Carriage movement varies along the bed

Advert

Carriage movement varies along the bed

Home Forums Beginners questions Carriage movement varies along the bed

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #467508
    Cai
    Participant
      @cai

      Hi,

      I've noticed that there is some variability in the carriage movement along my lathes bed (Myford ML7). I.e. the carriage is slightly stiffer towards the end of the bed and is slightly relaxed towards the chuck end of the bed.

      I'm very new to lathes, so I may be completely wrong but thought that the carriage should be able to move uniformly across the entire bed. The issue is that I can feel the carriage move a little bit when working on a piece of metal. In my mind, the carriage should be totally steadfast all the time and should not move a milimeter unless the user moves the carriage intentionally. Could anyone shine any light on this issue? I was under the impression that the lathe had been exceptionally well restored.

      Advert
      #10196
      Cai
      Participant
        @cai
        #467528
        not done it yet
        Participant
          @notdoneityet

          It would appear that the bed and/or carriage is worn. Perhaps your impression was unfounded?

          #467529
          Thor 🇳🇴
          Participant
            @thor

            Hi Cai,

            I agree, to me it seems that the bed is worn. On a lathe the carriage is most often used close to the chuck so the bed at that end gets more use and wear. The carriage should ,of course, move along the bed but not at 90 deg. to the bed, is that the case on your lathe?

            Thor

            #467534
            larry phelan 1
            Participant
              @larryphelan1

              I think Thor, that might have been just a slip of the finger, I,m sure Cai did mean along the bed, not across it.

              #467545
              Lee Rogers
              Participant
                @leerogers95060

                So . How do you get around the problem without a complete re grind of the bed . First it may not be as bad as you think because you may not use all of the bed that often. Set the gibs while close in to the chuck and live with it. Also if your not using the leadscrew to feed, lock the carriage and any other motion your not using for the cut. There is info out there on the correct measurements of the 7 bed, have a look and compare to yours . ML 7s are notorious for being subject to paint-pot restorations and that's why imports are so popular.

                #467547
                Nigel McBurney 1
                Participant
                  @nigelmcburney1

                  When taking facing cuts the saddle /carriage will move away from the work due to the cutting pressure on the tool,To avoid saddle movemnt the saddle lock should be used, on a Myford the lock is the hex bolt head at the rear right of the saddle,just lightly tighten with a spanner. When taking intermittent cuts its always adviseable to use the saddle lock. On every lathe it is possible to take a very light facing cut of a bar (brass or al alloy)as there is a certain amount of weight in the saddle and sufficient friction to prevent the saddle moving. Another method when quickly facing off the end of a bar is to hold the saddle travel handwheel firm in the right hand and face off with the left hand. When facing large diameters its usual practice to use the saddle lock.

                  #467549
                  ega
                  Participant
                    @ega

                    Cai:

                    I believe you describe the classic symptoms of a worn bed. It is also worth bearing in mind that the saddle gib strip is not positively restrained laterally which can lead to alternate tightening and loosening caused by the ends of the adjusting screws riding up the dimple in the gib.

                    Once your bed is dealt with this phenomenon can be prevented by dowelling the gib to the apron. The procedure is very well described in GHT's Workshop Manual (by reference to the topslide where the same idea applies).

                    #467550
                    Jouke van der Veen
                    Participant
                      @joukevanderveen72935

                      Could it also be wear of the leadscrew? The leadscrew is mor used close to the chuck than to the tailstock.

                      The leadscrew nut may not evenly move along the the total length.

                      My experience is that when you properly adjust the leadscrew nut close to the chuck then the nut will move stiff on the leadscrew close to the tailstock. And of cause the opposite if you adjust the nut close to the tailstock.

                      Regards,

                      Jouke

                      #467556
                      Bazyle
                      Participant
                        @bazyle
                        Posted by Cai on 27/04/2020 22:55:47: I was under the impression that the lathe had been exceptionally well restored.

                        'Restore' is ebay speak for wire brush and repaint which is what is done for 90% of 'restorations'. Most older lathes have this movement and you just learn to live with it. As said above adjust the settings at the area of the bed you are using as most things you make are only a couple of inches long.

                        One of the things to be aware of is when you have taken a cut and want to move the saddle back to start another cut the slack causes the tool to move closer to the work on this return journey, spoiling your finish. So you must move the tool away from the material remembering the position the dial. Also be aware that if you do this and make 3 cuts at the same setting you may still be taking off material even though you think it should have taken it all off at the first cut. There are several reasons for this not related to the wear on the lathe so don't be alarmed.

                        I suggest you read every thread on the forum to do with lathes made this year as you will learn a lot as almost every problem has already been mentioned along with suggestions of further reading.

