Cutting an M33 x 3.5 thread on my ML7

Advert

Cutting an M33 x 3.5 thread on my ML7

Home Forums Beginners questions Cutting an M33 x 3.5 thread on my ML7

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 31 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #10354
    Captain Barnacles
    Participant
      @captainbarnacles
      Advert
      #488350
      Captain Barnacles
      Participant
        @captainbarnacles

        Hello all,

        I am taking delivery of a new wood lathe in the next couple of weeks and it has an M33 x 3.5 thread on the headstock. I was wondering if it is possible (given my very limited experience) to produce items like face plates etc for the wood lathe using my ML7?

        I have a selection of change gears and I understand that it is possible to cut metric threads but I am a bit hazy on the set up. Looking at the chart It looks like I need to use B50 D75 A30 C45 E63 Is that correct? Presumably I then need a thread cutting tool on a bar? Can I then cut 3.5mm pitch threads on anything I can fit in the chuck? What size should I hole should I have before I start cutting internal threads?

        Many thanks in advance for any advice.

        #488399
        not done it yet
        Participant
          @notdoneityet

          I was wondering if it is possible (given my very limited experience) to produce items like face plates etc for the wood lathe using my ML7?

          It is possible but some experience would be beneficial… I expect lots have done it in the past, while not particularly experienced.

          #488402
          Ady1
          Participant
            @ady1

            You need to practice on smaller threads, say 12mm, until you are confident

            You may find it easier to do it by hand, instead of under power, especially if you only need a one-off item

            GL

            #488420
            Captain Barnacles
            Participant
              @captainbarnacles
              Posted by Ady1 on 31/07/2020 07:53:14:

              You need to practice on smaller threads, say 12mm, until you are confident

              You may find it easier to do it by hand, instead of under power, especially if you only need a one-off item

              GL

              Thank you. So manually rotate the chuck, I can see the sense in that. It's difficult to do much damage at 6 RPM I suppose laugh.

              #488429
              SillyOldDuffer
              Moderator
                @sillyoldduffer
                Posted by Captain Barnacles on 31/07/2020 09:28:59:

                Posted by Ady1 on 31/07/2020 07:53:14:

                You need to practice on smaller threads, say 12mm, until you are confident

                You may find it easier to do it by hand, instead of under power, especially if you only need a one-off item

                GL

                Thank you. So manually rotate the chuck, I can see the sense in that. It's difficult to do much damage at 6 RPM I suppose laugh.

                Make a crank-handle to fit into the spindle from the headstock end. The sort of expanding clamp used to attach bicycle handle bars is suitable. Turn an aluminium rod about 50mm long to just fit inside the lathe's spindle. Drill it through to take a suitably long bolt or length of studding, loose fit (say 1mm oversize). Cut the 50mm rod in the middle at an a sharp angle ( less than 45° ), so the two halves wedge into the spindle when the bolt is tightened. Put a handle of the other end. Although slow it gives plenty of control for thread cutting, which is an advantage in this case.

                3.5mm pitch is a very coarse thread and cutting it will stress the gears. Take gentle cuts to avoid breaking anything. The handle lets you feel excessive force being applied.

                Dave

                Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 31/07/2020 10:06:23

                #488430
                not done it yet
                Participant
                  @notdoneityet

                  There are plenty of taps available. £22.61 could get you one (don’t know what quality it might be) from epay.

                  While I would not suggest you try to use one just like that to cut the thread, you could rough it out the thread on the lathe and finish it off with the tap.

                  #488439
                  Ady1
                  Participant
                    @ady1
                    Posted by not done it yet on 31/07/2020 10:07:57:

                    There are plenty of taps available. £22.61 could get you one (don’t know what quality it might be) from epay.

                    While I would not suggest you try to use one just like that to cut the thread, you could rough it out the thread on the lathe and finish it off with the tap.

                    +1

                    If you can get a tap for 22quid, grab it, a die too

                    Do most of the work on the lathe and only finish off with the tap/die

                    Starting the thread on the lathe also ensures it is parallel/straight, not as easy  to achieve as you would imagine, especially on a big piece

                    They become part of the lathe if you ever sell it and are a huge help for useful bits if you hang onto it

                    Edited By Ady1 on 31/07/2020 10:42:35

                    #488484
                    Howard Lewis
                    Participant
                      @howardlewis46836

                      3.5 mm pitch is not too far removed from the 8 tpi of the Myford Leadscrew. You need to set up a gear train so that the Leadscrew runs at 1.1023622 times that of the chuck . A 33:30 will give the closest approximation (33.07087) , but using standard gears 55:50 will be the next nearest approximation (55.11811 equating to 0.2147454% error ).

