Workshop Purchase (wish)list

Advert

Workshop Purchase (wish)list

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling Workshop Purchase (wish)list

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 37 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #646597
    Rooossone
    Participant
      @rooossone

      So it's a lovely sunny evening and relaxing after a very successful week, Getting the Bridgeport transported and in her new home. I was able to put the workbench/racking back up and now it looks like a workshop again! very happy.

      I have been sat here for a while and sipping away on a nice local IPA compiling a list of all the things I know I don't have and will need now or in the future. I've also gone along and compiled a rough pricing estimate and link of the item. the list got fairly big fairly quick.

      I just thought I would share it here for some friendly critique and fine tuning.
      Naturally some of the items in there, could well be made by me if I can pull the trigger on a lathe but its more of a checklist of tooling to acquire by whatever means.

      Here is the link, I'd love to hear the discussion on things I may have missed (I haven't put anything on there I already have for example, or completely missed) or things your would purchase differently. What would you order of priority be?

      Edited By Rooossone on 26/05/2023 19:57:09

      Advert
      #21003
      Rooossone
      Participant
        @rooossone
        #646598
        JasonB
        Moderator
          @jasonb

          Forget the number drill set, the metric sets you list will be sufficient, add a few larger reduced shank "blacksmiths" drills if you want say 16, 20 & 25mm

          The 58pc clamp set will do so leave the other bits off for now

          6" rotary table may be a bit small on a BP

          Get an R8 shank flycutter rather than the 3 small ones or better still a 63mm indexable face/shell mill & arbor

          Unless you intend to use 5C on the lathe then ER collets, blocks and a collet chuck may be a better option. I'd also use a ER32 collet chuck rather than the set of R8 collets

          Might want to add a boring head to the list

          This is what you need wink 2

          dsc02181.jpg

           

           

          Edited By JasonB on 26/05/2023 20:19:30

          #646602
          Rooossone
          Participant
            @rooossone

            Okay Duly noted and shopping list updated accordingly

            You are correct. I am certain I need all those things in that picture 😀

            What would you recommend on the rotary table front then?

            #646603
            SillyOldDuffer
            Moderator
              @sillyoldduffer
              Posted by Rooossone on 26/05/2023 19:53:57:

              I have been sat here for a while and sipping away on a nice local IPA compiling a list of all the things I know I don't have and will need now or in the future. I've also gone along and compiled a rough pricing estimate and link of the item. the list got fairly big fairly quick.

              I just thought I would share it here for some friendly critique and fine tuning.
              Naturally some of the items in there, could well be made by me if I can pull the trigger on a lathe but its more of a checklist of tooling to acquire by whatever means.

              Here is the link, I'd love to hear the discussion on things I may have missed (I haven't put anything on there I already have for example, or completely missed) or things your would purchase differently. What would you order of priority be?…

              Well not listing what you already have makes it hard to guess what's missing. But I love spending other peoples money!

              Few comments:

              • Wouldn't bother with Number or Letter Drills unless really needed. Much to be said in favour of metric drills on 0.1mm increments
              • Another set of drills for Brass only
              • The Rotary Table and vice may be a bit small for a Bridgeport. How about a Kurt.
              • 5C collet block without 5C collets?
              • Taps, Dies and Milling cutters (long list! I'd go metric)
              • Safety Glasses
              • Bisley cabinets
              • Linisher
              • Bandsaw
              • Vacuum Cleaner
              • Files (also with set for brass)
              • Having gone for a Bridgeport, the Super 7 feels undersized. How about a Boxford, Colchester etc?
              • Digital or Dial Caliper. (Jenny and other manual types also useful)
              • Thin rubber gloves
              • Emery Paper
              • Spanners and nut drivers (Metric, BA & Imperial)
              • Stock fasteners, washers, etc
              • Dremel
              • Set squares
              • Angle Gauges (Wixey abnd protractor)
              • Marking fluid, Acetone, Meths and Penetration Oil
              • Blowlamp and insulating blocks
              • Brazing rods and flux
              • Screwdrivers and security heads
              • Air Compressor and accessories
              • Big vice on bench
              • Punch set
              • Hole locator set
              • Edge finders
              • Work light(s)
              • Paint floor and foot friendly mats
              • Swarf magnet and swarf bins
              • Deburrer
              • Dead Hammer
              • Angle plate

              and more…

              Years of fun ahead!