                        #467569
                        Jouke van der Veen
                        Participant
                          @joukevanderveen72935
                          Posted by Jouke van der Veen on 28/04/2020 09:10:17:

                          Could it also be wear of the leadscrew? The leadscrew is mor used close to the chuck than to the tailstock.

                          The leadscrew nut may not evenly move along the the total length.

                          My experience is that when you properly adjust the leadscrew nut close to the chuck then the nut will move stiff on the leadscrew close to the tailstock. And of course the opposite if you adjust the nut close to the tailstock.

                          Regards,

                          Jouke

                          What I said about adjusting the leadscrew nut close to the tailstock can not be true. Then you may expect slack close to the chuck, of course.

                          #467573
                          Dave Halford
                          Participant
                            @davehalford22513

                            Are you referring to the saddle mounted wheel or the bed wheel being 'stiffer?

                            The saddle wheel runs on the rack and any change in stiffness will be only the bed wear.

                            #467614
                            Cai
                            Participant
                              @cai

                              Thanks for all the replies. I removed the saddle earlier and adjusted the two hex bolts that control the gib strip. I gave the bolts a very, very small turn to tighten (Less than 1/16th of a rotation) whilst the carriage was closer to the chuck and it operated nicely i.e. not too stiff and not loose enough to move due to cutting pressure on the tool. It's like this for about two thirds the length of the bed. However the last third of the bed (on the tail stock side) is stiffer again.

                              The carriage is not engaged on the lead screw when I'm working on the lathe alot of the time, so I don't think that's the cause of the issue but may be worth checking anyway.

                              It's the wheel on the apron that I am using to move carriage along the bed.

                              I don't think the wear is bad enough to warrant regrinding the lathe bed just yet…so locking the saddle/carriage sounds like a reasonable solution to maintain a good level of precision.

                              Does anyone know whether the gip strip itself can cause wear to the underside of the lathe bed? My worry is that a regrind might create a nice flat surface for the top of the lathe bed but the underneath, where the gip strip sits could also wear?

                              #467617
                              Dave Halford
                              Participant
                                @davehalford22513
                                Posted by Cai on 28/04/2020 12:28:31:

                                Does anyone know whether the gip strip itself can cause wear to the underside of the lathe bed? My worry is that a regrind might create a nice flat surface for the top of the lathe bed but the underneath, where the gip strip sits could also wear?

                                Yes.

                                Have you checked the tailstock height? that wears the bed and the bottom of the stock casting.

                                #467619
                                David Davies 8
                                Participant
                                  @daviddavies8

                                  Cai

                                  the gib strip is on the side of the carriage and adjusted with four screws which are fitted with locknuts. I believe what you refer to as being underneath is the retaining plate which is adjusted with shims.

                                  Pinning the gib strip as suggested above by ega will stop it riding up on the points of the adjusting screws which will reduce the running clearance.

                                  HTH

                                  Dave

                                  #467633
                                  KWIL
                                  Participant
                                    @kwil

                                    The under side retaining plate is shimmed to give a nominal clearance, they should never touch such that any drag is possible. In use the pressure is downwards mainly onto the top of the shears only.

                                    Check the shears with a micrometer, front to back and top to underside, these measurements will show where the wear is as set out in previous postings.

                                    If a bed is reground, the carriage also needs to be done to match (reason – top of shear to leadscrew centre is reduced by grinding the bed)

                                    #467636
                                    Dave Halford
                                    Participant
                                      @davehalford22513

                                      I think the turning downward pressure is on the front shear, the rear of the carriage tends to lift.

                                      #467641
                                      Howard Lewis
                                      Participant
                                        @howardlewis46836

                                        A guess would be that, if adjusting the gibs bearing on the front face of the front shear, results in the Saddle being acceptable at the Chuck end, but tight at the Tailstock end, some very careful scraping at the Tailstock end, MIGHT improve matters.

                                        How much needs to be removed will be shown by the measurements already suggested.

                                        BUT remember that once removed, the metal cannot put on again as neatly as it was before you attacked it!

                                        Howard

                                        #467692
                                        Grizzly bear
                                        Participant
                                          @grizzlybear

                                          Cai, your ML7 condition may seem a mega problem.

                                          What do you intend to make with your lathe?

                                          My ML7 has exactly the same problem, in fact for the last 45 years. I've learnt to live with, it will still turn out good work. I'm not into model making. It's used for home maintenance and various hobbies like electronics, guns, gardens & welding.

                                          Good luck,

                                          Bear..

                                          #467696
                                          old mart
                                          Participant
                                            @oldmart

                                            The wear in the bed of the museum's Smart & Brown model A is so great that I opted to have the saddle extremely tight at the last three inches at the right hand end. It doesn't get used there often.

                                          Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
                                          • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                          Advert

                                          Latest Replies

                                          Home Forums Beginners questions Topics

                                          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                          Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                          View full reply list.

                                          Advert

                                          Newsletter Sign-up