Posted by Hopper on 17/06/2022 08:04:34:
Posted by Gary Wooding on 17/06/2022 07:09:12:
It's strange how topics drift.
The OP asked the meaning of "long V" and "short V" jaws. Instead of actually answering the question we get a discussion about handwriting ones and sevens.
I would like to know the answer to the original question.
Possibly refers to the outside jaws having the long end of the stepped jaws machined to a V whereas the inside jaws have the short end of the stepped jaw machined to a V. Hence Long V and Short V jaws refers to the length of the V.
…
We'd all like to know the answer, but it seems no-one does! Hopper's is best suggestion so far, but it's too subtle for my taste. Not saying it's wrong, just not obviously right.
I spent yesterday's coffee-break touring a couple of jaw catalogues hoping to find an answer. No luck. Schunk list about 40 different styles of jaw, but no sign of long or short V jaws. Nothing in Pratt-Burnerd's web info either.
Chasing the best is a hard sport. Having made sure the lathe spindle is good, one buys a chuck with a proper specification. Specifications are good, but worrying unless they're understood! Figures don't mean much unless the way they were measured is known. And having understood the spec, some forum smart-a*se (me) points out luxury chuck owners also have to choose the most suitable jaws for the job from a long list!
My take is the main advantage of posh tooling is saving time. For example, my ordinary 3-jaw is good enough for most turning unless the job has to be taken out of the chuck and replaced, perhaps after a bit of milling. Taking work out of my 3-jaw is a bad move, because chuck doesn't allow accurate resetting, although putting it back exactly as it came out and tweaking with a DTI helps. Trouble is tweaking takes time and doesn't always work because the chuck doesn't have high repeatability.
One answer is to buy a better made 3-jaw chuck, but even these struggle to reset work when high accuracy is required. Better for amateur purposes I think to fit a 4-jaw when reset is needed, because even an ordinary one will give a top-end 3-jaw a run for it's money! But 4-jaws have a major disadvantage when it matters, which is the time taken to adjust them. Not a problem in my slow-moving tinkering workshop, but slow working methods are bad news when a pro machinist has to work against the clock. Collets are often a good answer, but they have other limitations. Jigs and fixtures outperform ordinary workshop methods, but are only worthwhile for mass-production.
I suspect the best way for an amateur to do high-precision work is by sending CAD files to a professional CNC shop. There's no need to have an expensively equipped workshop at all.
![devil devil]()
Not seriously suggesting we should do everything from comfy chairs! I enjoy my workshop, hands-on making things is interesting fun.
Dave
Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 17/06/2022 09:51:53