Short drill or Spot / Centre drill first

Advert

Short drill or Spot / Centre drill first

Home Forums Beginners questions Short drill or Spot / Centre drill first

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #10320
    Chris TickTock
    Participant
      @christicktock
      Advert
      #484398
      Chris TickTock
      Participant
        @christicktock

        Hi,

        I am making a crossing out jig for clock wheels and need to drill a piece of aluminium I have which is 25mm thick.

        I will need to drill approx 20 through holes approx 3mm dia. I intend using my mill and rotary table to find the positions of the holes but the question arises do I need to centre drill these holes first or will a short drill be rigid enough used on the mill.

        My thinking is this is a job where absolute precision of the hole diameter is not crucial but I would like each hole to be within a reasonable few thou of each other. Once the holes are drilled pegs later made on the lathe have to be made to fit in the holes and each peg should be a fairly decent fit in any hole. A fairly good fit is required what is important is the holes as I said must be pretty uniform. Is a reamer required here or will a short drill likely do it in one?

        Chris

        #484406
        Paul Lousick
        Participant
          @paullousick59116

          If you want the holes to be within a thou of each other, I would use a spotting drill first (or a small centre drill if you do not have one). A short 3mm drill could drill flex slightly but spotting and centre drills have a bigger diameter and more rigid.

          Paul.

          #484409
          Ian Parkin
          Participant
            @ianparkin39383

            I would make your pegs first and experiment with drills in your material to get your required fit

            make your pegs out of 3mm silver steel perhaps

            rather than as you said making your pegs fit the holes…make the holes fit the pegs

            #484415
            Baz
            Participant
              @baz89810

              I would most certainly centre drill or use a spotting drill to start the holes, if you use 3mm silver steel as suggested by Paul for the pins I would ream the holes, you then stand a chance of getting them all pretty much the same size.

              #484416
              Chris TickTock
              Participant
                @christicktock

                Thanks Guys for posts todate.

                At the moment I am noting all posts before taking a view.

                Doing some further research I have come across spit point or 4 facet drills which virtually eliminate wander. Still struggling to get ectly the difference in geometry but think it may come down to instead of having a complete v angle cutting the point is altered in some way. Can anyone give me or point me to a better explanation.

                Chris

                #484417
                Former Member
                Participant
                  @formermember32069

                  [This posting has been removed]

                  #484418
                  Chris TickTock
                  Participant
                    @christicktock
                    Posted by Barrie Lever on 07/07/2020 11:47:28:

                    Chris

                    Are you doing this on a Sherline? No reason not to just checking. Remember if it is a Sherline to make sure everything is trammed in well and to use sharp tools as machine flex will be come your enemy.

                    Spot drill first especially if on a Sherline or similar small machine, then replace with a decent rigid drill, do this for each hole.

                    Don't run around and spot drill every hole and then come back and drill off as the repeat positioning will let you down at some stage.

                    I often make quick fixtures just using a spot drill followed by a decent drill. You will get a push fit if the peg material is accurate.

                    In this World there are drills and there are drills, really good drills will produce better holes than bad reamers.

                    I would pretty well guarantee a good result even in a light weight machine if using decent tools.

                    If the peg is just a peg with no complicated feature then you should consider just buying in ground dowels rather than turning these parts up, I often buy dowels on Ebay but also Talbot Tool in Sussex are good for these.

                    Drills and spot drills either Hoffmann or Drill Service.

                    B.

                    Edited By Barrie Lever on 07/07/2020 11:49:06

                    Thanks Barry,

                    You have answered one of my reasons for asking and that was I too think drilling all the holes with a spot drill then replacing after doing all holes is likely to invite inaccuracies, so doing each one in turn is the answer if i go that route. Still researching a fully ground split point though.

                    Chris

                    #484421
                    Chris TickTock
                    Participant
                      @christicktock
                      Posted by Chris TickTock on 07/07/2020 11:37:28:

                      Thanks Guys for posts todate.

