Both sets of tables are correct if used in their entirety and not mixed up.
Where the differences are concerned is where the infeed position is calculated from.
In Ivan’s book [ brilliant book BTW a must read if you are into gear cutting ] he calculates the infeed by touching the outer edge of the button on the blank, moving over to centralise then infeeds the distance in the table.
In the web article which was taken from calculations done by Grant in 18 ought plonk, the infeed is taken from a point where both buttons radially touch a blank of known width, [ W ], and then infeeds from this point.
It’s not easy to spot the differences between the two methods and this causes the tables to be different.
However if you drawn these out in CAD and overlay them, the differences are minute and both follow very closely a precise CAD drawn involute.
John S.
Edited By John Stevenson on 05/03/2010 12:30:35