                      By using a compound train, it should be possible to reduce the error even more. But you are looking to provide a ratio of 1:1.0021475, which is not possible with standard gears, incrementing by 5T..

                      Making a 22T gear, to drive a 20T on the Leadscrew, via one or more idlers will not improve matters. (You would probably need to use the tumbler reverse ) The ideal gear with 22.09459T, would give an error of 1.0042995, or 0.4299545% which is worse

                      Have a play with an EXCEL spreadsheet to see if you can come up with a more accurate gear train..

                      As already said, practice on smaller material to get the pitch right, before attacking expensive large diameter material!

                      HTH

                      Howard

                      #488568
                      Brian Wood
                      Participant
                        @brianwood45127

                        Captain Barnacles

                        I can offer four thread set ups for this pitch

                        For a Myford ML7 with gearbox the Mandrel gear will be 33 teeth; it replaces the 24 tooth gear of the standard imperial gearing. Match that to 10 TPI selected on the gearbox—the pitch generated will be 3.493 mm

                        For change wheel machines here are three alternative choices. They all need a 63 tooth wheel in the gear train

                        Mandrel 38—drives 63 on the first stud which is linked to 55 teeth. Idler(s) will be needed to couple to 30 teeth on the leadscrew. Pitch outcome is 3.51 mm

                        Mandrel 50—drives 63 on the first stud which is linked to 50 teeth, Again idler(s) will be needed to couple to 36 teeth on the leadscrew. Pitch outcome is 3.499 mm

                        Mandrel 60—drives 63 teeth on the first stud which is linked to 44 teeth. Once again idlers will be need to couple to 38 teeth on the leadscrew. Pitch outcome 3.501 mm

                        Others have suggested you practice on easier pitches to start with and use a mandrel handle for manually cutting these coarse threads

                        Finally you ask what hole size is needed to tap your 33 mm x 3.5 mm thread. It should be 29.5 mm diameter

                        Kind regards Brian

                        Edited By Brian Wood on 31/07/2020 20:52:46

                        Edited By Brian Wood on 31/07/2020 20:53:19

                        #488582
                        not done it yet
                        Participant
                          @notdoneityet

                          Do remember that it is the register surfaces that are, by far, the most important part – the thread is only there to keep those registers together precisely, so generally doesn’t need to be absolutely perfect in form.

                          #488584
                          Mike Poole
                          Participant
                            @mikepoole82104

                            Machining a chuck backplate or faceplate can often be one of the early jobs that a new lathe owner will have to tackle, a good read up on the way to approach the job will be very helpful. Screw cutting is a very useful skill to acquire and a good understanding of the features of a screw thread is a good start followed by how to sharpen a tool for the job and set the lathe up, measuring what you are doing and knowing what your target is, is important. ReadIng up and watchIng some videos will help to get a clear plan of how to do the job. A few practice runs will help get a feel for the task and boost your confidence, hopefully.

                            Mike

                            #488613
                            Captain Barnacles
                            Participant
                              @captainbarnacles

                              Thank you all so much, there's some fabulous information for me to digest.

                              I hadn't considered using a tap, I suppose that's a great example of Occams Razor at work. It's an approach that would give me the result that I'm looking for quickly and easily. I was rather looking forward to trying thread cutting on the lathe and it's a skill I would like to become competent at in case I need to machine something for which I dont have a tap or die. I think in the case of M33x3.5 though a tap would be a good investment as I plan on making several accessories.

                              I really like the idea of using a hand crank to rotate the work at a very controlled speed. I have a VFD on my lathe and can slow it right down but the torque seems to drop off quickly at the lower end of the speed range and I imagine that when cutting threads torque is all important.

                              My ML7 doesn't have a gearbox unfortunately. It looks as though I may need to buy additional change gears as mine all are in increments of 5. I have downloaded Duncan's app for calculating change gearing so I'll be off down the workshop this morning to take stock of exactly what gears I have available and see what I can do with them. I can see that it may be worthwhile purchasing additional gearing as I'm much more likely to cut metric threads in future.

