Regulator fixings

Advert

Regulator fixings

Home Forums Locomotives Regulator fixings

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #513763
    chris organ
    Participant
      @chrisorgan39405

      Hi, I am at the point of mounting the regulator to my 3 1/2 inch Rob Roy boiler.
      Martin Evans specifies 8BA stainless steel bolts, which suggests to me that he means drilling and tapping right through the bush into the boiler steam cavity.
      I was planning to drill and tap only as deep as the bush itself, but that is trickier and means a few less threads to grip. Am I being too cautious, is drilling right through reasonable ?

      Advert
      #1987
      chris organ
      Participant
        @chrisorgan39405

        What is best practice for mounting the regulator to bronze bush

        #514042
        chris organ
        Participant
          @chrisorgan39405

          …. well I went ahead and tapped blind holes. I used the S/S screws anyway. All held up at 120 psi test so all good.

          I'd still like to know people's opinions on this though.

          #514047
          Jeff Dayman
          Participant
            @jeffdayman43397

            If you have three complete threads engaged and the screws are a good fit, not loose, I'd say they will be good. Certainly better to use blind threads in such a bush from the standpoint of less places to have a steam leak than with through-holes.

            I have seen a lot of things in Martin Evans designs where a bit more care, as in a deeper bush / blind holes in your locomotive for example, would have made for a far better design. He frequently designed things on boilers with really short threads hanging in just a wisp of material. On his Comway design, the regulator casting is drawn machined with .008" of metal between two drilled holes over 1.25" deep. Unless you know a couple of tricks to do this drilling, the drill will break through spoiling the job. It could have been easily avoided with just slightly different design. Impossibly small springs on lubricators, as drawn, are another trademark. I am not a fan of Mr Evans. (the loco designer, not the current ME editor )

            #514137
            chris organ
            Participant
              @chrisorgan39405

              Thanks for the remarks Jeff. If I had thought ahead I would have arranged for another 1/16 or even 1/8 inch of depth on the bush which would have eliminated the whole concern ! There are several aspects of this design where a little more metal would have helped. Having said that, I’ve never built an engine before and having the whole build in one book was helpful so I’m not complaining. Like many things you learn your own way by doing it wrong on occasion.

            Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
            • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

            Advert

            Latest Replies

            Home Forums Locomotives Topics

            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
            Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

            View full reply list.

            Advert

            Newsletter Sign-up