Spot the connection

Advert

Spot the connection

Home Forums General Questions Spot the connection

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 79 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #24145
    Steve Pavey
    Participant
      @stevepavey65865

      Help needed to locate the star point

      Advert
      #206637
      Steve Pavey
      Participant
        @stevepavey65865

        Just dismantled the 2.2kW 3 phase motor from my lathe as the first step in re-commisioning it. Rather than just snip away I wondered if anyone out there could hazard a guess as to where best to start to locate the star point.

        The lacing looks like a waxed cotton thread to me – similar to carpet thread, and I happen to have a small amount – do you think that is suitable when it comes to lacing it up again (assuming I get that far of course). 

        The photo in my album appears much larger than it seems to in this post.

        Edited By Steve Pavey on 04/10/2015 20:58:03

        #206640
        Ian Parkin
        Participant
          @ianparkin39383

          Just carefully cut the strapping away and it will tease away from the windings and pull out

          then tease the wires out and you should easily see the star point

          cut and solder on new wires and then use your strapping or small tie wraps to tidy up

          #206642
          John Rudd
          Participant
            @johnrudd16576

            Is the Star point located to the left the termination box? I see some Grey wires……

            #206644
            Phil Whitley
            Participant
              @philwhitley94135

              hi steve, before you hack into the windings, how many wires are there in the connector box on the motor? if there are six, you don't need to touch the wihdings

              phil

              #206645
              frank brown
              Participant
                @frankbrown22225

                That blob at 6 o'clock, could it be that? My theory says that it should be close to the first set of coils (not where the lead out wire are). this is based on the first wire goes around coil #1, then coil #4. . . the second wire goes to coil #2, then coil #5. . . wire number three goes to coil #3, then coil #6. So the ends of the wire must at the last coil, the last but one and the last but two. This should be close to coil #1, or where we came in.

                Try picking out one lead out with a sharpi type marker, perhaps you can identify the start or ends of the sets of coils. A colour code would help, black, red and green or blue could be used for the input wires, then any sleeved long wire must go to aq coil or the star point.

                If you consider the service of the motor, hot with vibrations, the leads must be supported really well, I am not confident that stripping away all the lacing then trying to replace it all would add to the reliability of the motor, so minimum modifications must be the way to go. Just remembered of some incidents at work, because of the internal temperature rise, the actual coils change shape and move about, just something else to fret about.

                Frank

                #206648
                Steve Pavey
                Participant
                  @stevepavey65865

                  Posted by Phil Whitley on 04/10/2015 21:26:31:

                  hi steve, before you hack into the windings, how many wires are there in the connector box on the motor? if there are six, you don't need to touch the wihdings

                  phil

                  Oh how I wish there were six. Unfortunately not

                  John – The grey seems to be something like a piece of tape, rather than wires or sheathing. There does seem to be a couple of likely looking bits of sleeving at the 5 to 7 o'clock position – I didn't say so in the original post because I didn't want to colour anyone's thinking and I wasn't at all confident anyway.

                  I'm definitely all in favour of creating minimal disturbance Frank – it's a Brook Crompton motor, and everything looks so neatly laced I want to keep as much as possible intact.

                  I have some shrink sleeving at the ready to make the three new connections once I locate the star point – presumably soft solder is ok?

                  #206651
                  Phil Whitley
                  Participant
                    @philwhitley94135

                    hi steve, ok its not a problem, and this may sound obvious, but you are looking for the biggest lump in the windings, find where the tails that go to the connector block are solered to the windings, and look at the same place on the other side of the windings, and also at the other end of the motor, you cen cut the string binding and remove the taping, but keep bending of the wires to a minimum. when you find the star point, unsolder the connections, solder on some tails of similar size or larger, and route them into the connector box, then tape up the connections and tie them back to the windings with cotton string, and varnish them up to stop them moving , job done!

                    phil

                    #206654
                    Roy James 2
                    Participant
                      @royjames2

                      Steve,

                      Why do you want to find the star point? Do you now want it to be connected in a delta?

                      james

                      #206657
                      Mark C
                      Participant
                        @markc

                        Star point connection splitting to convert for delta = 240 volt inverter operation (usually).

                        I have converted 3 so far (a tiddler that was easy as its star point was really obvious with tails soldered on, a 3/4 hp which was less easy and a 1.5 hp which was a pig!). If you look at the tails they used you might be able to identify it by elimination – if you are lucky they used colour coded tails so you want something that is NOT connected to the termination tails and NOT one of the repeated field winding connections. That is a poor description but I cant think of a better way to explain it. If you are really lucky you might have one sleeve with three different colour wires in it – that would be a result!

                        Mark

                        Edited By Mark C on 04/10/2015 23:04:37

                        PS. Don't forget the big green and yellow wire – I reckon after a spot of DIY electrickery in a motor, that becomes very important indeed…..

