Help regarding choice in milling machine please

Advert

Help regarding choice in milling machine please

Home Forums Workshop Tools and Tooling Help regarding choice in milling machine please

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #135160
    Tracy Oatham 1
    Participant
      @tracyoatham1

      Hello all,

      I'm looking at upgrading from my Sieg SX2 milling machine, the one I was pretty set on was the Chester Mecury, (Sieg SX4) good price considering it comes with stand and DRO, only offput is its only available in MT4 spindle taper, link below :-

      http://www.chestermachinetools.com/mercury-mill-br-includes-dro–stand-7614-p.asp

      I'm now looking at the Chester Super lux machine, but cant find any reviews on it and was wondering if anyone here had any experience with it ????

      Link below :-

      http://www.chestermachinetools.com/super-lux-milling-machinebr2-axis-dro-3997-p.asp

      Many thanks for any help offered.

      John.

      Advert
      #17208
      Tracy Oatham 1
      Participant
        @tracyoatham1
        #135168
        JasonB
        Moderator
          @jasonb

          Axminster do the SX4 with R8 taper which is a bit more useful than the MT4 or use a MT4-MT3 reducing sleeve.

          J

          #135191
          Tracy Oatham 1
          Participant
            @tracyoatham1

            Hello and thanks for that,

            Axminster SX4 is quite a lot more £'s overpriced for the basic machine, no DRO's or stand included.

            Anyone else have any feedback on the Chester ????

            John.

            #135199
            Bazyle
            Participant
              @bazyle

              have you considered the 626 which seems to have some following on here in it's Warco equivalent.

              #135206
              michael cole
              Participant
                @michaelcole91146

                I use a Chester Lux with a 4MT spindle and over the last 10 years have been very happy with it,

                #135344
                jonathan heppel
                Participant
                  @jonathanheppel43280

                  For the same money, you can get good condition old iron. Well worth looking at.

                  #135349
                  Tracy Oatham 1
                  Participant
                    @tracyoatham1

                    Thank you all for your input, after reading quite a long thread from someone asking a similar question to mine above, I think I might now be looking at, as said by jonathan heppel, "old iron"

                    Now the real fun begins ) size wise (as I am quite limited) I have been looking at Tom Senior's as they seem to be in the size range that would suit me, have been looking at an E-type, only thing that concerns me with it though is the round column as I'm sure I read somewhere they are not as accurate/sturdy as say a square column ?????

                    John.

                    #135393
                    jonathan heppel
                    Participant
                      @jonathanheppel43280

                      I wouldn't worry about rigidity. Generally, a concern with round columns is position repeatability on the z axis, but there's a key that's meant to see to that. You may well find lack of a knee a nuisance when tool changing, and the high minimum speed a handicap also.

                      That said, it looks like it's excellent for high speed fine work. so I guess it depends what you're doing. Personally, i'd prefer a knee mill.

                      There was a thead on another Senior mill here a few weeks ago, which may be worth a look.

                      The myford and denford 626 and 836 may be worth looking at too. One issue with the 626 and 836 is their provenance. While there are many happy owners, there are also a few horror stories on the net also, often to do with warped castings. Proper stress relieving is an expensive process.

                    Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                    Advert

                    Latest Replies

                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                    View full reply list.

                    Advert

                    Newsletter Sign-up