                      At the moment I am noting all posts before taking a view.

                      Doing some further research I have come across spit point or 4 facet drills which virtually eliminate wander. Still struggling to get ectly the difference in geometry but think it may come down to instead of having a complete v angle cutting the point is altered in some way. Can anyone give me or point me to a better explanation.

                      Chris

                      Update; found the explanation hope it helps a future reader.

                      A Split Point drill has two additional edges ground into the chisel edge (flat centre of drill bit)

                      which make the entire point of the drill one long cutting edge.

                      Chrus

                      #484424
                      Steve Crow
                      Participant
                        @stevecrow46066

                        Hi Chris,

                        For jobs like this, I use stub length split point drills from cncpoorboy. They are very good quality. Being stub length, they don't flex much and eliminate the need for spotting.

                        25mm is quite deep for a 3mm drill. Do you need to go all the way through or will a blind hole do?

                        Steve

                        #484429
                        not done it yet
                        Participant
                          @notdoneityet

                          If you want to ensure all your pegs fit vertically, spot or centre drill as it just makes common sense to take precautions to avoid the drill ‘wandering’, even before entry.

                          #484433
                          JasonB
                          Moderator
                            @jasonb

                            If you are only needing a few thou accuracy then if blind I would go straight at then with a stub length split point drill, something like Dormer A022 series. If they are though holes then you will need a jobber length drill which is a bit more flexible so I would spot first, if you don't have a DRO then spot & drill at each position before moving to the next.

                            Lubricate drill with paraffin or WD 40 and withdraw often to clear swarf particularly if through holes.

                            Put some drag onto your rotary table as the large PCD of your peg holes combined with a small table will accentuate any backlash and have far more bearing on accuracy of position than what you are actually drilling with.

                             

                            Edited By JasonB on 07/07/2020 13:11:37

                            #484444
                            Chris TickTock
                            Participant
                              @christicktock

                              Thanks Guys really useful.

                              Steve's point, do I have to go all the way through. Answer is no but Malcolm Wild advised to enable release of stuck pins. I could just as easily not cater for this as the additional work may not be necessary….will think on this??

                              Equally taking all posts on board to drill first using the single point to 8mm on one radius then using the rotary table reverse one step at a time manually (so I can check its position) with say a 2mm jobber to give a small through hole for the release mechanism, the accuracy of this hole should not matter??

                              Jason what is a DRO? I know several people use WD40 for aluminium but the clock forum has scared me stiff of it so paraffin it is which I have anyway. Good point Jason on drag on rotary I think this parameter comes down to speed on the Sherline but have only used it a little yet.

                              Chris

                              #484447
                              Emgee
                              Participant
                                @emgee

                                Chris

                                I recently bought several different tapping size split point drills and found they cut oversize in all materials, especially aluminium, so best check your drills for drilled hole size in a piece of scrap before letting an unknown drill spoil your work.

                                I will add that the store agreed to a full refund including postage when I return the drills.

                                Emgee

                                #484459
                                Steve Crow
                                Participant
                                  @stevecrow46066

                                  Chris, Is your rotary table the Sherline CNC model?

                                  #484468
                                  JasonB
                                  Moderator
                                    @jasonb

                                    Don't reverse with your rotary table, just complete one circle and then go round again so you are always feeding in the same direction which will help to reduce backlash.

                                    Yes Keep the WD40 away from the actual clocks as it can go sticky over time but no problem using it as a cutting fluid on aluminium

                                    DRO = Digital Read Out. This gives exact position of the mill's table so you can be just about certain to return to the same spot which would allow you to do several hole at one angular setting and then get the ones on the next angular setting spaced out on the same radii. As you don't there will be some play (backlash) in the handwheels and leadscrews then do all at one radius winding the rotary table in a positive direction spotting and then drilling each one then move out to the next radius and go round again.

