Araldite to seal a tender tank

Advert

Araldite to seal a tender tank

Home Forums Locomotives Araldite to seal a tender tank

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1590
    John Billard 1
    Participant
      @johnbillard1
      Advert
      #283668
      John Billard 1
      Participant
        @johnbillard1

        I am completing the tender tank for my Claud in 5" gauge. Its been a long job, since 2000, and the engine hasn't been started yet! But I have been using works drawings. I plan to seal with solder but there are some small internal places where the gap might be slightly too wide for this. Once finally assembled there will be some inaccessible areas that I have in mind.

        Are there any experiences in using Araldite as a seal? Just for water tightness, not for structural reasons.

        Best wishes

        John Billard

        #283672
        Neil Wyatt
        Moderator
          @neilwyatt

          You could use petrol tank sealer.

          Neil

          #283677
          Another JohnS
          Participant
            @anotherjohns

            John;

            On a recently completed tender, I soldered it together, but there were a couple of small pinhole leaks.

            I let it dry, (the wifes' electric hair dryer helped) and dribbled in that quick setting clear liquid glue that does a good job gluing ones fingers together – the one I used has the trade name "Crazy Glue". Once set, I tried it again, and no leaks. (what's the generic acronym for this glue – ACC??)

            I could have tried solder again, but did not want to go through the reheat.

            Anyway, just a data point for you.

            John

            #283681
            wheeltapper
            Participant
              @wheeltapper

              A bead of silicon carney should do the trick.

              Roy.

              #283684
              old Al
              Participant
                @oldal

                I woundnt use Araldite to seal a tender. it doesnt have a good bond on brass and is likely to leak after time.Crazy glue comes up as a cynoacrylate and i definatly woudnt use that near water.

                If you have access through the top of the tender, you should get a small flame and locally solder the gaps. What lead solder have you used so far. Plumbers solder fills bigger gaps, but has a higher melting point. Their are lower melting point stuff that would work also.

                You need to get it right at this point because a leaking tender will mess up your paintwork and will be a real pain to fix thereafter……. and make you cry….

                I have known people to use motorbike petrol tank sealer, its an expensive option, but seems to work

                #283685
                vintagengineer
                Participant
                  @vintagengineer

                  When I have soldered tanks including petrol tanks, I seal them and use a pump to gain a bit of negative pressure in the tank so that the solder gets sucks into the joint.

                  #283697
                  Neil Wyatt
                  Moderator
                    @neilwyatt
                    Posted by wheeltapper on 11/02/2017 18:13:53:

                    A bead of silicon carney should do the trick.

                    Blimey, I always thought Diane was a carbon-based life-form!

                    Neil

                    #283708
                    Scrumpy
                    Participant
                      @scrumpy

                      Hi I would stay away from silicon or araldite and look into using POR15 a sealer many people use to seal fuel and water tanks , I sealed the tender on my Marshall Roller some 5 years ago with it and it's still perfect

                      #283715
                      wheeltapper
                      Participant
                        @wheeltapper
                        Posted by Neil Wyatt on 11/02/2017 19:44:28:

                        Posted by wheeltapper on 11/02/2017 18:13:53:

                        A bead of silicon carney should do the trick.

                        Blimey, I always thought Diane was a carbon-based life-form!

                        Neil

                        Oh gawd, that didn't come out the way it was meant.

                        it was just a play on words; chilli con carne= silicon carney.

                        sorry Diane.

                        Roy.

                        #283716
                        Tractor man
                        Participant
                          @tractorman

                          I used an epoxy floor paint for my work shop floor and the bumph that came with it said it was ideal to seal the insides of tanks with. When it set on the floor I could see why. Very even coverage and hard as glass. May be a worthwhile investment,BMW use it for their showroom floors. Let me know and I will send details. Mick

                          #283718
                          nigel jones 5
                          Participant
                            @nigeljones5

                            This is what I did last time – and it works perfect. Make sure any intended holes are either accessible or bunged up with something covered in grease, then mix a cup of fibreglass resin and pour into the warmed tank. When warmed it goes very runny so gets into the leaky bits. Swirl it round up the sides etc then pull out the bung and let any excess run off. Cheap and completely effective, tried and tested!

                            #283720
                            John Billard 1
                            Participant
                              @johnbillard1

                              Some interesting ideas here. Thank you.

                              What is the objection to silicon sealer I wonder, Scrumpy? I have looked up POR15 and this comes up as an anti rust treatment – is that right?

                              Yes could you send details of the epoxy floor paint Mick?

                              I'd be interested in gap filling properties.