                        Edited By Mark C on 04/10/2015 23:07:05

                        #206671
                        Gary Wooding
                        Participant
                          @garywooding25363

                          When I split the star points on the motors of my mill, an elderly friend, who'd spent his working life in this area, warned me to eschew soldering the new wires in favour of using mechanical crimps. He reckoned that the temperatures reached in the windings would cause soldered joints to deteriorate. He also advised against using plastic insulation, for the same reason.

                          I don't know if its true, but I heeded his advice anyway.

                          #206677
                          Neil Wyatt
                          Moderator
                            @neilwyatt

                            Crimps done well cold weld and are the most reliable way of joining wires.

                            Neil

                            #206678
                            Bazyle
                            Participant
                              @bazyle

                              Just to clarify, as I have an abandoned conversion, is the star point always at the same end as the existing connections?

                              Must have another look at mine. When I mentioned my difficulty I got the response that 'it easy', ' I've done loads' etc.

                              #206682
                              Steve Pavey
                              Participant
                                @stevepavey65865
                                Posted by Roy James 2 on 04/10/2015 22:41:12:

                                Steve,

                                Why do you want to find the star point? Do you now want it to be connected in a delta?

                                james

                                Mark C is right – I want to run the motor from the single phase 240 v supply using a vfd. I don't know how much of the existing electrical control gear currently fitted to the lathe I will be able to incorporate (for example it has a fwd/off/rev switch on the front panel – I'm guessing that it can be wired back to a suitable vfd). Anyway, the initial aim is to convert the motor from star to delta. I have yet to even look at the coolant pump, except to note that it has 3 red wires attached to it so is obviously another candidate for conversion.

                                I'll try to take some more photos this afternoon when I get the scalpel and plastic 'spudger' out.

                                Re the crimps vs soldered joints – I would think that if the solder was going to be affected by heat then the motor will have other, more major problems, so while I agree that crimp connections are excellent i'm not sure they are absolutely necessary. They are also fairly bulky compared to a soldered and shrink-sleeved connection, which might make it tricky to lace everything back together neatly. The heat shrink sleeve I have is rated up to 125°C and again, if the motor runs correctly after my surgery, it won't get anywhere near that temperature.

                                #206683
                                Mark C
                                Participant
                                  @markc

                                  Bazyle,

                                  It is easy but some are less so. It requires patience and a steady hand along with a bit of thought as to what you are doing. If you are ham fisted it is probably not a good idea to try but for anyone used to fixing stuff it should be straight forward. Hardest part is finding the connection in the first place- which is what started this thread!

                                  Mark

                                  #206687
                                  Mark C
                                  Participant
                                    @markc

                                    Steve,

                                    You might find your luck is in with the coolant pump – they tend to be dual voltage from my experience. You will need another inverter for the coolant pump or the motors will be very un-matched and both will vary speed together – which might be good for matching flow to rpm but I will bet the pump rate will not be linear with rpm! This might be a good time to investigate capacitor running of a synthetic phase.

                                    The switch gear should be capable of re-wiring but it might take a bit of working out (I am assuming it is a "standard" rotary switch with multiple poles). You will then only need an emergency stop switch (assuming you want to wire one) which will shut the thing down if the rotary switch fails or some other disaster ensues. You will probably want to wire for "two wire" control and should be able to find a diagram that works for your inverter along with the correct programming parameters. All that you need then is a pot for speed control – check the value for your inverter as they are not all the same (some 5K others 10 and I have one that needs 4K7).

                                    Mark

                                    #206691
                                    Ian Parkin
                                    Participant
                                      @ianparkin39383

                                      dsc00676 (medium).jpg

                                      Heres a series of pics I did to illustrate an article on how to change from star to delta

                                      its a brook motor so very similar to yours

                                      dsc00674 (medium).jpg

                                       

                                      dsc00676 (medium).jpg

                                      dsc00677 (medium).jpg

                                      dsc00678 (medium).jpg

                                      dsc00687 (medium).jpg

                                      Edited By Ian Parkin on 05/10/2015 11:08:38

                                      #206692
                                      Ian Parkin
                                      Participant
                                        @ianparkin39383

                                        Then after checking continuity heat shrink the connections twice and wrap or tie wrap all the wires back into place

                                        colour code or mark each pair and bring the wires out to the connection box and reconnect as delta

                                        Ian

                                        #206700
                                        john fletcher 1
                                        Participant
                                          @johnfletcher1

                                          Regarding soldered connection, and over heating, if we had any reservations we used to silver solder them. I have used crimp connectors as there usually space some where to fit them in. Not so neat as a soldered one. I'm out of tough, but know doubt sister flex is still available, from the local re winders, but heat shrink is good and air drying varnish is also available via the net. Ian says he did an article on converting from Star to Delta using a Brook motor, has the article been published and if so where. Perhaps he could send a PM or publish here for more to see. John

                                          #206712
                                          Mike Poole
                                          Participant
                                            @mikepoole82104

                                            When I wound motors in our winding shop we used oxy-acetylene to fuse the two wires into a small ball. To lace the windings we used flat cotton tape about 10mm wide and a piece of lewmex wire as a needle to thread it through the windings, systoflex heat resistant glass fibre based sleeving was used to sleeve joints.

