Andrew
Figure 10 of the patent shows the device configured for ordinary straight slotting with a fixed tool held in a slotted, cylindrical, 'lantern" / "American" style tool post. The tool post also holds the two slides in alignment but has no provision to release the tool pressure on the return stroke, as a clapper box does, so the tool will drag on the return stroke.
Which will work but is not ideal.
As shown the arrangement also forces the tool tip to divine its support at rather greater distance from the holder than is the case with a Bridgeport E and similar clapper box equipped heads. Dealing with relatively long, somewhat slender tools is regrettably common when cutting keyways or splines in smaller bores so minimising tool length is a desirable attribute of a machine intended to regularly do such jobs.
Seems to me that, as designed and patented, the ability to do ordinary slotting is to meet an occasional need rather than regular work. So a relatively inexpensive but objectively imperfect design would be satisfactory. I'm a little surprised that an accessory clapper box type tool holder along the lines of the Bridgeport E head was not offered as an accessory for folk needing to regularily do internal slots. I guess it would have been too expensive for too small a market given that the machine is specifically aimed at the punch forming market where the need for ordinary slotting would be rare. The basic device is clearly going to be rather more expensive than an ordinary slotting head so getting one to do significant amounts of ordinary slotting work would not be economic.
Jan
If you contemplate doing ordinary internal slotting and vertical shaping up to a sharp shoulder I think it might well be worth the effort to make a clapper box style tool holder along the lines of that fitted to the Bridgeport E head. Not a vastly complex project. Basically an accurate U section base with a close fitted pin and inline tool holder held on by a shouldered bolt fitting the holes that lock the slides together.
I've found a few more references to show you the tooling a Bridgeport E uses.
Photos at the end of this thread :- **LINK**
https://www.practicalmachinist.com/forum/threads/bridgeport-shaping-attachment-tools.155587/
Catalogue picture of the Bridgeport set along with show off specimen jobs on page 8 here :- **LINK**
http://manuals.chudov.com/Bridgeport/attachments-cat-30.pdf
More pictures of Bridgeport tooling here :- **LINK**
https://www.hobby-machinist.com/threads/bridgeport-shaper-head-cutters-help-identifying.67069/
Just about possible to infer dimensions of the Bridgeport set from the drawings on this page :- **LINK**
http://manuals.chudov.com/Bridgeport/Shaper-Attachment/pg3.jpg
If you don't fancy doing a clapper box there is no reason why you couldn't make up a solid carrier extending down to the end of the ram drilled on the end to take that style of tool. Without a clapper box pivot the tools will drag on the return stroke and will quickly loose their sharp edge on harder material such as steel. On softer materials they are likely to pick up and adversely affect the finish.
But they will work.
Folk like us rarely need to do more than one or two slots at a time so even a short sharp edge lifetime should suffice.
Clive
Edited By Clive Foster on 10/12/2022 19:12:23