              smiley

              Dave

              #646605
              Clive Brown 1
              Participant
                @clivebrown1

                With all due respect to Arc, I'd be reluctant to pay £279 for a 6 – 10 mm drill set. An average of £6.8 per drillsurprise. I'd buy cheaper, not too cheap though, and add an imperial, fractional set.

                #646608
                Rooossone
                Participant
                  @rooossone

                  Hi Clive, I am only really using arc as a reference. When it comes to actually buying anything I will have a look around. The list is to get an idea of things as I think of them or have them suggested.

                  Dave, I thought you might like the mystery of guessing what I might already have. That said, I have updated the list with another list I had made previously including a lot of the things I have acquired. There are certainly things there missing that I am remembering as i type so will add those.

                  I will be sure to work through the list you have shared and add it to mine where appropriate. This list may well serve as a scary warning as to the costs of model engineering. Totally worth it though

                  laugh

                  #646609
                  JasonB
                  Moderator
                    @jasonb

                    8" rotary table would be more in keeping with the size of the BP

                    Edited By JasonB on 26/05/2023 20:54:37

                    #646610
                    Chris Evans 6
                    Participant
                      @chrisevans6
                      Posted by Rooossone on 26/05/2023 20:25:19:

                      Okay Duly noted and shopping list updated accordingly

                      You are correct. I am certain I need all those things in that picture 😀

                      What would you recommend on the rotary table front then?

                      I am a Bridgeport user and have two rotary tables, a Vertex 10" HV and a very old 14" of unknown make. The 14" table has a 20" sub-table for the bigger radius work but only used every few years. I lack the muscle to shove it from trolley to machine table. The 10" table I can pick up.

                      #646613
                      Rooossone
                      Participant
                        @rooossone

                        Rotary table got a serious upgrade based on opinion!!

                        #646614
                        Nick Wheeler
                        Participant
                          @nickwheeler

                          You've omitted some important information: what are you intending to do with all this stuff? There's big differences between making tiny steam engines, and doing basic machine work for real cars or motorbikes….

                           

                          And you're right, some of it overlaps, like the imperial and metric drill sets. Those are expensive items, so settle on one and don't buy the other. A sub£5 calculator hanging off the mill will sort any conversion problems. I'm trying to be entirely metric, so would avoid the number etc drills but if you're going to use mostly imperial measurements, that should be flipped. Do you really need a chopsaw when you have a bandsaw?

                          As everyone else has said, buy the ER32 collets(and not having a full set is daft) with the available square and hex blocks. When you've settled on your favoured cutter size, treat then to their own specific collet. I'd probably attach the drill chuck to a 20mm shank to use with a collet. That all makes the the 5C redundant until you actually need them for specific jobs the ER won't do – no, I don't know what they could be.

                          Try and keep the tools needed for using everything to a minimum – it's seriously frustrating using a random selection of spanners, allen keys and sockets to just clamp a workpiece and fit the necessary tool.

                          Just because one person finds a particular tool essential doesn't mean you will – rotary tables are a good example, as there's a lot of resources tied up in one that might be better spent elsewhere for your work. £200 can still buy a useful amount of material. I have a pair of 123blocks that are touted as must haves, but only one of them ever gets used to align the toolpost square with the chuck….

                          You haven't listed basic metalworking tools like hacksaws, files, snips, punches etc.

                          What for, and how often is the expensive crane going to be used? They're meant to lift an engine in and out, not move long and heavy stuff around the workshop. Once you've had one tip over, you'll lose any enthusiasm for the things. They take up a lot space even when folded too.