                                    Edited By JasonB on 07/07/2020 16:25:28

                                    #484502
                                    Chris TickTock
                                    Participant
                                      @christicktock
                                      Posted by Steve Crow on 07/07/2020 15:14:37:

                                      Chris, Is your rotary table the Sherline CNC model?

                                      Yes Steve but I have a manual one as well.

                                      Chris

                                      #484586
                                      Steve Crow
                                      Participant
                                        @stevecrow46066

                                        Hi Chris, the reason I ask is if you have the CNC table there is no problem with repeatability when indexing so you can go round and spot, change tools, go round and drill and then again to ream for each circle of holes.

                                        Steve

                                        #484599
                                        Chris TickTock
                                        Participant
                                          @christicktock
                                          Posted by Steve Crow on 08/07/2020 14:25:17:

                                          Hi Chris, the reason I ask is if you have the CNC table there is no problem with repeatability when indexing so you can go round and spot, change tools, go round and drill and then again to ream for each circle of holes.

                                          Steve

                                          Thanks Steve, I am still familarising myself with the instructions relating to tiny positional error and backlash issues. More reading is necessary. My concern is if you end up with a tiny error to get the division position then unless you can return exactly to the start position each time round increases the error. This is tiny but as I said more study is called for. I am sure your right but I have to have a better grasp on this yet.

                                          Chris

                                          #484611
                                          Emgee
                                          Participant
                                            @emgee

                                            Chris

                                            As others have said only rotate the table in 1 direction, you don't then have to worry about backlash. Same with the cnc table, only rotate in 1 direction.

                                            If when using your manual rotary table you go past where you you should have stopped, rotate backwards way past the desired stop point and then rotate slowly to the desired position, that way backlash is always taken up in the same direction.

                                            If your table is very free to move and you have any backlash always apply at least 1 table lock before drilling. (edit)

                                            Emgee

                                            Edited By Emgee on 08/07/2020 18:22:12

                                            #484762
                                            Chris TickTock
                                            Participant
                                              @christicktock
                                              Posted by Emgee on 08/07/2020 18:18:39:

                                              Chris

                                              As others have said only rotate the table in 1 direction, you don't then have to worry about backlash. Same with the cnc table, only rotate in 1 direction.

                                              If when using your manual rotary table you go past where you you should have stopped, rotate backwards way past the desired stop point and then rotate slowly to the desired position, that way backlash is always taken up in the same direction.

                                              If your table is very free to move and you have any backlash always apply at least 1 table lock before drilling. (edit)

                                              Emgee

                                              Edited By Emgee on 08/07/2020 18:22:12

                                              Appreciate your post Emgee and will swot up on the instructions soon.

                                              Chris

                                              #484898
                                              Chris TickTock
                                              Participant
                                                @christicktock

                                                Hi, it really is a revelation just how involved drilling a hole can be if you want it fairly precise.

                                                Does anyone have a clear idea of whether a single point is a 4 facet drill which is a split point drill. The idea of this drill if my understanding is right is to replace the flat chisel part prone to wander on a standard drill with an additional 2 edges . Thus there are 4 edges which act as one cutting edge and if the drill is a stub and fully ground should make a precise hole. The included angle is 135 degrees which implies a 90 degree spot drill may be counter productive as the drill would foul on the walls.

                                                But my main question is is a split point drill bit the same (or could be) that referred to a single point drill?

                                                Chris

                                                #484904
                                                Hopper
                                                Participant
                                                  @hopper

                                                  I've never heard of a double point drill. So they'd all be single point to me. 

                                                  Either way, for a 3mm drill, you will get best result by centre drilling first if accurate location is the goal. Even a split point can wander easily on a thin flexible drill bit. Remember, it is only a perfectly ground point the first time you use it to drill a hole. After that, it's a worn point.

