Brook motor problem.

Advert

Brook motor problem.

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling Brook motor problem.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 39 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #17470
    Mark P.
    Participant
      @markp
      Advert
      #160756
      Mark P.
      Participant
        @markp

        img_1740.jpgimg_1741.jpg

        Hi all, I am having problems with this motor, it's a 240v 3/4hp 1430 RPM motor removed from a myford. The problem is when switched on it gets up to speed and I get a yellow flash from the region of the centrifugal switch and the circuit breaker trips. I have connected the Live to terminals AZ and T with a link wire between the two. Neutral is connected to terminals Z and A with a link wire between the two terminals, is this right? The motor has been stood around for sometime so I cleaned out any swarf and debris from inside the case and inspected the wiring for chafing and damage none found.I have been assured by my boss that the motor was good when removed. I have disconnected the cable for clarity.

        Mark P.

        Edited By Mark P. on 15/08/2014 13:38:43

        #160758
        MAX THE MILLER
        Participant
          @maxthemiller

          For a split phase motor, without capacitors, the Red and Black wires are the run winding. The yellow and blue wires are the starting winding and the centrifugal switch is connected in series with it. You can connect these windings in parallel either way, but you may need to reverse the connections to one winding if the motor runs in the wrong direction.

          The additional red wire and the striped wire probably go to the centrifugal switch in which case your wiring is correct.

          If it's the main Residual Current Device (RCD) serving all circuits which trips, then some kind of insulation breakdown from winding or switch to the frame is indicated. If on the other hand it's a Miniature Circuit Breaker (MCB) serving say a ring main which trips then an overload in indicated.

          When the contacts of the switch break the back emf will result in a high voltage between them. This could be jumping across to the frame tripping the RCD.

          You could try disconnecting the start winding and hand starting the motor by spinning the shaft. If the motor runs OK this confirms a problem with the start winding or switch.

          Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 14:20:19

          #160760
          Brian Wood
          Participant
            @brianwood45127

            Hello Mark,

            Checking my own capacity start motor, Live goes to terminal A and Neutral to terminal AZ

            There is probably a link between A and Z to couple in the start winding.

            To reverse the motor swap the yellow and blue leads.

            If it buzzes and refuses to start when coupled as I describe, provide a link between A and Z

            What I think you have done is wire live and neutral across the cenrifugal switch, and providing a dead short when the switch is activated at speed.

            I can't see terminal T in your picture and grovelling in the swarf behind my lathe I can't see T printed on my terminal board either.

            Regards Brian.

            Edited By Brian Wood on 15/08/2014 14:55:30

            Edited By Brian Wood on 15/08/2014 14:58:55

            #160762
            Mark P.
            Participant
              @markp

              Hi Brian, the T terminal is directly below the S terminal with the yellow wire.
              Mark P.

              #160769
              Neil Wyatt
              Moderator
                @neilwyatt

                This 'instructable' looks very good:

                **LINK**

                Neil

                #160770
                MAX THE MILLER
                Participant
                  @maxthemiller

                  [QUOTE=Brian Wood]What I think you have done is wire live and neutral across the cenrifugal switch, and providing a dead short when the switch is activated at speed[/quote]

                  That can't be the case. The centrifugal switch is a BREAK switch designed to disconnect the start winding when the motor get up to speed leaving just the run winding connected. It's not a MAKE switch.

                  Sorry. Can't work how  to do a partial quote. This forum is different to every other one I use.

                  Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 17:12:32

                  Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 17:13:31

                  #160780
                  Les Jones 1
                  Participant
                    @lesjones1

                    Hi Mark,
                    I agree with Max The Miller. If live and neutral were connected across the centrifugal switch the MCB would trip as soon as power was applied as there would be a dead short across the mains. Mark can you confirm what trips out ? Is it an MCB or the RCD ? My feeling is that the centrifugal switch is not breaking cleanly and flashing over to earth. If so there will probably black burn marks on the insulation near the contacts. My first step would be to CONFIRM that the wring is as we think. First remove your mains connections and links. Do the following resistance checks. You should get a reading of a few ohms between A and AZ. You should get a reading of a few ohms between Z and S. You should get almost zero resistance between S an T (This is the centrifugal switch if our assumptions are correct.) From A to Z you should get an infinite read. (Or at least 10 Meg ohms) Also check that there is an infinite (Or very high reading) from the motor frame and all of the terminals. (Preferably use a megger for this test.) If these tests give the expected results I would try starting the motor with an external switch connected in place of the centrifugal switch. Have this switch closed (In the on position) Apply the power and switch this switch off about a second after power is applied. (This simulates the centrifugal switch opening.)