                          For general workshop use, I'd probably buy a TIG welder instead of the MIG. That decision is reversed if you're going to be working on cars. That is how mine get used.

                          Even if you can afford to buy all this one go, it's probably better to get the basic clamps, cutting tools and measuring kit first then get the more specialised tools from the remaining slush fund when(if!) they're actually required.

                          A £70 adjustable spanner? Really?? I've never met a mechanic who didn't have adjustables, but they're in the good enough to get it done not family heirloom category. Mine are Bahcos, but the most expensive was the smallest(£7 at an autojumble), and the biggest was rescued from a skip before I was born. I wouldn't buy them new

                          I think Dave's right about the Myford/Bridgeport combination too.

                          Edited By Nick Wheeler on 26/05/2023 21:16:58

                          #646617
                          Rooossone
                          Participant
                            @rooossone

                            Hi Nick, I will try to respond as fully as I can.

                            Basically I am Getting into engineering with the dream of learning and taking part in the Live steam category of engineering. I will be learning from scratch mostly (I've been doing learning as much theory as I can over the last 6 – 8 moths. Followed by mass Youtube consumption. I am looking for in person guidance but havent been able to find anybody)

                            The main core goal for me is 4 inch traction steam and everything in between. I am under no illusions on the magnitude of the task ahead and that is one of the main motivators for me investing in the best way possible to set me up for the best chance of success. I prefer to buy right and buy once which is the reason I picked up the Bridgeport, it was also cheaper than buying a chinese import mini mill that I would eventually outgrow.

                            Nice idea with the calculator, I do actually keep meaning to get a cheap one for the workshop.

                            Unfortunately I already have a mitre chopsaw so I will need the bandsaw as it will only cut non ferrous with the right blade.

                            I have already swapped over to the ER32 collets and will expand out on that recommendation.

                            I am trying to keep my list to essentials to achieve the goals and make jobs easier. It is also a list I won't be buying in one lump. I'l be working on it and buying as i go or as i need it. But there's nothing in the list I don't have jobs already eyed up for. for example, i was looking at 1-2-3 locks this evening and couldn't find a job use for them so i haven't added them.

                            The engine crane is a nice-to-have. It's on the list but as you say, not sure how needed it will be.

                            And as for the spanners, I just threw a price in there as i was guestimating what i spent there, i did look them up and adjust (pardon the pun) accordingly.

                             

                            EDIT: I will leave the lathe as generic 'Lathe' for now.

                            Edited By Rooossone on 26/05/2023 21:39:50

                            #646627
                            JasonB
                            Moderator
                              @jasonb

                              You will be needing the crane to move things like the 4" engines boiler or pick up things like the wheels to get them onto the BP table. I'll alsoup the rotary table from my earlier 8" suggestion if that is what you want to be making.

                              You will also need to be thinking of a M300 or a Colchester sort of size lathe preferably with a gap bed. Probably get a proper collet chuck for that either flexi or 5C.

                              Edited By JasonB on 27/05/2023 07:06:05

                              #646640
                              SillyOldDuffer
                              Moderator
                                @sillyoldduffer

                                H&S is always worth a thought, but the risks in a Model Engineering workshop are low. Maybe a fire extinguisher. Safety glasses or a visor, occasionally ear-defenders. I wear steel toe-capped trainers, and maybe gloves, Two types of glove: rubberised fabric work-gloves for shifting stuff and cleaning up, but not near spinning machines; thin disposable latex to keep paws clean when working a machine (because they tear off if caught), or using chemicals. Latex also to keep finger marks off clean work. Nitrile is better than latex. However, barrier cream is also good alternative to thin gloves, and bare hands aren't daft unless you have sensitive skin,

                                Experience usually resolves which type of hand protection is best in your workshop. Experience also influences many other purchases. Much depends on what the workshop does, so there's an argument against creating a big list on day one. Particularly when a beginner isn't sure yet where the hobby will take him or is general-purpose. A lot of money can be wastered on tools that are rarely needed, in the worst case blowing the budget just before realising something important and expensive is needed. I don't need one, but I've noticed live steam specialists often put their engines on a motorbike lift.