                              One further thought, what material choice would you recommend? When I have used face plates in the past (for wood turning) the small ones, say 2-3", seem to be steel but larger ones seem to be lighter, perhaps some alloy?? Would standard grade aluminium be too soft (not to mention expensive)?

                              #488629
                              JohnF
                              Participant
                                @johnf59703

                                Captain, most things have been said already however the first thing I would make is plug gauge to test the internal thread you are cutting. Measure the mandrel thread using the 3-wire method then replicate the thread on a piece of steel bar so you can be sure the thread in any attachments you care to make will fit the mandrel on the wood lathe.

                                Also remember you cannot disengage the half nuts when cutting a metric thread on an imperial lathe, you must travers the carriage back between each cut. However if you do have a chasing dial there is method of using it but not in the normal way, I do have a written explanation if you want it but have a look at this link for a pretty good video of the method **LINK**

                                Lastly you asked the bore size for the thread and Brian is correct at 29.5mm but I would recommend you truncate the thread by 0.1 – 0.2 mm so make the bore 29.6 – 29.7 thus ensuring clearance on the root of the mandrel. Also remember to take this into account when cutting the thread to depth.

                                John

                                #488631
                                Clive Brown 1
                                Participant
                                  @clivebrown1

                                  Hi Cap'n!

                                  Some thoughts; I wouldn't see a tap as a quick and easy way of cutting an accurate 33mm x 3.5mm thread unless it's used purely for final finishing to size of a thread previously cut in a lathe. It's far to much metal to remove IMO and will be very difficult, perhaps impossible, to drive, esp. in steel.

                                  Aluminium might be OK. Cast-iron should be good, although still fairly tough going. With a mandrel handle you will find steel very hard work with that size of thread, even aluminum won't be that easy. Don't forget also that, for a metric thread on your machine, you can't disengage the half-nuts to return the carriage after each cut. It will have to be wound back. I'd favour using the VFD with the lathe back-gear and belt settings to give lowest speed with adequate torque and ability reverse the motor.

                                  #488633
                                  Thomas Cooksley
                                  Participant
                                    @thomascooksley79020

                                    Hi Captain, while I don't have a myford 7 and therefore am unable to comment on if it is able to cut a 3.5mnm pitch thread. I can help with some general information about cutting threads.

                                    As Brian Woods said your starting hole needs to be 29.5mm, it's easy to work out in metric just take the pitch away from the nominal diameter. Ie 33-3.5=29.5. Also you will need a lathe tool with a 60 degree cutting tip as all metric threads are 60 degree.(a lot of imperial threads are 55 degree)

                                    If you decide to use taps to cut your thread you will most likely need a set of three taps: taper, second and plug. Because the thread will need to go all the way to the bottom in order to screw on the shaft.

                                    Hope some of this helps, Tom.

                                    #488642
                                    not done it yet
                                    Participant
                                      @notdoneityet

                                      Tom,

                                      It would most certainly would not need three taps. It is a through-hole, so even a first tap would suffice, if long enough.

                                      A 33 mm thread may need more grunt than is available if starting from scratch (particularly if cut in steel🙂 ).

                                      A 60 degree cutter would be necessary if the OP cuts it all on the lathe. Cutter geometry is not an absolutely overarching necessity, if roughing out and finishing with any one of the three tap set – just being careful not to exceed 60 degrees is most important (but harder finishing with a tap, if roughed out at less than 60 degrees).

                                      Depth of cut would clearly need to be less than half the pitch, if roughed out on the lathe – even if only to leave just a small finishing cut, if the cutter were 60 degrees, and obviously less if the cutter angle was ground slightly under the target angle.

                                      Edited By not done it yet on 01/08/2020 12:36:22

                                      #488645
                                      Neil Lickfold
                                      Participant
                                        @neillickfold44316

                                        One of the newer things these days is live tooling. So a router is used and is set up on the tool post with an adaptor and with a 55 deg, or 60 deg multi flute cutter. And away you go. For external threads is mounted in line with the work piece and a D bit will work with a 60 deg or 55 deg depending on the thread form of course. With multi point cutters, one idea being used is the cutter has 4 teeth, 2 at the full form and 2 at less than full form. The lesser form does a rough out while the full does the final finish . These work better than just all 4 as a full form.

