254161
    Mr Mike
    Participant
      @mrmike

      Hi today I made the first part for my 4 inch foster agricultural engine. I did my research, had to wait for my plans due to Dorset Steam fair but today I finally made the first step. I’m starting with the front hubs, axle and wheels. Metal has been ordered so all I could do until it arrives is knock out a front tow pin and the front axle pin. Next it will be the front hubs and axle both of these are being machined from scratch.

      I’m fortunate enough to have a lathe and milling machine at home and access to a full machine shop at work. Work also has a few very knowledgeable and experienced people so help is readily available should I need it. Being an engineer I plan to fabricate as much as I can. I was wondering if any users here have any tips for me, perhaps such things as known drawing errors. All advice is greatly appreciated.

      Advert
      #2844
      Mr Mike
      Participant
        @mrmike
        #254188
        JasonB
        Moderator
          @jasonb

          Ther was a long list of errors for the Foster but not sure if it is still up on the net as teh guy who's site it was on passed away. I'll have a look.

          Welcome to the forum too.

          J

          #254189
          JasonB
          Moderator
            @jasonb

            Here you go, long list is also on Traction Talk Forum but you will justy have to register to view this thread. Also a very good forum for all things traction engine related, probably a few build threads of your engine in the miniatures section too.

            #254214
            Diane Carney
            Moderator
              @dianecarney30678

              And lots of general and generic hints and tips ongoing in Chris Gunn's article on the 4 inch Garrett 4CD. Not specific, of course, but worth a look

              Diane

              #254258
              Graham Titman
              Participant
                @grahamtitman81812

                Hi Mike if you click this link it should take you to a page of the errors Jason was wrote about i don't think you have to log.

                http://modeleng.proboards.com/thread/3225/errors-on-drawings?page=2

                Graham

                #254332
                Mr Mike
                Participant
                  @mrmike

                  Wow er thanks I think, it’d appear there is no end of errors. I had noticed the drawings were vague in places. No big problem as like I said I plan to fab as much as I can so if I plan ahead all should be good. Can any reading be recommend? Bearing in mind I’m new to steam. Thanks sincerely for the help.

                  #254344
                  JasonB
                  Moderator
                    @jasonb

                    Some of the items of that list are more to do with detail than real errors, just depends how true to the original you want to build.

                    Best book on the subject is "Scale Model Traction Engine Design & Construction" by Edward George. ISBN 0 9548393 0 7 Out of print a couple of years ago but the odd one does come up for sale and worth paying whatever is being asked for it.

                    As I mentioned above there are many good build threads on TT forum in the miniatures section, ave a look through those, the guy who compiled that list is also on there should you have any queries.

                    #254487
                    Mr Mike
                    Participant
                      @mrmike

                      Sincerely thanks for your help. I’ve registered with TT but the section on model engines requires a donation which since for some reason I haven’t received my activation email(it’s not in my spam folder either) I can’t donate nor post. My reason for asking is I’m about to start machining my front hubs and am reluctant to start untill im happy with the plans which im not. The drawing for the hub assembly is vague at best and im not happy the bearing set up will work properly. Perhaps me and others are not getting it but im thinking of doing the bearing to my own design. Thanks again and I will have to persevere with TT

                      Edited By Mr Mike on 07/09/2016 00:58:09

                      #254497
                      JasonB
                      Moderator
                        @jasonb

                        That must have changed as most people who have not made a dionation can see all except the "supporteres" section, the only thing you won't see if you don't donate is photos that have been posted as attachments, ones hosted elsewhere view fine. Wait until you get your activation e-mail – can take a few days.

                        Usual way with a lot of TE front wheels is to press in two plain or flanged bearings leaving a gap in the middle that the oil can flow into.

                        Edited By JasonB on 07/09/2016 07:30:26

                        #255375
                        Mr Mike
                        Participant
                          @mrmike

                          Hi and again thanks for the help. My issue was with the collar that holds the hub assembly to the axle. My drawings are in metric so obviously have been converted from imperial. The axle has a diameter of 20mm the hub inner being 25mm this obviously being the outter diameter of the bearing I’ll push in. The drawings showed the inside diameter of the collar at 25mm this made no sense to me as it would be very loose on the axle and it obviously didn’t fit on the outside of the bearing. Anyway with a fresh mind I measured the drawings and found that the collar measured the same as the axle so it’d appear that whoever metricised the drawings got it wrong. I’ve learnt a valuable lesson here and it’s check, check and check some more as I am now the proud owner of 4 axle collars. 2 I made beautifully with a 25mm inside diameter and 2 equaly beautiful ones with the correct 20mm diameter. Newbie mistake I guess and probably the first of many.