                              Kind regards

                              John

                              #283725
                              John Billard 1
                              Participant
                                @johnbillard1

                                Just checked again, POR15 is sold by Frosts as a tank sealer.

                                Thanks

                                John

                                #283732
                                Another JohnS
                                Participant
                                  @anotherjohns
                                  Posted by old Al on 11/02/2017 18:26:27:

                                  time.Crazy glue comes up as a cynoacrylate and i definatly woudnt use that near water.

                                  Why not? It needs moisture to cure. It is used by the medical industry and the aquarium industry. Now, we know that it is not a all-round perfect glue, as it has like zero shear strength, but for pinhole leak filling?

                                  Now, I would not glue a tank together with it, but for sealing, why not? (background, I did use it on my Tich, mid-80s, and seems to be just fine there, but should have a close look this coming spring, maybe I'll be in for a surprise!)

                                  John.

                                  #283733
                                  julian atkins
                                  Participant
                                    @julianatkins58923

                                    Hi John,

                                    Try to dress the joints a bit.

                                    I always use Bakers Fluid Flux and old fashioned sticks of plumbers solder. If there is any external excess it can be removed with various implements especially a Stanley blade etc.

                                    My platework is always very bad, but I have always found the above very forgiving of my lack of skill in platework.

                                    Cheers,

                                    Julian

                                    #283738
                                    JasonB
                                    Moderator
                                      @jasonb

                                      " I plan to seal with solder but there are some small internal places where the gap might be slightly too wide for this"

                                      If you have a few joints with gaps then poke some brass shim or copper wire into them and then the solder will bridge the gap

                                      #283740
                                      Brian Baker 2
                                      Participant
                                        @brianbaker2

                                        Greetings,

                                        There is a grade of epoxy specially made to bond copper brass and other metals, made by evo-stik.

                                        It works best when the joint area is roughed up with coarse emery.

                                        I have also used Gurit brand which is an epoxy used in boat building.

                                        On one of my early locos, the soft soldered joint started to weep, and i used a small rotary wire brush to clean the area, epoxy applied, no problem.

                                        Remember that copper metal catalyses the epoxy reaction which can then cure very quickly.

                                        It is always best to keep the joint gap as small as possible.

                                        regards

                                        Brian

                                        #283746
                                        Scrumpy
                                        Participant
                                          @scrumpy

                                          Why I say stear away from araldite is some 6/7 years ago my brother used it on his 5 in King over the next few years we had to keep cleaning the injectors of araldite .

                                          On a different forum it was suggested we use POR 15 which we did since then no problems we purchased from Amazon in a few weeks I will use it on my traction engine I have full confidence in this product

                                          Frost automotive have a good data sheet

                                          #283797
                                          Another JohnS
                                          Participant
                                            @anotherjohns

                                            Nick Feast wrote up a construction series for the Q1 locomotive.

                                            Pg 328, 11 March 2011 he starts describing how he used an automotive adhesive to glue the tender together.

                                            Has anybody any first-hand knowledge of how well this worked out over time?

                                            John.

                                            #283824
                                            John Billard 1
                                            Participant
                                              @johnbillard1

                                              Thank you everyone for such interesting replies. Further opinions will be welcome of course. Looking at my tender I will be using solder for the basic structure but some aspects will certainly need the cold treatment as it will be impracticable to use heat in certain places.

                                              Best wishes

                                              John B

                                              #283848
                                              Mark P.
                                              Participant
                                                @markp

                                                I’ve had a lot of sucess sealing tenders with automotive seam sealer.
                                                Mark P.

                                                #284667
                                                John Billard 1
                                                Participant
                                                  @johnbillard1

                                                  Mark, that looks useful. Is it okay for brass? Not many car bodies are made of that!

                                                  Best wishes and thanks

                                                  John

                                                  #284671
                                                  Mark P.
                                                  Participant
                                                    @markp

                                                    Hi John, yes it works well, cellulose based, paint it on, on a well degreased surface give it a couple of coats and let it dry between coats. Work it well into corners if you can rough the surface up a bit first so much the better. It seems to stay a bit flexable so no cracking or flaking. Give it a try.
                                                    Regards Mark P.

                                                    #288089
                                                    Andrew Binning
                                                    Participant
                                                      @andrewbinning37010

                                                      I sealed a 7 1/4" tender tank ( Brass ) with fibreglass epoxy and several years down the line there is a leak near the rounded profile at the bottom of the tank. The epoxy has come unstuck. I haven't attempted a repair yet but would be tempted to try the petrol tank sealer route. Araldite and epoxys don't bond well to brass.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Locomotives Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up