Drill powered nibblers – buying advice sought.

Advert

Drill powered nibblers – buying advice sought.

Home Forums Beginners questions Drill powered nibblers – buying advice sought.

Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #556598
    Robin Graham
    Participant
      @robingraham42208

      I want to make some curved cuts in 1.5mm mild steel sheet. It looks like a nibbler might be the tool of choice, but I don't want to pay £££s for a dedicated machine, so I've been looking at drill powered devices.

      At the bottom end I found a TOOGOO machine for £12, which does seem too good to be true. At the top end there is the Australian-made CaNibble at £50. In between there are many offerings including one from Axminster at £36.

      With the exception of the CaNibble all these tools look the same – I know that you gets what you pays for, but on the other hand I also know that identical items are marketed at widely different prices on Amazon and elsewhere.

      Does anyone have any experience with these tools?

      Robin,

      Edited By Robin Graham on 31/07/2021 23:51:14

      Advert
      #10916
      Robin Graham
      Participant
        @robingraham42208
        #556599
        Paul Lousick
        Participant
          @paullousick59116

          As you say, "you gets what you pay for" but all should come with some kind of warranty and if it does not work, send it back and get a refund. Check the return policy, some are free and some you have to pay postage. (Ebay and Paypal have return money policies. May take some time but you should get it back)

          Paul.

          #556600
          Ed Duffner
          Participant
            @edduffner79357

            Hi Robin, what radius cuts do you need to make? I cut a 90mm diameter hole the other day in some 3mm steel plate with a jigsaw and filed to finished size.

            Ed.

            #556603
            Steviegtr
            Participant
              @steviegtr

              I had a Makita 110v nibbler some years ago. Brilliant . Gave it away to a friend through not using it. But very good quality.

              Steve.

              #556615
              John Haine
              Participant
                @johnhaine32865

                **LINK**

                Uses one from RDG.

                #556629
                Baz
                Participant
                  @baz89810

                  I purchased the Axminster version a couple of years ago and I am very pleased with it, I have used it quite a lot for cutting up 18g sheet steel and it performs very well, it is powered by a Parkside cordless drill. For occasional use it seems to be very good value.

                  #556631
                  Bob Worsley
                  Participant
                    @bobworsley31976

                    Awful things, I bought a Bosch one, flog it to you if you want.

                    What is wrong? Well, they use a circular punch and die to cut in any direction so the swarf consists of millions of horseshoe shaped bits of metal, which get in the soles of your shoes.

                    #556633
                    not done it yet
                    Participant
                      @notdoneityet

                      Do you have a compressor? If so, a pneumatic nibbler might be an option?

                      #556635
                      Nick Wheeler
                      Participant
                        @nickwheeler
                        Posted by Nicholas Wheeler 1 on 01/08/2021 10:01:33:

                        I'm with Bob – don't do it. The swarf is horrible to deal with, the tool is bloody noisy, your drill will hate you and the cut edge will still need smoothing even if you do manage to cut along your line. An air powered nibbler adds the ghastly racket of the compressor.

                        Clamp some scrap plywood across the cut on both sides of the material and use a jigsaw.

                        #556637
                        Clive Foster
                        Participant
                          @clivefoster55965

                          +1 for Johns link on improving the tool. The length of the assembly when fitted in the chuck makes them hard to handle as does the relative rotational freedom. A solid strap between the drill and nibbler handles may make a worthwhile improvement in rigidity.

                          Next I use mine I shall figure out a solid strap between the drill handle and the nibbler handle to keep things more stable. Rather like the system used by the DeWalt shear attachment :- **LINK**.

                          https://www.dewalt.com/products/power-tools/polishers-shears-and-nibblers/18ga-shear-attachment/dwashrir

                          But stronger. That DeWalt device is a bit of a disappointment. Works but not nice to use due to lack of rigidity in the coupling.

                          But its five years since I used my nibbler so the matter is hardly urgent!

                          Plan B was to strip an old cordless drill to make a battery powered all in one. Even less urgent.

                          My experience is that even the uber-cheap ones will work OK. For a while at least so its really a matter of estimating how much use it will get.

                          Chip control has to be taken really seriously. Big bag in a stand with something to hold the mouth open underneath coupled to disciplined clearing at regular intervals is essential. Catches half to two thirds of the things.

                          Thats why mine is a last resort tool.

                          Clive

                          #556643
                          roy entwistle
                          Participant
                            @royentwistle24699

                            1.5mm mild steel, I'd use a piercing saw, medium to fine teeth lubricate blade with a candle

                            Fret saw if piercing saw is too small in the throat

                            Roy

                            #556654
                            Terry B
                            Participant
                              @terryb

                              For anything upto that thickness I use a jigsaw with a metal cutting blade. No distortion, make sure you use eye protection as the odd metal chip can fly up.

                              #556659
                              Nick Wheeler
                              Participant
                                @nickwheeler
                                Posted by Terry B on 01/08/2021 12:23:51:

                                For anything up to that thickness I use a jigsaw with a metal cutting blade. No distortion, make sure you use eye protection as the odd metal chip can fly up.