                    Les.

                    Edited By Les Jones 1 on 15/08/2014 17:58:38

                    #160781
                    Brian Wood
                    Participant
                      @brianwood45127

                      Hello Mark and Max,

                      Yes Max, you are of course right. I was swayed by Mark's description which suggested the short takes place when the motor is up to speed.

                      Mark.

                      I would remove the two link wires you put in and leave the supply coupled to AZ and A. It doesn't really matter which is to live being AC. As in my last response, motor reversal is done by swapping the yellow and blue leads.

                      Better luck this time Brian

                      #160786
                      Neil Wyatt
                      Moderator
                        @neilwyatt
                        Posted by MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 17:09:05:

                        Sorry. Can't work how to do a partial quote. This forum is different to every other one I use.

                        Hit the quote button and delete the parts fo the message you don't need.

                        Neil

                        #160787
                        Mark P.
                        Participant
                          @markp

                          Hi Les, the RCD trips when the motor gets up to speed (and I assume that the capacitor is taken out of the circuit). I will do a resistance check tomorrow and see whats what. Also will wire it up without any links fitted if it checks out ok. If it is goosed I've not lost anything as it was free. By the way Les my dummy CR2032 batteries worked, I got a regulated 3.3V PSU from flebay and my DRO's are all systems go.

                          Mark P.

                          #160798
                          Les Jones 1
                          Participant
                            @lesjones1

                            Hi Mark,
                            I have found that sometimes an RCD can trip due to a current of voltage spike when an inductive load is switched on or off. I have an old bench grinder that tripe the RCD every few weeks and my pillar drill used to do the same until I fitted a proper contactor type on/off switch. I do not fully understand the cause. I would expect a spark from the contacts on the centrifugal switch when it open but your description sounds like it is more than that.
                            I will wait for the results of tomorrow's tests.

                            Les.

                            #160826
                            MAX THE MILLER
                            Participant
                              @maxthemiller

                               

                              Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 22:31:16

                              #160828
                              MAX THE MILLER
                              Participant
                                @maxthemiller

                                I've tried quoting as suggested by Neil, but any text I type just becomes part of the quote.

                                 

                                ——————————–

                                Mark P.

                                Does this motor actually have a capacitor. If so it will be external to the motor and very obvious.

                                Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 22:35:10

                                Edited By MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 22:36:45

                                #160833
                                Chris Trice
                                Participant
                                  @christrice43267

                                  I’ve got a Makita cut off saw that trips the circuit breaker the moment it starts. Any solutions to this problem are welcome.

                                  #160835
                                  Jeff Dayman
                                  Participant
                                    @jeffdayman43397

                                    To Chris Trice:

                                    1. Depending on age of saw, call Makita and ask about a warranty repair?

                                    2. Throw it out and buy a new one?

                                    Makita tools are generally excellent equipment in my opinion, but after several years good service, if they fail, they are not valuable antique/vintage tools to be saved and restored, they are mass produced throwaways.

                                    JD

                                    #160842
                                    Roger Hart
                                    Participant
                                      @rogerhart88496

                                      According to my copy of 'Model Engineers Handbook' the red wire and the yellow wire go to live, the blue wire and the black wire go to neutral. To reverse direction then reverse the yellow and blue only. Of course earth the motor frame. The yellow and blue are the start winding in series with the centrifugal start switch.

                                      I have had trouble like this. The problem started as an occasional trip and got worse and worse. If the flashover (to frame) has persisted for some time the mica insulation will track and it may be impossible to clean it up to remove embedded metal particles. Worth a try though. The alternative is the skip.

                                      #160846
                                      MAX THE MILLER
                                      Participant
                                        @maxthemiller

                                        What you say is normally correct Roger, but this motor seems to have the centrifugal switch wired between the S and Z tags. Simply paralleling the two windings would leave the start winding permanently in circuit.

                                        #160857
                                        Les Jones 1
                                        Participant
                                          @lesjones1

                                          Hi Mark and others,
                                          First Mark. From Roger's comments I think I guessed wrongly which connections were the centrifugal switch and which was the start winding. So in the tests I suggested I think you should get a reading of a few ohms between T and S and almost zero between S and Z (The opposite way round to my last post.)