                                If I was putting a big well-funded workshop together from scratch it would be very brightly lit, with lamps positioned to avoid shadows, and I'd put a lot of thought into maximising productivity by positioning tools and stock 'just so'. Compared with my Chinese mill, Bridgeports come with a galaxy of conveniences that speed up workflow. It's a shame to undermine these by storing collets boxed in a distant cupboard rather than mounted in a rack with the mill. Ditto cutters, edge finders, and all the other mill related stuff – it should all be within easy reach of the operator. Same applies to the lathe. The idea goes further when a workshop has a particular workflow, say from mill to lathe, to bench and back to mill etc. Which alters were the power points go…

                                How well insulated is the space? Poor insulation leads to condensation, so it should be beefed up before filling the space. If damp turns out to be a problem, a dehumidifier may be needed.

                                I started with a big list, but prioritised it before spending any money, ruthlessly starting with essentials only. Didn't get it completely right, but so far I've only made one completely useless purchase (a cross-vice), and 3 not so smart (a 3 in 1 sheet-metal tool, a flood cooling system and a press. Nothing wrong with them, but they're rarely needed for what I do,) In contrast, owning 3 DIY worktables and a medium crowbar is very handy.

                                Dave

                                Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 27/05/2023 08:35:13

                                #646641
                                Chris Evans 6
                                Participant
                                  @chrisevans6

                                  Having a very comprehensive set of 5C collets I prefer them to the ER style for the work I do (99% motorcycle).

                                  Hexagon and square collet blocks are used frequently as is the 5C collet chuck on the lathe, my cutter grinder takes 5C collets. Throw in the availability of hexagon and square 5C collets as a bonus. They suit me but only for what I do, a Traction Engine would require a very different approach to "Must Have" kit.

                                  #646648
                                  Nick Wheeler
                                  Participant
                                    @nickwheeler

                                    Dave makes a number of good points there: I'd be making sturdy fixed benches(and a couple of mobile ones) with lower shelves and good bench vices a priority. Ensure the floor is smooth and level first. Lighting is essential. So is effective tool storage – the Halfords tool chests are excellent and good value.

                                    A cheaper crane and a lifting table would make a lot more sense than the expensive one, although if I were going to be frequently moving heavy stuff around the workshop I'd want a rail and chain block instead of an engine crane.

                                    #646654
                                    JA
                                    Participant
                                      @ja

                                      I have just looked at you list. I would add pencil. paper and a note book (commonly called a laptop or PC these days). You already have a camera, I use a good, now old, pocket camera.

                                      What you really need is a good starter project. That will tell you what you have missed off the list. Only make tools if you have to.

                                      I trust the IPA was good.

                                      JA

                                      #646658
                                      Swarf, Mostly!
                                      Participant
                                        @swarfmostly

                                        Rooossone,

                                        You should be scanning this and other fora looking for posts that start 'Help needed to empty Dad's shed.'

                                        You might get a few duplicates but you could always sell those on and you would be doing those posters a big favour!

                                        Best regards,

                                        Swarf, Mostly!

                                        Edited By Swarf, Mostly! on 27/05/2023 10:08:40

                                        Edited By Swarf, Mostly! on 27/05/2023 10:09:26

                                        #646665
                                        Nick Clarke 3
                                        Participant
                                          @nickclarke3

                                          While the advice to stick with metric drills is sound if you are building from scratch, if you are trying to follow instructions and plans from ME or similar you may find that number and letter drills and imperial (ME) threading gear have a more important place in your set-up.

                                          As has been said – what are you intending to make?

                                          #646667
                                          SillyOldDuffer
                                          Moderator
                                            @sillyoldduffer

                                            Really good fun spending Roossone's money!