                          Edited By Mr Mike on 12/09/2016 02:04:09

                          #255376
                          Paul Lousick
                          Participant
                            @paullousick59116

                            Hi Mr Mike,

                            You will probably find that there are lots of mistakes on drawings which have been produced for model engines. Often drawn/converted by drafters who do not have a lot experience or done to a cheap price, hence the mistakes or poor quality drawings. (drawings would cost $1000's instead of $100's to purchase if professionally produced). My advise is to double check everything before machining a part. I had previously worked for 40 years as a professional mechanical draftsman and re-draw everything, mainly to check the compatability of components but to also make changes to suit available size materials.

                            Paul

                            #255885
                            Mr Mike
                            Participant
                              @mrmike

                              Hi, again thanks for the advice. I think from now i’m going to draw the part i’m making along with everything else in that particular assembly as it’ll help me notice any missing measurements and get a better idea of how things go together. Especially since I’m scratch building as much as I can and the drawings seem to be aimed at those buying castings and purely cleaning them up, therefor they have a lot of measurements missing.

                              #259097
                              Mr Mike
                              Participant
                                @mrmike
                                img_20161003_181115.jpgHi just a couple of pics to show I've not been idle. One shows my front hub and covers that have been made from one piece of round 100mm such as the one in the picture. I have since made another one of each from this piece of steel. Another pic shows a hub after I've machinex the slots for my spokes.img_20160918_171606.jpg

                                Edited By Mr Mike on 04/10/2016 00:45:19

                                #259099
                                Mr Mike
                                Participant
                                  @mrmike

                                  img_20161001_151732.jpgWhen I came to mill the slots for my spokes I needed to rotate the work. Whilst I had access to a rotating table I wanted to try something new. So I turned a dummy axle that fitted the inside of my hub and after drilling its middle out I T slotted it to the bed of the mill. After fitting the hub over it I could rotate the hub through 360° and clamp it in place for machining.

                                  img_20161001_150118.jpg

                                  #259101
                                  Mr Mike
                                  Participant
                                    @mrmike
                                    Oops sorry failed attempt at posting video

                                    Edited By Mr Mike on 04/10/2016 01:44:08

                                    #259103
                                    Paul Lousick
                                    Participant
                                      @paullousick59116

                                      Hi Mr Mike,

                                      This is link to a previous post of mine showing the building of my traction engine. Not a 4" Fowler but a 6" Ruston and Proctor which would be about the same size as yours.

                                      Paul.

                                      http://www.model-engineer.co.uk/forums/postings.asp?th=112162

                                      Edited By Paul Lousick on 04/10/2016 06:46:25

                                      #259105
                                      JasonB
                                      Moderator
                                        @jasonb

                                        Off to a good start Mr Mike

                                        I'm not sure what the Foster drawings show but as the hubs were originally cast it is usual to replicate the radiused corners on the hubs which could still be added if you wanted to. It's a bit of a personal thing, some like to get the engine done and out on the rally field ASAP, others tend to like to get the details as original and may not steam the engine much.

                                        #259224
                                        Mr Mike
                                        Participant
                                          @mrmike

                                          Hi thanks for the replies. I'm aware that most use castings but as personal preferance im going to scratch build as much as I can. As mentioned previously the drawings tend to be aimed at those cleaning up castings so some measurements are missing. As for putting a radius on the edges the 3 parts in 1 picture are 1 complete hub assembly. Obviously the spokes go in the slots of the main hub and then the top hat shaped item is solid and fits on the inside of the hub I have put a radius on the part of this that sits up against the axle. The slim 8mm wide biscuit shaped cover goes on the outside of the hub covering the spokes. Since once the whole assembly is in place and held in situ via a collar it is then covered with a hollow usually brass cover to finish it off. Since the 3 items made so far all mate together I didnt think it'd look right with the hub having rounded corners being mated to other items with the same. Instead all 3 parts were turned at the same time to exactly the same diameter so when they are together it will be practically seamless joins throughout out the whole assembly. Obviously this is personal preference