                                        Here is a link to Stefan Gotteswinter on youtube who shows some things with his set up..

                                        Neil

                                        #488649
                                        roy entwistle
                                        Participant
                                          @royentwistle24699

                                          Neil The OP has stated that he is cutting internal threads.

                                          #488667
                                          Thomas Cooksley
                                          Participant
                                            @thomascooksley79020

                                            Hi Everyone, not done it yet I'm sorry, not being familiar with wood lathes I assumed that the centre hole in the face plate would be smaller than the size of the shaft leaving a lip to come up against the end of the shaft, thus requiring tapping right up to the lip.

                                            Tom.

                                            #488716
                                            Neil Lickfold
                                            Participant
                                              @neillickfold44316

                                              Not on the home lathe, but many cnc lathes with live tooling cut internal threads with a thread profile wood ruf cutter.

                                              The advantage is a very clean thread that is de burred and has the leading feather edge removed. It also allows for a timed start of the thread relative to other detail on the part.

                                              Many who do woodwork also thread mill internal threads on the lathe with small cutters down to 5/16 threads.I am looking at making a set up for my Myford lathe, with a variable speed trim router to drive the cutter based on either 6mm or 1/4 inch collet, and getting some cutters made in Carbide from a company in Auckland.

                                              #488734
                                              Hopper
                                              Participant
                                                @hopper
                                                Posted by Neil Lickfold on 01/08/2020 22:39:04:

                                                Not on the home lathe, but many cnc lathes with live tooling cut internal threads with a thread profile wood ruf cutter.

                                                The advantage is a very clean thread that is de burred and has the leading feather edge removed. It also allows for a timed start of the thread relative to other detail on the part.

                                                Many who do woodwork also thread mill internal threads on the lathe with small cutters down to 5/16 threads.I am looking at making a set up for my Myford lathe, with a variable speed trim router to drive the cutter based on either 6mm or 1/4 inch collet, and getting some cutters made in Carbide from a company in Auckland.

                                                If you look on YouTube at old films of British factories making Howitzer shells and the like you can see the next step in this internal thread milling process. The cutter instead of being like a profiled woodruff cutter is multi rowed, looking more like a gear hob. So it is plunged straight into the job, which is then rotated one turn to cut all 10 or so turns of thread in one hit. Very time efficient and a perfect result every time.

                                                #488754
                                                not done it yet
                                                Participant
                                                  @notdoneityet

                                                  Yes, but we are hobbyists, not making thousands, or millions, of the same item on a production line (with several processes being carried out simultaneously or in quick succession) such as in a munitions factory. KISS principle should apply – at least for new starters – leaving the more difficult/specialised manipulations for the others.

                                                  #488832
                                                  Captain Barnacles
                                                  Participant
                                                    @captainbarnacles
                                                    Posted by Thomas Cooksley on 01/08/2020 16:29:01:

                                                    Hi Everyone, not done it yet I'm sorry, not being familiar with wood lathes I assumed that the centre hole in the face plate would be smaller than the size of the shaft leaving a lip to come up against the end of the shaft, thus requiring tapping right up to the lip.

                                                    Tom.

                                                    Good point. I believe that most faceplates do have through holes which allows the face of the threaded cylinder to mate up to a flat face on the headstock spindle. However, I have seen faceplates which do not have through holes and I do not know if these have a thread which is long enough to provide mating surfaces (as the through hole type would do) or if the "stop" is provided by the end of the threaded spindle coming up against the bottom of the faceplate's threaded cylinder. Apologies if my terminology isn't accurate, I'm not an engineer (yet!).

                                                    More good information to digest, I am most grateful for all the input. One thing I am realising is that it's not quite as simple as I first envisaged but I'm stubborn. Difficult/Challenging = Worthwhile in my book.

                                                    #488879
                                                    Thomas Cooksley
                                                    Participant
                                                      @thomascooksley79020

                                                      Hi Captain, the more you do in this game the more you will find that there are many different names for things and processes as well. There are many modern names for things that more traditional engineers call something else, none of them Wong, just different.

                                                      The simple fact is that there will be a: stop, lip, register (call it what you like) to tighten up against. If you had a straight main spindle and a through hole it would just get tighter and tighter while you were turning your wood. The end of the spindle may come right through and damage what you are making. Also you would find difficult if not impossible to unscrew the two parts.

                                                      Tom.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 31 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up