                                Interesting, as 1.5mm thick is about the thinnest I'd use a jigsaw on. And would prefer some support along the cut as I suggested above.

                                Thinner than 1.5mm I use snips and some ibuprofen….

                                #556663
                                Hacksaw
                                Participant
                                  @hacksaw

                                  I've got one too. Yes , noisy . Yes , very messy sharp bits , ( I clear up best i can with a welding magnet if it's steel ) I often have a dog in the workshop, who loves getting arc eye , metal splinters in his paws , and the vice tommy bar whacking him on the head !

                                  Unless it's a more substantial one than mine , it'll struggle on 1.5mm steel . Needs plenty of practice to cut curves accurately .. the steel needs lubricating on the cut line . Forever jamming , and they dislike being pulled back in a cut for a second go ..

                                  I've often thought if it was mounted upside down on a table so it was rigid like a router table , It could work better . But then the bits would be firing straight at your face ..?

                                  #556670
                                  ega
                                  Participant
                                    @ega

                                    The OP's CaNibble link shows the tool mounted upside down with the [female] operator using gloves but no eye protection.

                                    Incidentally, the Monodex type shear, which produces a c 3mm wide waste strip, works well for shallow curves in thin material.

                                    #556671
                                    old mart
                                    Participant
                                      @oldmart

                                      I bought one similar to the Axminster one, I forget the name, the spare parts make it better value. A line of oil should be run along the cut line, or the parts will wear quickly. You can rotate the heads and lock them quickly to make the direction of feed easier.

                                      #556685
                                      lee webster
                                      Participant
                                        @leewebster72680

                                        As mentioned above, noisy, messy, more messy, difficult to control, messy. Bought one used it a couple of times threw it away. Best thing I did was throw it away. I would rather bite my way through metal than use one of those.

                                        #556704
                                        Grindstone Cowboy
                                        Participant
                                          @grindstonecowboy

                                          As others have said, messy – I have one somewhere, used it once, went back to the Monodex type.

                                          Rob

                                          #556706
                                          Nick Wheeler
                                          Participant
                                            @nickwheeler
                                            Posted by Grindstone Cowboy on 01/08/2021 21:43:01:

                                            As others have said, messy – I have one somewhere, used it once, went back to the Monodex type.

                                            Rob

                                            I have, use and like those. But not on 1.5mm thick steel.

                                            #556707
                                            Mike Poole
                                            Participant
                                              @mikepoole82104

                                              Trumpf This has to be the ultimate nibbler, the template section of our tool room was revolutionised when they got a CNC nibbler.

                                              Mike

                                              Edited By Mike Poole on 01/08/2021 23:14:58

                                              #556711
                                              Robin Graham
                                              Participant
                                                @robingraham42208

                                                Thanks for replies. Perhaps I should have said that that my project is to make a sort of bbq/smoker thingy out of oil drums and scrap sheet metal, so I need to cut holes for vents, tubes etc in both the curved surfaces of the drums and the flat ends. I didn't frame the question as 'what's the best way from here to there' because I wanted opinions specifically about nibbling tools. Generally, when I buy a new tool for a particular job I have an eye on its usefulness for other things.

                                                I have piercing saws, which are great for what they do, but wouldn't work here because of the geometry. I also have a jigsaw, but it's my second most hated tool (first is the angle grinder*) – cutting anything thin without support, which would be difficult in this case, doesn't work well.

                                                I'm encouraged to go ahead and try a cheapy after following John Haine's link to mikesworkshop.

                                                A lot of the negative comments both here and elsewhere concern the pesky crescents. I don't think that would be a problem for me because I have a scarily powerful vacuum machine which would whisk them away.

                                                Thanks again for replies,

                                                Robin.

                                                *Angle grinder phobia – I have a groove in my left kneecap thanks to a momentary lapse of concentration. A&E, much blood, and a new pair of trousers ruined. Not only in the knee area.

                                                R.

                                                 

                                                 

                                                Edited By Robin Graham on 02/08/2021 01:19:15

                                                #556716
                                                Howard Lewis
                                                Participant
                                                  @howardlewis46836

                                                  You will have to tidy up after your ears recover, and you have swept up all the crescent moon bits of swarf.

                                                  In which case, why not mark out, and chain drill?

                                                  You will still have the filing, and clearing to do just as if you had used a nibbler.

                                                  Depending on the size, would a hole saw do the job?

                                                  Howard

                                                  #556757
                                                  Ed Duffner
                                                  Participant
                                                    @edduffner79357

                                                    With regard to nibblers specifically and having repaired several Makita's in my day job, I wouldn't choose to buy one myself. The motor ingests the crescents and there goes the motor.

                                                    The replacement parts are also very expensive, at least for Makita. Registering for a longer warranty, if available, is definitely a recommendation.

                                                    Ed.

                                                  Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
                                                  • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                  Advert

                                                  Latest Replies

                                                  Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                                  Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                  Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                  View full reply list.

                                                  Advert

                                                  Newsletter Sign-up