                                                   

                                                  Edited By Hopper on 10/07/2020 13:59:36

                                                  #484912
                                                  SillyOldDuffer
                                                  Moderator
                                                    @sillyoldduffer
                                                    Posted by Chris TickTock on 10/07/2020 13:25:49:

                                                    Hi, it really is a revelation just how involved drilling a hole can be if you want it fairly precise.

                                                    Does anyone have a clear idea of whether a single point is a 4 facet drill which is a split point drill. The idea of this drill if my understanding is right is to replace the flat chisel part prone to wander on a standard drill with an additional 2 edges . Thus there are 4 edges which act as one cutting edge and if the drill is a stub and fully ground should make a precise hole. The included angle is 135 degrees which implies a 90 degree spot drill may be counter productive as the drill would foul on the walls.

                                                    But my main question is is a split point drill bit the same (or could be) that referred to a single point drill?

                                                    Chris

                                                    The 'single point' terminology has me confused, but twist drills are a confusing subject. I believe all twist drills are single point drills, as opposed to augers, saw toothed hole drills, and other configurations. Could be wrong.

                                                    Twist drills wander for several reasons, many of which are down to the operator. Allowing the flutes to choke with swarf, cutting too hard with a sharp drill, forcing a blunt drill, rpm too slow, or a poorly shaped drill can all cause trouble. Deep holes, more than 4 to 6x diameter, are more likely to wander than shallow ones. Hand drills always wander in my experience, pillar drills much less, and mills better again. A lathe is best of all because the work is rotating, hence prefer a lathe when straightness is important.

                                                    Drills tips are shaped to optimise performance for particular purposes. Rounded tips are preferred when breaking through sheet metal. Square tips for flat bottomed holes. Angles to suit Brass, fast metal removal, or whatever. As the flutes can also be optimised for different purposes there's a bewildering variety of drills to choose from.

                                                    As life is too short, I use general purpose 118° drills, sometimes started with a centre punch, more often with a centre drill. I'm happy to believe spot drills are better, just not tried them yet. What centre and spot drills have in common is being short and stiff, just what's needed to get a general purpose drill going in the right direction. General purpose drills are cheap to make, easy to resharpen, OK with hard and soft materials, fairly stiff, with decently wide flutes for ejecting swarf, and although inclined to grab and tear on exit, they aren't vicious. A good compromise drill, but in some circumstances it's worth sending for a specialist.

                                                    I think Chris is describing the type of drill where the chisel end is ground in either a sort of S shape or 'split point' to extend the drill's cutting edge closer to the centre, which improves the drill's self centring properties. They're more expensive and wear faster than general purpose drills.

                                                    135°drills are preferred for harder materials.

                                                    Most of time I find all that's needed is a decent accurately placed hole sufficient to allow an ordinary 118° drill to make a good start. Once going correctly it will do the job. This is provided I frequently clear swarf, lubricate, and take care to cut at a sensible speed and pressure. Overdoing it always causes a wander.

                                                    The 'decent accurately placed hole' can be made with a centre punch or a centre drill. I do most of my drilling with a mill and prefer a centre drill accurately aimed with a DRO. However, if the hole is non-critical, I often don't bother starting it – I just go straight at it with the drill. I think it works because a milling machine puts the drill accurately at a right angle to the firmly clamped work and is able to make its own all important first start. Curiously drilling in a lathe always seems to need a starting hole because the drill can be seen skidding about on its chisel before. engaging. I may be doing it wrong…

                                                    Dave

                                                     

                                                    Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 10/07/2020 15:30:56

                                                    #484917
                                                    John Baron
                                                    Participant
                                                      @johnbaron31275

                                                      Hi Guys,

                                                      Since I made a four facet drill grinder and started regrinding my drills with it, there is no way that I would go back to using conically ground ones. Apart from being self centring the force required is much reduced which is an advantage with thin small diameter drills.

                                                      One point I've not seen mentioned is a drill ground off centre will drill an oversize hole and is more likely to wander.

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up