                                            From the beginning my outfit included a computer, printer and 2D-CAD (QCad) Spreadsheet, Word processor and graphics tools too.

                                            Now I spend a good deal of time with 3D-CAD, which supports complex designs, and saves time in the workshop. Can be done on a laptop, but a fast computer with two big screens is much better. Most of my prototyping is done on a computer supported by a 3D printer, so when I cut metal there's a good chance all the bits will fit together. Pity in a way because I enjoy working my machines. Again the value of CAD tooling depends on what the workshop is for: being experimental means I do high proportion of original design. 3D-CAD is much less valuable when an engine is being built to an existing design. CAD is also less useful if the workshop mostly does repair and restoration work.

                                            Although well equipped now, I got plenty of fun and interest out of a mini-lathe and basic hand-tools. There's no need to spend enormous money on day 1. May even be better not too.

                                            Except you need an angle grinder and a packet of cigarette papers…

                                            Dave

                                            #646670
                                            Anonymous

                                              I use a 12" rotary table on my Bridgeport. Horizontal/vertical capability is a necessity:

                                              spotting_drill.jpg

                                              I prefer a parallel central hole, not Morse taper. A parallel hole means it is simple to make locating pegs:

                                              rear rim drilling me.jpg

                                              There is a rotary table hidden under the wheel!

                                              Andrew

                                              #646675
                                              Ketan Swali
                                              Participant
                                                @ketanswali79440
                                                Posted by Clive Brown 1 on 26/05/2023 20:27:37:

                                                With all due respect to Arc, I'd be reluctant to pay £279 for a 6 – 10 mm drill set. An average of £6.8 per drillsurprise. I'd buy cheaper, not too cheap though, and add an imperial, fractional set.

                                                In my opinion, if brand is less significant, this set also from ARC link would be just as good as the Dormer set link, and a lot cheaper.smiley

                                                Ketan at ARC

                                                #646676
                                                Hopper
                                                Participant
                                                  @hopper
                                                  Posted by SillyOldDuffer on 27/05/2023 08:33:32:

                                                  H&S is always worth a thought, but the risks in a Model Engineering workshop are low. Maybe a fire extinguisher.

                                                  I consider a fire extinguisher essential in any workshop. You just never know. Most of us will go a lifetime without ever needing one. But when you need one, you REALLY need one, and FAST. Grinders, chop saws, Dremels etc and the usual workshop degreasers, oils, fuels etc are a potential risky combination. Let alone electrical wiring, be it 240 volt or 12 volt vehicle electrics etc. Keep the fire extinguisher next to the entry door, or attached to the inside of the door, so that if you come out to find a workshop full of smoke, you can grab it straight away. And if doing welding or silver soldering etc with a torch etc, place the extinguisher nearby just in case.

                                                  More obviously, safety glasses are essential. And don't underestimate the need for good hearing protection (speaking as a victim of "industrial deafness&quot. Angle grinders and chop saws are the worst offenders. And air compressors in confined space.

                                                  #646679
                                                  JasonB
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @jasonb

                                                    LSM do several of their traction engine designs with metric drawings so worth looking at those if you don't want to measure in Bananas.

                                                    Decent size angle plate or two would be quite high up on my list, useful for holding odd shaped castings.

                                                    #646682
                                                    Rooossone
                                                    Participant
                                                      @rooossone

                                                      I'll definitely add a fire extinguisher, I added a first aid kit as I kept meaning to anyway. I was thinking about angle plate but was going to see if I could get away with what I had listed I can always come back and add them.

                                                       

                                                      I thought pens and paper were a given? I got a pencil case full of sharpies, pens and pencils I'm covered there. I got plain a3 an lined a4. I got a crap tablet I leave here for touch dro at some point. 

                                                      I'll add a line though, they're part of the list. 

                                                      And a shop vac. I'll lookout for a Henry or something. Doing alright with a broom, dustpan and brush though so far. 

                                                      Edited By Rooossone on 27/05/2023 13:22:28

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 37 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up