                                          Next Chris. If the cut off saw is a slow speed one with an HSS or carbide tipped blade then it will probably be an induction motor. If so a spark suppressor consisting of about a 100 ohm resistor in series with about a 100 nf capacitor (Of suitable rating for 250 volts AC) connected across the centrifugal switch contacts might help. You can get this type of suppressor with the resistor and capacitor encapsulated as a package. Another possibility is a transient suppressor (Sometimes called a metrosil I think.) connected across the start winding. (These are the devices use in surge suppressor sockets.) If the cutoff saw is the abrasive wheel type it will probably be a series (Also known as a universal) motor. If this is the case then the resistor/capacitor spark suppressor connected across the start switch might help. Also look for a build up of carbon dust around the brushes which might cause leakage to earth.

                                          Finally Roger. Your tracking to earth theory is also my favourite one. As a test I would be tempted to see if the fault still occurred with the earth removed and the motor insulated from earth. !!!! I WOULD NOT SUGGEST THAT YOU SHOULD TRY THIS MARK !!!!!!

                                          Les.

                                          #160858
                                          Neil Wyatt
                                          Moderator
                                            @neilwyatt

                                            It's easy!

                                            Posted by MAX THE MILLER on 15/08/2014 22:33:18:

                                            I've tried quoting as suggested by Neil, but any text I type just becomes part of the quote.

                                            Mouse to just under or over the quote and a red line with a box with a cracked arrow in it should appear. Click the arrow and it will insert a return under (or before) the quote, giving you a plain line to type on.

                                            Neil

                                            #160870
                                            Mark P.
                                            Participant
                                              @markp

                                              Hello Les, I've had a look at the motor and this is what I find.

                                              1. Between terminals S & T 15 ohms.

                                              2. Between terminals A & AZ 4 ohms.

                                              3. Between terminals A & AZ infinite.

                                              4. Between terminals Z & S initial high reading, increasing for 2 minutes then infinite.

                                              5. Between all terminals and casing infinite.

                                              The capacitor is on terminals S & Z.

                                              Terminal T goes to the centrifugal switch via a yellow wire.

                                              Terminal AZ goes to the windings via a red wire.

                                              Terminal S goes to the windings via a blue wire.

                                              Terminal A goes to the windings via a black wire.

                                              The other side of the switch goes to the windings via a yellow wire.

                                              I assume that I will need a link from Live to terminal T to feed into the start winding,and a link to neutral to terminal S.

                                              Mark P.

                                              #160874
                                              Neil Wyatt
                                              Moderator
                                                @neilwyatt

                                                There's a typo there – both 2 and 3 can't be right.

                                                Neil

                                                #160881
                                                Roger Hart
                                                Participant
                                                  @rogerhart88496

                                                  So, my apologies, its a capacitor start/induction run motor so my earlier comment was wrong. But the windings do not seem to be on the usual terminals, so going by winding colours (harder to confuse) we have red+black as the running winding so to live and neutral. The starting winding plus switch is blue+yellow and go in series with the capacitor to live and neutral. To reverse direction then change over either red+black or the blue+yellow.

                                                  You may be tempted by Les' suggestion which I would also follow – but be careful.

                                                  #160884
                                                  Les Jones 1
                                                  Participant
                                                    @lesjones1

                                                    Hi Mark and Roger,
                                                    I think your original assumption was reasonable as there was no mention of a capacitor and the fact that the centrifugal switch is connected internally to the start winding. Mark I think it is probably your statement 3 that is wrong. It would have been nice to have a reading between the windings to confirm that they are not connected together before any links are connected. Also a reading of the switch resistance may have been helpful as anything other than almost zero resistance could indicate dirty contacts which could indicate that it might spark more than normal. I think the way the motor was connected and the way the links were fitted was correct. I WILL REPEAT ROGER'S COMMENT THAT IF YOU DO THE TEST THAT I WOULD DO BE VERY VERY CAREFUL.

                                                    Les.

                                                    #160890
                                                    Mark P.
                                                    Participant
                                                      @markp

                                                      Hi Les, my mistake forget statement 3. There are 4 wires going to the windings,Yellow, Red, Black and Blue. I suppose that the Red and Black are the run windings and the Yellow and Blue via the switch are the start windings. Just rechecked the figures, A to AZ 4 ohms, S to T 15 ohms via switch (will clean switch contacts tomorrow) T to A infinite, A to S infinite so I assume that they are not connected internally

                                                      Mark P.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 39 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up