SX2P – Thrust Bearings??

Advert

SX2P – Thrust Bearings??

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #379452
    J BENNETT 1
    Participant
      @jbennett1

      I have had an original X2 Mill for a number of years, which is now in pieces whilst undergoing a long running conversion to CNC, including the longer base and solid column upgrade.

      I need another mill and have been looking at the SX2P which seems generally well liked. However, looking at the exploded parts diagram on Arc's website I cannot see any sign of thrust races for the X and Y leadscrews. There appear to be just bearing blocks.

      Can anyone enlighten me as to how leadscrew thrust is is handled on the these machines?

      Advert
      #15203
      J BENNETT 1
      Participant
        @jbennett1
        #379464
        Neil Wyatt
        Moderator
          @neilwyatt

          I think that, like the SX2, they are plain bearings which is usually the case on smaller non-CNC machines.

          If you call Arc they will advise if they have a suitable aftermarket thrust bearings.

          Neil

          #379476
          JasonB
          Moderator
            @jasonb

            You need to go upto the SX2.7 before you get thrust bearings

            #379506
            J BENNETT 1
            Participant
              @jbennett1

              Thanks for the quick response.

              I have just had a quick look at the SX2 parts diagram and it appears to retain the double row thrust bearings on the X-axis as also used on the original X2. both the X2 and SX2 had plain bearings on the Y-axis. (Both exploded parts diagrams have the axis incorrectly labeled!). It would appear that the thrust bearings were dropped on the current SX2P version.

              As I have not seen any adverse comments regarding the operation of the X-axis leadscrew I will assume it is satisfactory and not put me off ordering one.

              When I have a moment I will post a bit about the current problem I have with the CNC conversion of the X2 and will be interested to know if any one else has encountered the same issue.

              #379507
              Neil Wyatt
              Moderator
                @neilwyatt

                I'm sure my X2 hasn't got thrust bearings on either axis, but it is an early version.

                Neil

                #379537
                J BENNETT 1
                Participant
                  @jbennett1

                  My X2 definitely has thrust bearings on the X-axis and its quite old. Arc's X2 (Old X2 Mini Mill Spares) page shows the bearings. I know there were quite a few variations of this mill, mine's a Warco Mini Mill, but as far as I know they all had thrust bearings on the X-axis.

                  #379546
                  JasonB
                  Moderator
                    @jasonb

                    I seem to remember Ketan saying that the new SX2P used some of the base/table parts from the 1 series which does not have the bearings. The older X2 and SX2 have a different base casting and look to have the thrust bearings.

                    #379549
                    Ron Laden
                    Participant
                      @ronladen17547

                      Mine is a SX2P and the manual (if you can call it that) is a bit of a joke, apparently the SX2P doesnt have an X axis it has two Y axis, one short running front to back and one long running left to right..wink It also has qty 3, "yes 3" leadscrew nuts on the long Y axis according to the parts list…lol. So the manual and its drawings are not to be trusted but it doesnt show any thrust bearings, which probably means it does have them ? but it probably got that bit right and it doesnt.

                      Anyway, I have experienced no problems with mine and the only adverse comment I have seen regarding the X axis is, and I quote "the X axis is probably not engineered as good as it could be" but as I say, I have found no issues.

                      Ron

                       

                      Edited By Ron Laden on 07/11/2018 08:34:54

                      Edited By Ron Laden on 07/11/2018 08:36:41

                      #379553
                      Russell Eberhardt
                      Participant
                        @russelleberhardt48058

                        If you look at my thread on converting the SX2P to CNC you will see that adding thrust bearings is easy.

                        **LINK**

                        http://www.mycncuk.com/threads/4524-Sieg-SX2-Plus-build?highlight=russell

                        Russell

                        #379558
                        Ron Laden
                        Participant
                          @ronladen17547

                          Thank you for the link Russell, that does look easy and certainly a mod I will do on my mill.

                          Ron

                          #379638
                          Alan Vos
                          Participant
                            @alanvos39612

                            I added thrust bearings to an SX2P. All it required was boring the right size blind holes in the bearing blocks. Very low risk. If you mess up, buy a new bearing block. Definitely worth doing.

                            #379645
                            Zan
                            Participant
                              @zan

                              There’s a series running in ME at this time on the cnc conversion of an SX2 plus. Have a look at that it’s a fully dimensioned series

                              #379669
                              Neil Wyatt
                              Moderator
                                @neilwyatt
                              Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
                              • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                              Advert

                              Latest Replies

                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                              Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                              View full reply list.

                              Advert

                              Newsletter Sign-up