                                            Mike

                                            Edited By Michael Poole on 05/10/2015 13:26:00

                                            #206725
                                            Steve Pavey
                                            Participant
                                              @stevepavey65865

                                              A scalpel and some blunt softwood wedges later, and I have this – (1) undoing the lacing, (2) separating the wires with softwood wedges, and (3) opening up the sleeve to reveal what is hopefully the star point:

                                              There is only one other place where three wires come together, but two of them are clearly the original wires leading out to the connection box, so this is the one I chose to dissect. I'm fairly happy that the 3 wire connection in the last photo is the star point, but if anyone knows different I would think now is a good time to shout!

                                              I have some glass fibre type heat resistant sleeving but I'm waiting for some coloured heat shrink sleeving and numbered collars to arrive courtesy of eBay (hopefully tomorrow). I think there is enough room for crimp connections if I want to use them.

                                              All the information above has been really helpful, especially Ian's photos and the info on the coolant pump motor etc from Mark – I think John Mills (Doubleboost on Youtube) converted his coolant pump to single phase with a capacitor so I need to have a dig through his videos and find some info on capacitor sizes.

                                              Have yet to choose and buy a suitable vfd – presumably they all cater for wiring in external control switches (???). I'm not sure what you mean by '2 wire control' Mark, but perhaps that will become clear when it comes to wiring up the vfd.

                                              #206750
                                              Mark C
                                              Participant
                                                @markc

                                                Steve,

                                                2 wire= binary logic IE. Stop is wired with NC switch feeding start & direction NO switches (often of the momentary variety but not exclusively which is why you can use your existing rotary switch). If stop is NOT pressed then start or reverse will result in a signal at the inverter. As long as inputs are latching then things are fine for basic operation. If you want more control you need more wires – I don't know why it is called "2 wire" but it might be due to the logic of the basic switch arrangement being along the lines of binary? Or it could just be a generic name the electricians I know have come to use…..

                                                You will find that the different makes have different ideas but they will all do the same basic operation, it will just be a case of working out how!

                                                Having a workshop running exclusively on inverters I can strongly advocate the use of load reactors (output filters/chokes) on the motor side and line filters on the mains side – I was amazed how effective they are at killing the electrical noise and high voltages. I concluded that messing with winding conversion warranted giving the motor all the help I could in continuing to work and these help a lot.

                                                Mark

                                                #206752
                                                Mark C
                                                Participant
                                                  @markc

                                                  I had meant to add that your motor was very much like the small motor I did in that the star point was wired using tails, the other two I did had just the windings joined without tails, the 3/4 hp was on the outside of the windings and the hard one was buried under all the field winding connections which is why it was a pig to do!

                                                  If you take the covers off and can see three tails all going the same place they are a good candidate for the star point, I checked mine when I had split the star point out for equal resistance in case I had it wrong but they are going to be quite low resistance so you need a decent meter for the job.

                                                  Mark

                                                  #206755
                                                  Ian Parkin
                                                  Participant
                                                    @ianparkin39383

                                                    Mark

                                                    2 wire control is used if you have latching switches so your start switch is n/o and wired in series with a n/c stop switch only if the switch latches on will the inverter start and carry on running

                                                    and i dont think this system is a no volt release system as if your start switch is on and the stop switch is out then the inverter will start on power up

                                                    Most inverters allow you to make the inputs latching or not.

                                                    if you want to use normal switches (unlatching) you need 3 wire control

                                                    Ian

                                                    #206760
                                                    Mark C
                                                    Participant
                                                      @markc

                                                      Ian,

                                                      Yes, you are correct about the power on problem with latching switches, not a hope of HSE passing that one off! Industrial practice is quite a bit different to our workshop requirements but we should all be working safe all the same.

                                                      Getting the wiring correct for latching inputs can sometimes be a bit confusing but I don't think any of the modern inverters lack this function, not even the cheap imported types.

                                                      The idea that you can run inverters 2 or 3 wire is a bit of a confusion at best, you really need a few more than that in reality. Most of the time the minimum you need is 7. This comprises a digital common, the start stop logic and the three wires for speed control – the analogue input often uses a different ground to the digital common – all of which I suspect you know already… but it might help others just getting their hands on inverter drives for the first time.

                                                      When Steve gets his inverter he can probably get a fair bit of help here setting it up if he is finding it a bit daunting – some of the parameters can be a bit confusing at the first attempt.

                                                      Mark

                                                      PS. I mention 7 wires as it is very irritating to get home with all your new toys only to discover that the six core you got for the job is a wire short for the job in hand…..

                                                      Edited By Mark C on 05/10/2015 21:38:53

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 79 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up