The taper is approximately 0.486" per foot using your measurements. Brown and Sharpe is approximately 1/2" per foot, 0.50085(!) for number 9. Standard plug depth is 4 1/4".
It isn't Jarno or Morse both of which are about 0.6" per foot.
If your taper was extended by 1 1/4" it would be about 0.030" smaller, ten thou smaller than the .9008" of the small end of a Brown & Sharp No.9.
So… it might be one cut short, if your measurements are suspect, but I would expect a digital caliper to be within a thou or two.
I wouldn't go out and buy a mill to match taht taper though!
Neil