                                          #259231
                                          Mr Mike
                                          Participant
                                            @mrmike

                                            Paul thanks for the link. I was aware of your thread and had studied it previous. You do nice work and I'd actually shown friends your pictures as a reference for what I was about to produce. I'm an engineer by trade so may be biased but I think your pictures of the milled hub are a think of beauty. Now I have my own pair of near complete hubs they have pride of place on my desk at work and currently function as excellent paper weights though I'm certain few other paper weights have as many man hours invested in them.

                                            #259234
                                            JasonB
                                            Moderator
                                              @jasonb

                                              Mike, it was not the mating faces that I was saying should be rounded, as you say when they are assembled with your favorite epoxy the joints should not be visible under a coat of paint so you need those as crisp as possible.

                                              It is the two inner faces and the outer faces of the inner and outer cover plates, Don't have a good close up photo of the front hobs on my Fowler only this part assembled wheel which were also cut from solid but if you look at this one of Paul's you can see the mating faces are square edged but the other external corners all rounded this can either be as cast on teh model hubs or if cutting from solid added with a simple form tool.

                                              exploaded hub.jpg

                                              Edited By JasonB on 04/10/2016 20:33:35

                                              #259246
                                              Mr Mike
                                              Participant
                                                @mrmike

                                                Thanks for the info jason like I said there's no info on the drawings but since I've put a radius on the small circumference of the inner hub cover (the top hat item) its no big job to do the outside circumference and then the brass hub cover can have its edges smoothed and job done. Since my work has to come out of the lathe during the day if I'm using one of works I'm a dab hand at clocking work back up in short time. Besides I may put the whole assembly in the chuck when its time to ream the bearing to size (discuss). Also one has to think of paint as it doesn't like to stick to sharp edges. Whilst I'm certainly in no rush to complete the job since I get my joy from the building im still not sure how I feel about getting it exact to how the production model was. As far as I'm concerned it's a test/demonstraition of my skills hence I'm scratch building. Once the wheels are done I have a square bar under my desk from which I plan to fashion the axle. I could purchase castings and be done a lot sooner but like I've said my preference is to scratch build. Somethings I have purchased such as the spokes especially since they are cheaper from lsm than I thoughr and I don't really need to demonstrate or test my skill in cutting out 24 pieces of flat steel.

                                                Again thanks for the help and please feel free to offer advice in the future. When im further down the line I may start a proper build thread but at the moment work keeps me busy and a boring illness limits progress.

                                                #261456
                                                Mr Mike
                                                Participant
                                                  @mrmike

                                                  Hi, as this is rapidly coming the place for good reliable advice for me I have a query regards lubrication for my front hubs. I plan to fit plain bearings in two halfs (as sugested here, thanks). My drawings simply a drilling in the side of the hub. Does one fit a flip top oiler or simply use the drilling as my lube point. My phosphor bronze is missing in transit at the moment so my hubs are on hold. Not wishing to name and shame yet but I have an email saying it was posted 3 weeks ago. I've tried to email back but its a no reply type email address, so ive rang and left messages but no joy yet.

                                                  To keep myself busy ive started machining my front axle from a piece of square steel and whilst I can obviously get it to within tolerance via the drawings, if someone has a photo of a cast one the could show me it'd help me get it spot on.

                                                  #261466
                                                  Paul Lousick
                                                  Participant
                                                    @paullousick59116

                                                    Mr Mike,

                                                    I used grease to lubricate the bushes in my hubs. Oil will run thru the bearings onto the ground unless the axle shaft is fitted with seals. (the trouble and strife (wife) would complain bitterly if I stained our driveway with MY engine)

                                                    Paul.

                                                    greaser.jpg

                                                    #265493
                                                    Mr Mike
                                                    Participant
                                                      @mrmike

                                                      Hi thanks for the reply. I had thought of grease but only briefly as I thought oil was the accepted method. I have zero experience so far of fitting flip top lubricators so all advice is welcome. Im fitting split bushes and wasn’t planning on cutting oil ways into them any advice to contrary is welcome.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 32 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Traction engines Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up